Weekly Comic Book Discussion Thread 12/28/2006

Looks like folks are still away for the holidays so I’ll get things started.

Detective Comics #827: Wonderful. When the Ventriloquist got knocked off in Robinson’s OYL debut, I was commiserating on the loss of my favorite minor baddie on another board with another poster I eventually noted that it was easy enough to bring Scarface back, he’s the attraction after all, not Wesker. I even said that I’d have the new Ventriloquist be better at it, and drop the G’s for B’s, which I’ve always found annoying. The other person suggested making the new one a woman. Looks like we both got our wish. Anyway, I’m loving it. Scarface is a favorite, but the only time I’ve seen him taken at all seriously is in the Animated Series. Makes sense then that Dini would be the one to bring him back and make him proud. I especially love the twisted dynamic of this relationship.

Astonishing X-Men #19: I’m of the opinion that when the X-Men deal with aliens and the like, they fall away from the core concepts that make the team work. That said, the plotting and character work here is very strong.

52 Week Thirty-Four: Still going strong. I like that Waller is stealing a play directly from Brother Eye (although Brother I never meant for WW to kill anyone), and Luthor’s increasing bitterness. Even without Superman to kick him around, he’s still a miserable SOB.

The Flash the Fastest Man Alive #7: Oh ick. And it was going so strongly too. LA? Kadabra as a petty crook? Come on guys.

**Blue Beetle #10: ** This is just good fun. Killer monkeys, misunderstandings leading to fights between heroes, Jaime using the armor creatively instead of having it do all the work. Good stuff.

Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes #25: Wait, Ultra-Boy is among the Legionnaires most likely to play along? Really? I did like Brainy’s insane scheme for shutting down the shields.

Batman #661: All filler, plus Grotesk turns out to be the most obvious suspect anyway. Not great.

Superman/Batman #31: Ick. Just, ick. There’s reaching back into the past of the characters for ideas to mine, and then there’s just wanking to the stuff only the most hardcore fans would even recognize. When Zook and Ultra the Multi-Alien appear as anything other than a background character, it’s the latter. Really guys, Zook?

Justice #9: Oh, now I get it. This is a toy commercial. They’re going to try and sell me those armors in action figures, aren’t they?

Justice League of America #5: It’s so full of good ideas, but so poorly executed. I like everything in here, but the pacing is so awful. There’s also a really poor bit of logic here: A superhero’s wife was killed by another superhero’s ex-wife using super-weapons. Solution: give all the wives super-weapons. Not that a ridiculously powered blaster would have saved Sue anyway, given her mode of death. But it’s forgivable, since I’ve seen many people IRL try to use this or similar reasoning.

I like the new Ventriloquist too, which surprised me because I HATED Wesker.

Is anyone else reading the Connor Hawke miniseries? I’m liking it so far, but I’m a giant dork for all Green Arrow-related things and I’m super thrilled to see Shado after a 15-year absence. Finally, Ollie’s going to find out he has yet another kid he never knew about!

Does anyone know what e-mail address I should use to send a request for more Secret Six? They solicited such feedback at the end of the last issue, but didn’t say how to send the message. Semaphore? Skywriting?

I just picked up Larry Gonick’s The Cartoon History Of The Modern World, the third installment in his graphic novel History Of The World series.

As always, Gonick is witty, well-researched & opinionated.

Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs & Steel gets a nice mention. Several allusions to recent events in the Middle East are made.

Altogether, it lives up to or exceeds the first two volumes.

Larry Gonick would make a fine Doper, IMHO.

Telepathy? :smiley:

LOL. It’s about time. But I’m boycotting comics altogether until they give Cryll his own series.

Dues I kid you not, when I went on wensday to check out the new comics, everything I wanted (Astoning X-men and JLA) were sold out. So I just assumed they were late (again). SOon as I saw this thread I grabed my coat and told my boss I’d be back in 20 minutes. Best coffee break evar! :smiley:

Thanks for kicking it off, Menocchio.

I picked up Annihilation #5, because of something I’ve heard will happen in #6 - It’s really not bad, and I kinda wished I followed along before - isn’t Kl’rt supposed to be dead?

Ultimate FF lumbers along - I’m going to tough it out until the next arc to see if things pick up.

Black Panther - picked it up for Civil War tie-in goodness, and wow. I’d heard the writer had a kind of reverse racism thing going on, but dayumn.

Civil War : Choosing Sides - Howard the Duck’s triumphant return to Marvel comics.

NextWave - the solicit for this month’s cover was what made me start buying the book. Sadly, the story inside is a bit sparse in this outing.

Guy Gardner : Collateral Damage #2 - Bleh. Moving along as fast as possible…

Hawkgirl - Looks like we may soon finally resolve Hawkman’s fate, between this book, JSA, and JSA Classified… then I can drop this book.

Connor Hawke : Dragon’s Blood - Yes, I am reading this miniseries, and I like it so far. No Speedy? Or Ollie? Or Cissie? Or Merlyn? Tch. Other than that, I like.

Lessee, what else -

Batman : We’re not quite done with Grotesk yet, and I suspect there may be a twist left - we’ll see.

Detective : Damn good.

Flash : Keeps running away from what made the previous version successful.

Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters : Miss America, F*** Yeah!

Blue Beetle : I’m not sure it’s New Genesis they’re on - I think the Forever People had a planet of their own…

Supergirl : Powerboy amuses me. Love the vaguely sinister panel.

JSA Classified : Ahh, so it wasn’t who they would have us believe it was. This, I think, is a good new villain.

Superman/Batman : Nice to see Ultra, but… paced for the trade, and painfully so.

I love, love, love my local comics store, but they always sell out so quickly :frowning: What’s happening in the latest?

I’m certain it’s not, since Lonar says ‘[t]his planet is surely unknown save to those of New Genesis’ which is not how it would be phrased if it was New Genesis.

I’m relatively happy with Raphael Albuquerque’s art, so far. I’d still rather Hamner was staying on the book, but it’s not so bad if RA can keep up the quality of work he did on this issue.

Guy Gardner #2: The buildup of the previous issue promised that we’d see Gardner’s usefulness as the bad cop you call in an emergency, the necessary evil, the monster who gets the job done. This issue, we just saw the screwup who did a worse job than any conceivable other GL except for G’Nort. Well, Chaykin makes a dandy fashion illustrator, but not much else of benefit here.

Also: If the rings are sentient and have moral awareness, why do they need hosts with less of each than the actual rings have? Could a GL ring and the Helmet of Nabu serve as each other’s host consciousness?

Justice League of America #5: We’re about to discover two things about Vixen:

She doesn’t need the Totem anymore, and her powers and Amazo’s cancel each other out.

Uncle Sam and the Freedom Fighters - My biggest reactions to this issue: 1) Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray are in my head - I was thinking new versions of Red Bee and Invisible Hood would be cool for about a year now. 2) The Celestials exist in the DCU. And they work for SHADE.

On Supernova–what do you get when you compress a White Dwarf Star?

And, who in the DC U keeps a fragment of White Dwarf Star in his belt?

Initials R.P. may be the man to watch.

They continue to struggle at Trade Paperback pace with the machinations of Thanos.

And Bosda - old news, my man. Didn’t I mention Palmer as a favorite in one of the past two discussions? :wink:

Finishing up - Justice rocks my socks; Supergirl and the Legion also rocks my socks, but in a different way. Nice cover switcheroo from the solicit on JLA, glad to see the big guns doing something…

52 : Well, that was a short-lived new character. And the Question seems poised to endure into the New Year, at least a little…

Jack of Fables : Feels like filler, but it amuses.