We're, all of us, superfans of Babymetal, yes?

I mean, how in the heck could the discerning listener not be?

Never heard of him.

Same here. But thanks for the link, I need more exposure to pop culture. Interesting music. Not my cup of tea, but there seem to be real talent there.

I can never really be sure if the Japanese are making fun of us or not.

Sorry, is there a reason we’re using the singular masculine to refer to a band fronted by 3 japanese female teenagers?

I’m disappointed. I thought it was going to be actual babies.

90 seconds in, I was hoping to be Rickrolled.

I feel the same way. If the fans are sincere it is in the very least incredibly unusual.

I never heard of them, but I just watched the video and in answer to your question I can safely say no.

I’m sure that lots of kids like it, and that the young guys like the cute girls, but it’s forgettable generic idol J-pop with metal pretensions.

That is hilarious - laying down a blanket of rapid-fire, double-kick metal so you can put cute girly-pop on top of it.

They ain’t Shonen Knife, that’s for sure :wink:

Can’t view YouTube at work.

Enough with the rigid gender roles, gramps!

I should add that I’m slightly embarrassed that I’m at all familiar with terms like idol and J-pop. It’s just internet osmosis, I suppose. Spend enough time online and you soak up all kinds of unwanted crap.

Just like porn, it was better with the sound off.

First I was confused, then delighted, then curious, then a little thirsty.

I am not sure if I like like it but I am intrigued enough to find more.

I like it. It took me a while to figure that out, though.

For some reason I want to like it. I can’t say why, but I want to.

But I just don’t. It’s sounds like something done by someone who thinks they understand metal but don’t. Like a slick corporate engineered version of metal by someone following an algorithm or something. Then they took the results and threw in some cutesy j-pop and, for the cherry on top, used auto-tune for the vocals. I almost always hate autotune.

It’s too fake and overproduced. There’s no heart to it. Are those girls even the ones singing?

To me you’ve described its charm to a T.

Well that was a pretty bad song. You could have at least given us a song. This at least doesn’t sound like something someone threw together as a joke.

Youtubers React to Baby Metal