What happens after Trump?

I’m afraid that part of the party was irrevocably destroyed.

I don’t feel Donald Trump or the magas are in control of the Republican party. They’re just the clown show the party is using to distract attention from the real agenda.

The real agenda is to take control of the election process so the Republican party gets to choose who gets to vote, what votes get counted, and, most importantly, who gets elected. The Republicans are planning on becoming a permanent majority. The Democrats will still be around and there will still be the illusions of elections being held but the Republicans will be deciding the outcomes before any votes are cast.

Once they’ve finished this process, they’ll have no further need for maga voters or for any other popular movement. Who will hold office will be decided in back rooms before the votes are cast and the elections will just be a formality.

You mean after the partying and dancing in the streets?

They are the chrome dog on the front of the Mack truck.

More like the truck nuts on the coal rolling diesel dually if you ask me.

Can you unpack this a little bit? Because it sounds a bit like a conspiracy theory. I’m not saying that there aren’t powerful Republicans trying to make use of the distracting chaos. I’m saying that I don’t believe the chaos is part of the plan, or at all under the party’s control, or that there’s any one in control in the party other than Trumpists: initially out of expediency, but now…?

It’s not a conspiracy theory, it’s an actual documented conspiracy.

Lots of documentation.

Though I think it’s more accurate to say MAGA is in charge of the Republicans but also do so at the behest of someone else.

My point though is that those people pulling the strings aren’t at all interested in compromising with Democrats.

Trump has been ignoring the laws Congress passed, and spending money Congress did not appropriate, for more than twenty months. I can’t 100 percent rule out this changing. But I think it would take some psychiatric or neurological event, either in the brain of Donald Trump, or the collective brains of the Republicans on SCOTUS, rather than a change in the composition of Congress.

It will publicize the corruption already uncovered by mainstream journalists.

Next year? The way I would phrase it is that Democrats on the internet will criticize those they unfairly regard as the establishment for not doing the impossible.

There probably will be situations where Democrats seek to jail a Trump official for contempt of congress. Two problems. One is that, historically, the penalty may be something on the order of a few weeks of house arrest. If we get that far, vengeance seeking progressives will fume when precedent is followed. But we probably will not get that far. It takes cooperation from the Justice Department to do the physical arrest, and Trump’s Justice Department will refuse. Are there loads of progressives who would criticize Jefferies and Schumer for failure to do what is obviously impossible? We’ll see.

Yeah, I always had almost the exact opposite feeling as well.

Here’s what it looks like to me.

The Tea Party revs up around 2009, and looks like and is treated like a bunch of cranks, but the party as a whole pays lip service to them.

Fast forward a few years, and the Tea Party has managed to worm its way into the GOP, and then Trump captivates all those folks and they basically become MAGA. I never saw much difference between the Tea Party types and the MAGA types, except for the red hats and the anger.

So with that in mind, they and the party followed Trump, Pied-Piper style. Most Republican politicians fell into three basic categories: 1. Those old-line Republicans who didn’t love the Tea Party, MAGA, or Trump, but who went along to a greater or lesser degree because they wanted to remain relevant, and now feel like they’ve got the tiger by the tail. 2. Those who LOVED the Tea Party, Trump, and MAGA, and compete to outdo each other with more absurd Trumpian garbage. And finally, group 3 who were the opportunists who glommed onto the MAGA train hoping to use it for personal gain, without letting something like principles get in the way. These are the Ted Cruzes of the GOP- politicians with naked cynical self-interest and no principles. There’s a lot of overlap -I’d count McConnell as a blend of 1 and 3, and someone like Mike Johnson as more of a mix of 1 and 2, for example.

So right now, MAGA is directing the GOP, but not all the politicians are 100% on board. Most (I feel) are either such opportunists that they just don’t care, as long as they come out on top, or they’re reluctantly on board because they can’t bear (after all this!) to be associated with Democrats.

I also feel like the Project 2025 and Heritage Foundation people are basically using the MAGA phenomenon for their own purposes, but they didn’t necessarily engineer it. More of a happy accident from their perspective, and they’re trying to make hay while the sun is shining, so to speak.

This is why the GOP leadership outside of Trump seems so shambolic- without him, you’ve got multiple groups pulling in different directions- the old-liners are going to want to return to the status quo ante Tea Party, the MAGA/Tea Party types are trying to pull as hard as possible to the far Right as they possibly can, and the opportunists are trying to figure out which horse to bet on.

So without a firm hand at the wheel, things start to meander and get a bit weird, which is what we’re seeing right now prior to the anticipated mid-term beatdown. We get people like Karl Rove slithering out of the ooze to decry Ken Paxton and Trump, and Tucker Carlson speaking out against Trump, MAGA, and the Iran War.

That description is marvellous, and seems to capture it for me.

Post-Trump, I think a lot of your Group #1 are going to want to slam the lid down on #2; #3 will be the decisive factor there, but they’re waiting to see which way the winds are blowing.

I would put both Rubio and Vance firmly into camp #3. I suspect that the party will line up behind Rubio, because he’ll be a way to transition away from Trumpism with some legitimate continuity, but they can sacrifice Vance to simultaneously symbolize a clean break, because who needs logical consistency.

Trump is a destroyer of trust. He’s not able to do what he does when people trust others/institutions, so he must destroy it and he’s very effective at destroying trust in others/institutions.

So hopefully what happens next is we can learn to trust others and institutions. I think that’s the core of what holds any democracy, or shared collective, or whatever we have, together. Can’t work without it.

