Do not underestimate me. I thought we were past my blow up this game.
NAF had a post after the time limit passed.
Given how Gastardly this game is going, I want to make sure we know what we can know. I would like to know about NAF ASAP.
–
**Related:
Working on my “We are all Town” theory: Is there any MAFIA Variant where ““Ghosts”” have posting access to a scum board, and or, can vote in NKs ? **
Right O.
Not getting answers on Win Cons, am I ?
Okay, first impressions…
No vig kill. This tells us that there is no compulsory vig, probably.
SpEd was VT. Looking back over Day 1, he was highly critical of the cases on both Tom Scud and BSPI. He stood on a few toes in doing this (Joey, Alka and probably others - I’ll admit that I’m being hasty with my rereads of his posts).
FS is VT. Spent most of Day 1 defending Tom’s conclusions. Didn’t point the finger much.
Other then the whole not revealing until AM, I’m not sure what you mean by Gastardly. I don’t think you understand that term.
I’m looking forward to the next longish post of what you were going to say.
No, you didn’t. You hopped from person to person with the last person being the scummiest one you saw.
True, at the start I would have guessed that you were town, as time went on that thought has changed. 
I look forward to a better explanation.
Don’t be a twerp. NAF posted that gigantic post (which probably took him 20 minutes to prep) something like 4 minutes after the end of day post. The anti-strategy rules aren’t intended to make a ‘gotcha’ situation.
Pleonast’s Conspiracy Mafia allowed the Witches (a pro-town group) to communicate even after death, and to vote on their targets. Why do you think it’s pertinant?
Why wouldn’t I be?
Me too. 
I think you are reading me wrong Cat, but then I would say that wouldn’t I.
Oh, the post after time thing. Meh, I would hope that the mod would tell us if he modkilled someone. I would especially hope that he would tell me if I was the person he killed.
Okay, so we have Freudian Slit as a townie, and Special Ed nightkilled.
From the way things played out, I think we can guess that there may well be powers that can act on people during the night after their death, and not revealing the alignment of a lynchee immediately may be intended to make those powers more hazardous to use. Alternately, it could affect the scum powers somewhat.
I don’t see anything about the way the deaths have played out that gives me any reasons to change my suspicions yet. Vote Cucuy.
Meeko advice corner! I wouldn’t assume there’s anything terribly Gastardly about the game until we get concrete evidence thereof–Mahaloth, after all, is not Idle Thoughts. (watch the latter appear now that I’ve taken his name in vain).
So, assuming this is true: why all the mentions of the Crimson Thorns? Are they a distraction, or what? And who do you think did the nightly killings? Vigilante? SK?
I was going to respond to the “what if there are no scum” question, but then decided that it really is a silly conversation to even have.
So…what does everyone feel about a mass claim? I don’t think we brought that one up yesterDay.
(and yeah, I really would like to go though the end of yesterDay again and post my catchup thoughts, but I don’t know if I will be able to in the next few hours. But I left off right before Storyteller’s big post, so I know where to start up again. And it might be time to start looking at some of those pages I refferenced earlier in the game too. See who did what now that we know who Ed and FS are.)
Geeze, NAF I was kinda hoping you would put up some defense but basically all you’ve got is “wasn’t me but then I could be scum”. I think I’m going to continue my vote from yesterday that case is looking better with such a week defense.
Vote NAF
Just the Opposite Boozy, I’m with you, I am not asking for his death, at all. I just noticed, that on the face of it, he did post after the time limit. And, given that factually, it was after the limit, the question had to be asked.
Just lingering thoughts from F.S. delay in alignment notification.
I saw posted elsewhere, and will respond here ::
I highly doubt that set up would present itself.
All I know, is that this Mafia game has been the most… unusual I have ever played. Period.
So far the only unusual feature from my viewpoint is the delayed reveal of the deceased’s identity, and that’s not all that odd–it certainly happens in variations elsewhere (such as “only certain people can investigate corpses” or “the identity isn’t given out expressly, just clues in their possessions/personal effects”).
Can you characterize more fully the events/situations in the game structure that have struck you as unusual?
Snipped, and bolding added.
Zeriel, I noticed this too. I assume you mean to reference the “X is 100% Dead” verbiage?
I find that to be strange as well.
Does anyone else care to jump in on “” 100% Dead “” ?
**
I would ask Mahaloth,** but not only is he not answering me, he’s not even saying that he’s not answering me.
No, no. You named them all. That and the actual default of not talking at night.
Just for my third game of Mafia, the first to have both of these rules in effect, it is making for, a learning curve, from Glyph and LOST.
I’m not saying I have added information. I don’t. I am just making a baseline observation here, based on this game, on my entire (2 games) MAFIA experience.
Ok. Granted I was wrong with LOST on mass claiming. However::
I am not sure there is a canon here, per se. That is to say, there is no real yardstick to measure the Claims to.
What does claiming now gain for Town? ***
FOS NAF for even asking.
Defense? Against what?
I think he’s wrong in reading what I had to say. Would you like me to dig up posts where I said I was changing my mind?
This is a bullshit vote my friend.
For asking what people’s opinions are? You have to be more specific here buddy.