The rules for this thread are simple. Pick 5 states that you really like in any order for any reason. The only ones that are disqualified for you personally are any ones that you grew up in, currently live in or lived in other than for incidental reasons like college attendance.
I will go first:
New Hampshire
Vermont
Colorado
Texas
North Carolina
I like them all for different reasons. New Hampshire and Vermont would have my heart forever if they could just find a way to heat those states with solar arrays during the endless winter months.
I despise Arizona politically…but I love to visit that state! The scenic wonders are beautiful beyond all belief. The Phoenix Zoo is a sterling zoo (and from a San Diegan, that’s saying something!) Flagstaff is a lovely town, and I could happily live there.
For the same reasons, New Mexico and Utah. I visit now and then, and love playing tourist there.
I have abstract admiration for New York and Massachussetts, but I haven’t actually visited either.
I ranked New Hampshire as my #1 overall but that is really sad you can’t find 4 other states to like. You could always default to Hawaii or Alaska (for very different reasons) if you had to.
I am fortunate enough that I’ve been to most of the states and found something great about each. But top 5:
Utah, it’s beautiful
South Carolina, embodies the feeling of being in The South
Washington, enjoyed Seattle & also the time in the wilder spaces
Missouri, remember trout fishing there w/ grandpa
Number 5 is tough, but I’ll say Georgia for its mountainous parts.
New York State --Even though my recent trip was a bit dull, it was lovely. And as my fourth trip to the state* (which has included most of the landmark stuff in NYC AND just interesting things around the state) I do love visiting it. I don’t want to move there, but I do like it.
California --I’ve visited all over the state from SF to San Diego. Even Fresno. Which I liked b/c of the Forestiere Underground Gardens. I liked LA when I visited even! I’d go again. (It reminded me of Houston.)
Washington State --I haven’t been there in years, but I visited a bit after grunge was a thing and just before the Portlandia years and I found the wilderness/coasts parts incredibly beautiful.
New Mexico --The roads blow. Seriously, drive over the border from to TX to NM and you can immediately tell. Gorgeous state and there’s a hot spring place I’m trying to nudge The Fella to take me again for my birthday.
For five, I guess I’ll pick Louisiana. I’ve been there a lot in the past several years and it’s a good place with good people.
My fifth visit–we went there when I was like two/three.
Utah (bought a house in Cedar City in 2002 for my retirement, but lost it during the Great Slight Economic Turndown when I couldn’t keep up mortgage payments)
Arizona
Alaska
Maine (the only Eastern state I have visited, and the fall colors were unbefornicatinglylievable.
Oregon
These are all states I’ve visited and like for scenery, romance (in the broad sense), history, climate etc. No politics, religion or the like come into it. These are in no particular order.
Utah
Michigan (and the Great Lakes area in general)
California
Colorado
New Mexico