Weird Wild West Mafia/Werewolf/Psychopath

Ok, something else worth thinking about.

Looking back at the No Kill on Night 2, the following occured.

Nanook self protected
Oredigger77 blocked JoeyP

This means either the scum hit Nanook or Oredigger picked the right scum killer that Night. Given that we had several outed power roles by that point, the fact there was no Night kill is quite a data point.

Admittedly the scum would have preferred to take out the doc or the investigator but that still left a couple worth taking out instead which should have been just as good. Instead they either ventured into the unknown pool and hit the right one or they got stopped instead. Also with their own investigator, they had a good chance of narrowing down the pool further.

I think I know which occured that night.

And so to a WoW on pedescribe.

fluff
#21, #29, #76, #98, #417, #425, #452, #603, #867, #938, #1043, #1128

#145: Comment on vigilante kills, also mentions scum strongman
#146: Mentions Bartender, Prostitutes, General Store owner–an inventor, perhaps?
#181: Response to Meeko
#182: Comment no editing, case against cucay and BS, P.I.'s votes
#219, #222: Comment on Meeko’s vote
#420: Defends defence of BS, P.I., comment on Meeko not being unintelligeble
#426: WoW on Freudian Slit and casts vote on FS.
#511: Response to Meeko
#521: votes meeko saying his PM was specific. PS: for note, I got one line, no wincon
#526: Response to NAF that power roles about power roles having a different wincon
#532: comment on PMs + handshaking
#551: response to Meeko justifying votes
#552, #583: refuses to handshake on PM
#598: Accepts Meeko’s claim about PM and unvotes
#601: response to meeko about outed poweroles.
#606: response to meeko
#611: comment handshaking and roles
#657: WoW on Allwalker. Fniods it unlikely that Oredigger, Squid and Allwalker would be scum
#667: votes joeyp to break tie saying he was suspicious for a while
#671: says he will switch to oredigger as the tie up was v. scummy.
#673: Switches vote after joeyP.
#675: Vote count shows oredigger to be lynched
#682, #683: Comment on condeming mentalguy as well as creating a tie
#820, #821, #822: votes storyteller following claim
#823: Is sure we can discount possibility of governer and scotsman scum
#824: comment on naf’s failed attempt to daykill storyteller
#825, #826, #827, #828: comments on storytellers claims
#850: Comment on bomb role
#861: Comment about detective and day vig going after storyteller
#882: Comment about surviving lynch in a suite of powers, while possible is unlikely for storyteller
#890: Says we can consider oredigger a town roleblocker or scum non-roleblocker
#977: comment to oredigger
#979: trusts sherrif votes uscdiver
#997: questions to mod
#1005: Is suspicious of Oredigger again, thinks he may be a third party cultist type role.
#1008: doubts oredigger is scum, just not town
#1019, #1027, #1030: comment against oredigger
#1113, says we have 4 CTs no third party. Says oredigger is town, says cucay is possibly scum investigator, says NAF is a power role and likely townie because of lynch stop.
#1115: says naf is unlikely to be scum because of claimed power.
#1132, #1133, #1145: responses about end of day 2 lynch
Well, what to say other than telegraphing NAF1138’s role through a lot of his posts.

I had sex last night, or so I Was told. And an IRL job interview today, man, I must be doing something right.

You know what, looking back over it, the more I begin to think NAF1138 is more likely to be scum than JoeyP. I reckon he has not only a Scum Strongman power in amongst his box of tricks but also the Governer ability to buy a vote as well.

But not both at the same time, so if he survives today, I would strongly suggest OreDigger blocks him overNight.

**unvote JoeyP

vote NAF1138**

I suppose I ought to WoW on NAF1138, but too many things are pointing scum in his direction.

Between my Interview (Not sure if I told this game about my Interview today) and the other game, I completely forgot that it was Day over here. Forgot about the game entirely, actually.

Anyway. I’ve been watched and sexed, you guys know me to be Vanilla now. [ Not sure anyone ever bought my “for all you know” gambit. Oh well.

I wanted to comment that you could have sexed Allwalker, and take the post earlier where I was watched, to save Allwalker [I knew nothing about him, just, I felt it was waste to block me. when it was more or less already stated by someone else, that I was vanilla.] But it was already Night.
Anyway. My interview is today at 1 pm EST. Im actually typing now as I am getting ready. [I am taking my time so as to not be that rushed. Obviously, I have some down time right now, hence I am here.]
All of that to say, I am busy today. Just as good, I am vanilla. I think we are close to a Victory. [Or a Loss. Pure math will get us soon enough, right?]

I hope we are not at Gas Water and Electric with the state our game is in now. Hopefully those with power(s) can figure out the Town Victory. [Gas Water and Electric is the name of a classic brainteaser, that, IIRC, does not, and can not have a legit, correct, answer to the question as posed.]

<oog>
Meeko, put the game down.

