What celebrity would you go gay (or straight) for?

I don’t know about going gay, but I’ve certainly felt an attraction to certain male actors. Not a sexually-horny attraction, but a wow, he’s so hot attraction. Like the aforementioned Fight Club-era Brad Pitt (even the Thelma and Louise-era Pitt, which is the first occurrence of this realization), George Clooney in Ocean’s Twelve, Pierce Brosnan in The Thomas Crown Affair, and the guy that came to fix the gas leak in our basement recently*. Holy crap, that guy was handsome.

*Yeah, I know. He’s not a celebrity. But he should be.

Russell Crowe. He would make me wet. If I was a chick. Especially if he threw a phone at someone because he was trying to call me and they wouldnt freaking connect him!

No one’s ever gotten crazy for me before so I go for that.

Good… Lord… Erm… Thanks for introducing me to her…

I’ll be in my bunk!
Although, to the topic… I think I’m like a few other posters. I can definately appreciate a good-looking, attractive man, but I can’t envision changing my sexual preferences for one.

Yeah, I’m kinda in that boat. I do have guy-crushes, however, for early-day William Holden and Glenn Ford, and a guy-voice-crush for Dick Haymes (singing or speaking, doesn’t matter). All suave, earnest, magnetic, wore clothes well, and had great hair.

Ed Harris, I’m not quite sure why, It just is.

I vaguely recall one of the board’s gay guys years ago saying that the scene of Rebecca de Mornay in Risky Business standing at the window sill while the wind blew her skirt all around her face left him thinking that if he did go straight, it would be for her. “Are you ready for me? Ralph?”

I love Jodie, but I can’t quite agree that she’s THE most beautiful woman in the world (that’s likely Monica Bellucci). That said, if you’re not in love with JF, there is something wrong with you and you should immediately see a doctor.

I can’t quite imagine actually going gay for her, but I do think Natalie Portman is the hottest little thing since the birth of the sun.

Off topic, but as a guy, I fully agree with this statement.

That’s who I’d go for.

Also - Claudia Black. Rrrrrrowrrr.

Wouldn’t go so far as to have sex, but would stare in slack-jawed appreciation of Catherine Zeta-Jones’ gorgeousness, and would want to hit a few bars with the Marlene Dietrich of the 1940’s.

My GF knows I’d go gay for Mathew McConnaghey; I think the story about him being arrested while high, naked and playing the bongo drums in his house is what cemented the deal.

Beyoncé Knowles or Shakira. That music video they have together, ‘‘Beautiful Liar’’ makes me want to jump them both. If 1 is totally straight and 10 is totally gay, I’m like a 3. But Jesus help me, those women are fiiine. I’d do 'em just for the bragging rights.

Rosario Dawson, Winona Ryder. Maybe Jennifer Garner.

I’d go straight for Charlize Theron or Bernadette Peters.

I’d stay gay for Hugh Laurie or Adrian Brody.

You’ll have to wrestle me for her. :slight_smile: I’ve always said I don’t know if I want to be her, do her, or devour her with a spoon. Nigella Lawson. Holy smokes, that woman. Her cookbooks are really entertaining, too – she writes with such charm. sigh Love her.

I can’t forget Twin Peaks-era Sherilyn Fenn. That scene where she turns up naked in Cooper’s bed? Ohhh, Cooper, bless your heart. I would not have been such a gentlman. (Lady. Whatever.)

The “Crying Game” actor had me going…

I’m about a 2 on a scale of 1- 10, and my tastes would be situational–never saw a guy in a movie/on tv and felt anything.

Since we’re adding disclaimers…I’m a pure Kinsey 6 and would never actually go straight for any of those women. Jodie Foster is still totally hot though.

Tina Fey . Actually, there are several (I’m not exactly 100% straight), but Tina Fey makes me absolutely crazy. My boyfriend likes her too; she’d probably be pretty weirded out if she knew how often she stars in our little games. Oh,Tina , how I love you!

(I added pictures for anyone who doubts she’s the most fuckable woman alive)

Dear People Magazine:

I have the best idea ever for a new annual Top 50 list…