**unvote NAF1138
vote CatInASuit
**
Surprise, surprise. :rolleyes:
I generally like a mirror shine on my shoes, thanks. 
I can self protect more than once. I can stop the lynch only twice. I can Day kill twice. I was once able to track (not watch). I can buy a vote, at least twice!
I know. I know. Honestly I am surprised that I didn’t die last Night. It makes me worry that my plan sucked and that the claimed power roles are full of CT. But, I think we can at least risk the one mislynch if it turns out I was wrong about you Cat.
Let me rephrase part of that last post. I once was able to track, not watch, but no longer can. I don’t want anyone to get confused and think I was saying I could only do it once.
Once NAF tells me what I am doing today, I will let you guys know.
[[There is LITERALLY no point in vanillas still playing.]]
Ok. Sure. Meeko, vote for CIAS.
Also, while you may feel that there is no point in vanilla’s still playing, you are wrong.
Go try and figure out which, if any, of the claimed power roles is most likely to be lying.
Oh fiddlesticks. I went back over my WoW on pedescribe and he didn’t start going on about multiple powers and so on until Day 3, which would have been after he would have had a chance to investigate NAF1138.
NAF1138, I can think of one reason why you are alive and not MHaye, despite your multiple abilties and that is because there was a small possibility MHaye would see the killer going out at Night when they should have been doing nothing instead, whereas you would have been doing nothing if you were town because you had used a power that Day.
I still think the remaining scum are between NAF1138 and JoeyP though and my lynch today is definitely a mislynch, although you are right in that you have at least one spare, even if there are two scum remaining and they only have standard Nightkills.
Ok NAF1138, never mind the waste of a mislynch. You control my vote. I want you to justify it. Why me, and not either Meeko or JoeyP?
No OMGUS, no personal stuff, I want to see good solid reasoning on your thoughts to my actions.
That is not true at all. We’ve reached a point where the powers don’t really matter because we are out of observable powers it comes down to who you trust. I think at least one and probably two of our power roles are scum and we need to figure out who. The only power that could figure this out is cucuy but we don’t know if he is scum or not.
If you want to limit the game to us power roles trying to figure out which of the power roles is scum that fine but you still need to figure out who you’re going to vote with because that will allow them the votes they need to eliminate the other roles but you still have an important role.
I don’t like this at all.
** vote: NAF1138 **
Hoestly? You were farther down on my list until Zeriel and AllWalker came up town. You put together the case against Pede, and it was a damn good case. You had him dead to rights as scum. In normal situations that would have been enough for me to give you a pass for now. But, I am having a slightly difficult time seeing how you can see me as playing pro scum at any turn in this game, and frankly I would expect more solid reasoning from you. This worries me.
So where we are now, pro town point in your favor, the lynch of Pede. Pro scum points in your favor, being one of three in the vanilla pool, the very bad case against me. Additional pro scum point in your favor, your position durring the mental guy lynch.
Why not Meeko? Because of a) his being blocked by Digger last Night and yet there was still a kill. There may well be two CT’s left, but still it’s a point in his favor town wise. b) Because of what seems to be genuine frustration with being a vanilla townie. He might be faking it, but it seems fairly real to me. I would think if he were scum he would be trying to hold back and hide the frustration that scum must be feeling right now.
Why not Joey? Because there have been too many signposts pointing to not Joey so far this game. If you turn up town I will be calling for his head first tomorrow.
Now. Of the power roles who do I think are most likely to be scum. I would say Boozy, cucuy, Digger, in that order. With Digger being least likely to be scum IMO, because of the whole double role blocker thing, cucuy being number 2 because, even though he has been playing a fairly pro town game his investigations have come up short when they counted. That could easily be bad luck, and I think his general play has been pro town this game with very little crossover into proscum territory.
Boozy is a close run thing with you and Joey, partly because Boozy gives me scummy vibes like crazy most games, and partly because he just voted for me even after saying he doesn’t believe that a Day kill can be a balanced thing on the scum side.
