What is funny about this joke?

Here’s a joke I used to hear when I was a kid. It’s the stupidest joke I’ve ever heard: unfunny, weird, rambling, and obtuse. Here it is:

A man got a letter, but he couldn’t read it because it was written in German. So he took the letter with him on the bus, and asked the bus driver to read it. The bus driver had blue hair. He said, “sorry, I can’t read this.” So the guy gets off the bus takes the letter to a policeman, and asks him to read it. The policeman has orange hair. He says, “sorry, I can’t read this.” So the guy walks down the street to a store, and asks the storekeeper to read the letter. The storekeeper’s hair was yellow, “the color of snot (one of the details I remember from the joke.)” He says, “sorry, I can’t read this, but my Lawyer can speak German so take it to him.” So the guy finds the Lawyer and takes it to him, and the Lawyer throws the letter into the fire.

Ha ! Ha ! Get it?

Yeah, that’s what I thought.

Has anyone else heard this joke, and if so, what the hell is funny about it?

Well, I haven’t heard this exact joke, but I’ve heard some like it. You know - long, rambling, you’re itching for the teller to finish the stupid thing already, huge build up and then…

bleh.

The actually content isn’t the joke - it’s the absurd buildup for the non-existant punch line that’s supposed to be funny.

Meh.

That there is what you call a shaggy dog story.

Alcohol helps. :smiley:

I should probably be embarassed to admit that I love a series of shaggy-dogs that end up actually being one big long shaggy dog (where the details from the first tale end up being relevant in the fifth.)

Okay, here’s a couple of my favourites – (Although they don’t translate into this medium at all, you can take them and torture whoever you like with 'em in meatspace.)

The pastor of a church in Nebraska went to open it for services one Sunday and horrified to find that it had burned down in the night. After his initial shock, he consoled himself with the knowledge that providence could be relied upon. Looking around the ruins, he noticed that the Bingo cage survived relatively intact, and felt his confidence returning. When his flock turned up in their finery, he met them with a brave face and told them of his plan to raise money for a new building materials by organizing a bingo night in the town hall, with donated prizes. Everyone agreed that this was a fine idea and and the plan was carried out. It was quite a success, and after only a single night, they had enough for a truckload of bricks and mortar. [NB - ideally, the story is drawn out to include several devastating misfortunes/rebuildings, with a three-little-pigs-like progression of building material, but I’m being lazy/merciful here) Plans were carefully drawn up, and so economically that each brick was accounted for. All the men donated their labour and in no time at all a beautiful new church was erected. As the pastor walked around the building, inspecting it with approval and pious gratitude, he noticed that one brick was left over. This surprised him, because he was sure that the plans had called for the exact number of bricks that they had at their disposal. He walked around the building again, looking for an empty space, but found none. At last, he shrugged, looked up, and threw the brick straight up.

Ha ha ha. Oh, you don’t get it? Never mind. Here’s another:

A man is flying from New York to California, after a long a tiring business trip. As he approaches his seat he is chagrined to find that the window seat is occupied by a pinched-looking woman holding a swaddled baby. He has a sinking feeling as he settles into his seat. As the plane takes off, the baby starts to cry. And cry. They reach their cruising altitude, and still the baby shows no sign of being consoled. Exasperated, the man resolves to put the baby out his mind altogether, and endeavours to relax. In aid of this aim, he produces a cigar from a box which one of his business associates had given him as a gift and begins to smoke. Immediately, the woman begins to make small sounds of disapproval, of which the man takes no heed. The baby, of course, continues to cry. As the blue, calming smoke encircles the man’s head, the woman slowly becomes more pop-eyed, and her mouth becomes a thin, twisted line. The man continues to enjoy his cigar, at last finding some peace. The woman begins clearing her throat ostentatiously. The man gently knocks his ash into the tray on the armrest between them and sighs contentedly. At last the woman can contain herself no longer and says, “Excuse me, but your cigar is irritating my baby.” The man looks at her sideways and asks, “What do you mean? Clearly the child was irritated from the start of the flight – it has nothing to do with me if he’s ill-tempered. At any rate, it’s almost finished.” Furious, the woman fumes while he finishes his cigar – and still the child cries, yet slightly harder as he senses his mother’s anger. Feeling satisfied and somewhat sedate after his smoke, the man sleeps for a while. He’s woken up some time later as the baby resumes its crying. Feeling foul temper creeping up on him, he tries to head it off with another cigar. Soon the soothing aroma of combusting nicotiana tabac is rising like incense. “Really,” exclaims the woman, “I don’t know how you can be so rude. You know that you’re irritating my baby. Listen to him crying!” “Lady,” replies the man, “you’ve got it backwards. You’re baby’s crying is irritating me. That’s why I’m smoking.” “Really! I’ve half a mind to throw that smelly thing out the window.” Now the man is beginning to get angry: “You try a thing like that,” he rumbles, “and I promise you I’ll throw that brat out after it.” Shocked, the woman grits her teeth and remains silent as the man continues to smoke, occasionally exhaling in her direction with a derisive fricative sound. Soon the cigar is finished, and miraculously the baby settles down. Again, the man begins to drowse, and finally to sleep the sleep of the just. Naturally, he is rudely awakened some time later by the infant’s renewed cries. He rubs his eyes, stretches, and reaches into the box for another cigar. No sooner does he have it lit, however, than the woman snaps completely. Shrilly, she says, “How can you possibly? The flight is only half-over, and you’re on your third fat cigar? My baby’s blanket positively reeks of it. Well, don’t say I didn’t warn you!” With that, she snatches the cigar from the man’s mouth, snaps the window open, and throws the cigar out. Not missing a beat, the man says, “Lady- when I make a promise, I keep it, and if you can’t put up with my cigar, I don’t see any reason I should tolerate your squalling kid.” He grabs the baby out of her lap, blanket and all, and heaves it out the window. But the amazing thing is this: When the plane lands at LAX, and the technicians went to de-ice the wings, what do you think they should find on the wing but the baby, right as rain? And the kicker… the kicker is… pardon me… (heh) what do you think the baby had in its mouth?