Go and concentrate on your interview, there will be plenty of time for when you get back.

And best of luck.

</oog>

I will just go ahead and say this, because it does no good being unsaid.

Anyone else surprised that Cucuy is still around? I would have thought he would have been dead by now. He has verified his claim how many game days ago?

But but, but, I can still get my ““fix”” from this game, I didn’t tell this game I would be gone. :smiley:
But yeah. Stoked about the job, and frankly, the start of my life. [If you think about it.]

Why are you surprised? Did you have a reason for me to NOT be here?

Sorry for being absent, I’ve been out in the wilderness and my phone had 1 bar. I got NO RESULTS for my investigation last Night. I assume I was too afraid to leave the house— part of my role as Wimpy Sheriff is to actually be Wimpy. :o

We’re starting to run out of time to react to whatever cucuy’s investigation reveals. If he found scum we’re pretty locked up so I think we need to start discussing what to do if he found town.

I don’t think NAF is town, I think he’s third party. Although we’ve only seen one of his powers work it’s enough that I believe he power claims. But we don’t need to eliminate third parties to win so I don’t think we should worry about him.

I wouldn’t think that we have more then two scum remaining so we’ve got some time until LYLO. I think that verifying the people that cucuy has investigated is the most important thing we can do. If will give us two live confirmed town (remember I’m assuming his investigation comes up town) of which we will at least have one remaining toMorrow to direct us. Having confirmed town will be extremely beneficial so we don’t run into you want to lynch our X you must be scum.

Well, that’ll teach me not to preview. At least we now know what your failures look like. Since the scum blocker is dead and I was with Meeko I think it’s safe to assume that was a fail.

I’m going to have to think about this for a bit I’ll be back after lunch.

bleached
Ok Cat.

For the record you are at the top of my scum list right now.

I can buy votes. I can Day kill, and I can stop the lynch. I can stop the lynch more than once. Now, you may think that I am lying. That’s fine. It’s a hell of a lie. I have also now pushed hard for the lynch of, not one, but two Crimson Thorns. And you see this and think to yourself, “Huh, he’s probably scum.” Really?

So, I’ll risk getting lynched toDay and getting Night Killed, I think I have probably done the most useful things I can with my powers. I am going to buy your vote. Oh, and I am going to vote for you too.

vote CIAS

There may be truth in that, but why waste his power on Scum then? If you’re basing you suspicions on his Daytime hit on Z [that Z was VT and easy to kill], we didn’t have reason not to suspect Z was CT. And because my investigation of you last night showed no results doesn’t mean you are in the clear either. As a result of yesterDay and last Night, we now have 3 dead VT and 1 dead VT. Whoever MHaye watched is unknown since he’s dead. The only person with a successful Night action was Boozy, and unfortunately he took out a VT.

If NAF is CT with all the powers he claims at his disposal, that would make for a vety unbalanced game. I’m going with the assumption that he is Town.

And despite my lack of results for last Night, I’ll vote the same.

vote CatInASuit

Mod, disregard the votes in my quote!
grumble grumble damn near edited my post

If I am top of your scum list NAF1138, why don’t you just Day Kill me and move onto lynching someone else?

Would love to know how I suddenly jumped to the top though?

Underline mine, hold on, you can stop the lynch more than once. That’s overpowered for any game, especially with all your other powers and means that if true, you probably cannot be killed before the end of this game given the numbers left.

Excuse me while I hold your cape. :rolleyes:

Oh no, I’m not basing it on him taking out Zeriel.

I’m basing it on pedescribe pretty much describing his role through out the game from Day 1 onwards before he would have had a chance to scum investigate him.

And if he was so powerful, why haven’t the scum taken him out yet. He’s that powerful and massive role against the scum and they picked MHaye? WTF?

Can’t Day kill anymore. I used that power twice already.

You jumped to the top because you are a claimed VT and I think that there has to be one more CT in the VT pool, and because you are ignoring my posting history in the game in an attempt to get me lynched. So, yeah, that one is a bit personal and maybe just the tiniest bit OMGUS, but there you have it.

Re your next post, I agree, my role is terribly over powered, but that doesn’t mean that Maha knew that when he put the game together. But have you ever known me to lie so outrageously about stuff? That isn’t really my MO. I’m not Roosh I tend to go for the believable lies rooted in truth when I am scum.

Once that we know of.

I’m certainly not ignoring pedescribe’s and storyteller’s posting history though. I guess my only chance for survival today is to do a WoW on you and see what drops out. I;m not looking forward to that you have been prolific in this game.

There is a first time for everything :stuck_out_tongue:

So let’s see your claimed power list then

Can Day Kill twice (once that we have seen)
Can stop the Lynch at least twice (allegedly, I think you can stop it once)
Can Self Protect once ?
Can Watch at Night ?
Can Buy Vote

How would SIR likes his shoes shined?