[QUOTE=John Mace]
Maybe I’m extrapolating from two small a sample, but my Italian friends (actual Italians, not Italian-Americans) always told me one way you could tell the American tourists is that they’d eat gelato while walking in the street. No well mannered Italian would do that, I was told. It was also a swipe at Americans’ antziness-- they can’t just sit and relax in a cafe to eat like you’re supposed to.
[/quote]
You mean an outdoor cafe in a public square of the type found all over Italy? That’s public eating, John, which your mate Kass would regard as appalling and crass.
7 years ago? What is this, some sort of bizarre discontinuity principal by which someone who, in his late fifties/early sixties, expresses certain views very strongly (in a book, not in a bar over a beer) should not be assumed to still hold those views seven years later? That is just stoopid.
[QUOTE=John Mace]
I don’t get it. What was the context of his writing this? So, the guy has an old-fashioned sense of manners. Eating while walking on the streets is commonly looked down on as borish American behavior by lots of Europeans, btw. I don’t get what the bid deal is. Did he say this was going to be at the top of his agenda when he started his tenure on the bioethics committee? It looks like this quote goes back to 1999, btw.
[/QUOTE]
Read the whole quote. The guy has extreme views on propriety, out of all touch with modern western behaviour and thought, and he is put on an ethics committee. Ethicists don’t have some hotline to a god, or handbook based on unarguable logic from which they can obtain answers to difficult ethical dilemmas. They just make judgment calls.
As Tuckerfan points out, it is quite clear from the passage quoted in his cite that Kass is the type of guy to whom the whole concept of “IMHO” would be alien. He is a guy who Knows what is Right and Wrong, namely what he thinks is right and wrong.
What seems right and wrong to this dickhead is most definitely out of touch. He is kind enough to make us “aware” that there’s a problem with eating a sandwich, or biting an apple. His reasoning? It’s what an animal would do. An animal also breathes. Should we be “embarrassed” and try to cover that too?
This guy has serious issues with his own body. That is entirely relevant to his fitness to be on a medical ethics committee.
Would you put Hannibal Lector on your menu committee?