Weird Sandwiches I Have Known

In My Humble Opinion
1

I knew a kid whose favorite two sandwiches were

  1. Peanut butter and sauerkraut

and

  1. Peanut butter and butter.

He used to speak longingly of peanut butter and sauerkraut, and I finally realized that his mother stopped making it because it was just too gross to countenance. He had a younger brother who sensibly passed on the above two choices, preferring the hearty crunchiness of…

Peanut butter and white sugar.
My wife used to take care of her younger brothers when she was growing up, and often sated their juvenile hunger with…a butter and sugar sandwich. Sort of a third-rate doughnut, I guess.

Anyone else enjoy weird sandwiches?

2

liver sausage on cinnimon (SP?) raisin bread.

3

What’s with the peanutbutter weirdness?

I went rafting with a guy who went on and on about the virtues of peanutbutter and pickle sandwiches. I thought he was joking until he had one for lunch.

I have been known to eat beef jerky & cream cheese sandwiches. Once.

4

I have made myself a PBButter sandwich on occasion, and also a PBApple. And I also put butter and sugar on white bread (open-faced) for an after-school snack.

5

I have a favorite weird sandwich spread: Smoky Hill green salsa, local stuff made with smoked green jalapeños… [drool] mmmmmm…[/drool] …goes great with turkey and muenster…

Damn, we’re out!

6

Cheddar cheese and dill pickle with mayo, on white.

Peanut butter and cheese.

7

Peanut butter and butter.

Peanut butter, butter and banana.

Peanut butter and salami.

Peanut butter, green olives and Vidalia onions.

And of course peanut butter and Spam, Spam, Spam.

8

My dad told me about one of his childhood faves.

Very lean raw ground beef, a pinch of salt, and a heaping helping of fresh horseradish.

Mix all together, refrigerate overnight. Spread on sliced bread, wheat or rye.

I tried it, years ago. Odd, but surprisingly tasty. Wouldn’t try it today, though.

9

What was that one Ally Sheedy made in Breakfast Club? Butter, pixie sticks, and either Captain Crunch or Bugles?

My weirdest was cream cheese and grape jelly.

10

Peanut butter and bacon.

11

Peanut butter and sweet pickle relish.

Peanut butter and chow chow (mild, of course).

On whole wheat, naturally. Any other bread is just wrong.

12

I used to take a jelly and margarine sandwich to school everyday. All the other kids laughed at my lunch, but they were eating macaroni and “meat” sauce.

13

I used to take a jelly and margarine sandwich to school everyday. All the other kids laughed at my lunch, but they were eating macaroni and “meat” sauce.

14

My favourite: Processed cheese, deli turkey, Pringles pizza-flavoured chips, and pickled green tomatoes. On white toast. With mustard.

15

a sad by product of living in a fundie Xtian commune as a child:

Cold boiled chicken skin sandwiches on government bread with salt and pepper, butter if we were lucky, some of the canned Kraft Mac Cheese sauce if we were Powerball lucky.

16

Two slices of white bread with tons of butter and stuffed with mashed potatoes.

17

Peanut Butter, Miracle Whip and Lettuce. (actually quite tasty) From the same Grandmother that puts Cranberry Sauce on her Turkey sandwiches. :confused:

18

When I was a poor white child us kids would occasionally eat mayonnaise sandwiches. Mayo on white.

19

My peanut butter/sauerkraut friend did also enjoy peanut butter and pickles. Must have been the salty/sour combination. That’s one taste I could never stand - reminds me of puke.

My cousin liked peanut butter and cheese, as mentioned by at least one poster.

The post about the Pringles chips jogged my memory of eating potato chips on pizza in the school cafeteria. We also used to make a sandwich out of the spaghetti and Italian bread they served every week. Mmmm…school cafeteria spaghetti sandwich…

20

My favorite sandwich was mustard and butter on white bread.