That just means putting party aside and seeking out and voting for trustworthy people regardless of their politics. Build those kinds of people up.

Late: Just saw that I posted in June re: "We usually get an opposite/let’s reset/go back to normal…after an authoritarian President. Nixon - Carter; Bush - Obama; Trump - Biden; Trump - ?"…Here that would mean a trustworthy person like Carter/Obama/Biden. Much less important if they are effective or not.

I agree. Rubio seems like the least tainted old guard Republican still active, and he’s by far the most likeable. Cruz is just odious in every way, and Vance is too far up the Trump administration’s butt to ever extricate himself from it.

That’s an excellent point. The nation as a whole needs to rebuild trust in the government, in our fellow man, and just in general. I’m thinking Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address is very pertinent advice here, especially in light of the acrimony on both sides. All these calls to “remove the GOP as a political party” and “Republicans should never be allowed to serve” from aggrieved people on the Left are not only silly, they’re counterproductive. There’s no practical or possible way to do that without becoming as bad or worse than they are, so we need to learn how to work together. Which in that context means restoring confidence in the government, its institutions, and its leaders as a primary goal, and then from there, working on bipartisanship as much as possible. Hopefully the post-Trump GOP will see the utility of this and won’t be as relentlessly and needlessly partisan as they’ve been in the past, because that sort of attitude will just keep the hostility stoked.

That just means submission to the Republicans, since that’s the only kind of “working together” they ever accept. Give them everything, in return for nothing, and then be bashed by them for it.

In order to accomplish anything the Democrats will need to at the very least sideline the Right and render it incapable of stopping them. Not convince them, not compromise with them, not bribe them; force them to submit or work around them somehow. Those are the only methods that have ever worked for longer than the nation has existed. Every bit of progress in society has been accomplished against their adamantine, lifelong resistance.

The first problem with that with that is that right wing politics make people untrustworthy. The second problem is that the Republicans are fully dominated by the MAGA extremists and con artists; “putting the party aside” is one of those noble sounding goals that can’t possibly work.

It’s certainly possible for people to eventually be so fed up with the party that it ceases to be able to make headway and vanishes. Saying that it’s impossible is ignoring history; strong political parties (who elected presidents) have gone. This country wasn’t founded with Republicans and Democrats. It’s ironic to invoke Lincoln, because the Republicans weren’t even around until his time.

Now, is it likely? I don’t know, probably not. Not likely any time in the immediate future, I don’t think. It might at least take a generation. And I don’t know that it would make things better. Even if Republicans were to be swept away instantly with a magic wand, you’d likely see a split in the Democratic Party and the end result might look very similar to what we have now. And it’s not really the party itself that’s the problem; it’s their tactics and dangerous rhetoric. The Republican Party of today isn’t really much like the party of Lincoln’s time, nor is the Democratic Party. Parties change.

I think the likeliest good scenario would be a Republican Party dwindling in power, forced to change their tactics immensely. Distance themselves from Trump and much of what they have been trying to do and say. Give up on attacking democracy and try to actually win with real ideas that might help, even if the Democrats disagree. Find a way to appeal to younger people and independents, which means backing away from radicalism. I don’t know how likely that is, but I would like to think it’s not completely improbable, in time.

That’s just ridiculous. And stupid as well.

A HUGE segment of the population are Republican. Any efforts to disenfranchise them or deliberately cripple their party is not going to go well.

This isn’t de-Nazification after WWII, not without another Civil War. And our own experience with this sort of thing is STILL biting us in the ass 150-160 years later, after Radical Reconstruction.

So we’re going to have to learn how to work with them. As much as that frightens people, it’s a fact.

And even if the Democrats were to sweep the midterms, it’s still an idiotic idea. If that were to happen, the voters are voting with something in mind, and I would argue it’s likely something economic, not partisan politics and anti-GOP.

True. What I was saying is that there’s no practical or possible way to get rid of the Republican Party in the short term, which is what a bunch of the more silly and foolish people on the Left are suggesting. And furthermore, any attempts to do so would probably be met with a LOT of resistance, as almost certainly that’s not what anyone voted for.

Agreed, that certainly can’t happen.

re: putting party aside/vote for people instead

First, you only need a majority to win. So you just need to get a marginal amount of people to do this.

Second, it’s already happening today. There are Trump voters who will not be voting for their R Senator/Congressman in the midterm. The reason is they are turned off by the R candidate, and are not turned off by the D candidate. That’s putting party aside and at least not standing in the way of the better/trustworthy candidate.

Third, most importantly, you just have to believe it can be done and then it can be done.

I just wanted to mention that even if the Dems win both houses, Trump will rule by XO and SCOTUS under Roberts will support that. The Dems will investigate out the wazoo, maybe a few impeachments which will go nowhere in the Senate. Even if they win the Trifecta in 2028, they will still have end the filibuster to accomplish anything.

About 40% of the time, it seems to me, SCOTUS rules against trump.

No, it’s an impossibility. We submit, we resist, or we flee the country; there’s no fourth option. The Right never accepts anything other than total submission. Not ever. That’s why the Civil War happened.

True, it’s de-MAGAfication of the GOP. I would say the Democrats should reject working with any member of the GOP who won’t answer one simple question with a yes, “Did Joe Biden win the Presidential election in 2020?” Anyone serving in Congress who fails to say yes to that question is a traitor to the country, plain and simple.

I do think there are Republicans who Democrats could work with but they have to demonstrate they are in touch with reality before they are worth cooperating with. Sadly, I expect the majority will take the position of “screw the Democrats and blame them for everything that doesn’t go well”.