So, yeah, I would say You, Joey, and Boozy are my picks for the group most likely to contain scum. Right now you are on top mostly because I expect more from you. That might be totally unfair to you, but that’s how it goes. Sucks to have my respect doesn’t it?
**Vote Count:
NAF(1): Boozahol
CatInASuit(3): NAF, Cucuy, CatInASuit**
Sorry, NAF. Hate to do it to you like that, but I’m just feeling a little ram-rodded right here about the lynch of Cat. You’re using one of your one-use powers in order to ensure the lynch of Cat in a situation that shouldn’t be LyLo, doesn’t need that much convincing of the Town to push through…
And that makes me think that we actually are at LyLo, and you’re a little overeager to get this thing done with. As in, you’re scum, and losing one more Townie, along with not having a Doc (and our one-shot Vig being depleted) means that if we lynch ole’ Kitty, the Town is toast.
**NAF1138 **- you may have bought my vote, but you cannot keep me quiet. 
First: what are the signposts that don’t point at JoeyP and does that mean you have ignored the huge data point from Night 2. Your comments about why I am scummy are fair, ditto those for Meeko. But your handwaving for JoeyP is not acceptable.
Second: Consistent voting for scum does not automatically make you town, see Storyteller in M2. BTW, your vote on MentalGuy on D2 was a really, really safe vote. I am basing my position on your play in the game and that of the other players, not your claimed powers.
Three: I could be wrong and we are at LoL today. If we have seven players and 2 CT left, it could go like this. Mislynch today + NK tonight leaves us with 5 players and 2 CT. If NAF1138 stops the lynch tomorrow as he may do if he decides to, then the following NK would leave us at 2 town and 2 CT which equals a scum win.
In a really horrible way, the best play for the town today is actually to lynch NAF1138 regardless of whether he is town or not precisely because he has a lynch stop power. It will be LoL for the next 2 days assuming 2 CT, but is possible to survive. Add NAF1138 in and it really skews it towards the town. If NAF1138 is scum, then we have to lynch him now or we lose the game.
Four: Your list of possible scum makes no sense at all. Especially in reference to Boozy. And it all relates to boozy and cucay and in particular the Night 1 confirmation that occured which you seem to have forgotten
If cucay is town, then Boozy is town. Night 1 confirmation.
If Cucay is scum, then Boozy is either town or scum. But this can only occur if cucay is scum.
Regardless of the fact, it also means that if you think Boozy is scum, you are likely to try and lead the town to a loss by trying to clear out the vanilla pool.
Of course, there is one final reason why everyone should be voting you. You are a liar.
Hey, it’s all in the hands of the rest of the town, but you are scum to the core.
Oh one last thing for the town to ponder.
AllWalker being blocked by Oredigger got a wonderful night of passion
I suddenly felt really odd, knocked out and brainwashed and it wasn’t pleasant.
But then it could just be colour text, right.
Right?
I had forgotten about this and it pretty much settles it for me. With 7 people left we can get two confirmed town by lynching cucuy or scum. Two confirmed town would leave us with and unconfirmed pool of 4 of which two are likely scum with a possible third party in there. I think we will gain more information from shrinking the pool the scum can hide in then by hoping that cucuy is town and has a successful investigation.
I thought I remembered this but when I went to look I couldn’t find it. My take is that NAF probably doesn’t have the lynch stopping power which is why he is inconsistent. But I think just based on what we’ve seen his powers are way out of wack with both the scum and town sides and is more then likely third party. I think we should let the scum deal with him.
I’m not sure what you’re trying to say here are you blaming me for something or are you trying to compare the message I give out with my blocks to the message you got with your vote being bought?
Ramrodding, with a single extra vote? Sorry, I don’t see it.
Damn, forgot to include my vote:
Vote Cucuy
Who was your second day-Kill?
I linked the two posts. It’s right there.
Yup, comparison between good time girl Oredigger and not so good time knockout drops NAF1138.
Also, if you lynch cucay today, and he is town you get a confirmed pool of precisely one. Boozy - because he could confirm the role. I am treating all VT reads as basically godfather at this point. If he confirms more power roles and then dies to be revealed as town, our confirmed pool will then grow.