[narrator waits for sufferer to suggest “Uh… a cigar?”]

No! A brick.

previews

Curse you, TellMeI’mNotCrazy! :stuck_out_tongue:

(Obligatory, obnoxious plug: If you’re clever enough, you can find this story in Visual IRC 2.0’s hidden credits sequence, among other fabulous jokes and commentary. Well, are you?)

Joe woke up one day to find the head of a screw in his belly button. Naturally, he was scared. He’d never even heard of such a thing happening; what did it mean? Could he do anything about it? Was he going to die?

Joe figured a doctor would be the person to ask, so that day, he walked down to the clinic and had his doctor check it out.

The doctor looked at the screw. He prodded the screw with a pen. He sent Joe down to radiology to have X-rays taken. But after running every test he could think of, the doctor was still stumped. “Well,” said the doctor, “I have no idea what it means. I’ve never seen anything like it. It’s probably harmless, but just in case, you might want to have a mechanic give you a second opinion.”

So Joe went down the block to a mechanic. The mechanic looked at the screw. He measured it with calipers. He compared the screw to his toolsets. “You know,” said the mechanic, “it looks like a half-inch star bolt. I bet I could unscrew it.”

“Will it hurt?” said Joe.

“Probably,” said the mechanic. “But it’s all I can think of.”

The mechanic found a half-inch star driver and tried to remove the bolt. Joe writhed and screamed in pain, but the bolt wouldn’t budge! Finally the mechanic gave up: “I’ve done my best. Sorry.”

As Joe walked to the door, the mechanic had an idea. “You know, maybe someone put a curse on you! I know a witch doctor who lives at the top of a mountain across town. Ask him about it.”

So Joe hopped on the bus and rode across town to the mountain. After following a windy trail for several hours, he reached the top. Sure enough, a wrinkled old man was meditating there. Joe approached the witch doctor and showed him the bolt.

The shaman closed his eyes and sank deep into thought. A minute later, he opened his eyes and explained to Joe, “Here is what you must do, my son. There is an herb that only grows at the top of this mountain. Take it with you. Grind it into dust and mix it with water. Rub the paste onto your bolt. The full moon is tonight; let the first rays of moonlight strike it as you recite the words, ‘Rasha nisim vova meklek mashim rasha.’ Go now, you do not have much time.”

Joe certainly didn’t want to run out of time… he didn’t even want to think about what might happen if he was too late! He picked a handful of the herb, then ran as fast as he could down the twisting mountain path. There was no bus in sight, but the sun was almost about to set, so Joe hailed a cab to take him home.

Quickly, he ground up the herb and mixed it with water. He took off his shirt and rubbed the paste all over the head of the bolt. Then he ran to the window, where he could see the moon about to peek over the horizon. Joe began to recite the words: “Rasha nisim vova meklek mashim rasha.”

As he spoke, the moon rose ever so slightly above the horizon. The moonlight struck the bolt, and it began to turn. An eighth of a turn… then a quarter… half a turn… and then one full turn. The bolt popped out of Joe’s belly button, and suddenly…

…his ass fell off.

I never heard this story, but I’ve come accross some others which seem very similar in the principle to me. It’s not intended to be fun, but to make fun of the listeners
The joke has to be long, very long. And it has to contain a myserious detail that will make the listener curious (in the case of your joke the hair colour of the people and the content of the letter). So, they just want to know the end line (what is written on the letter, why have people wirdly colored hair). In the end it turns up that you’ll never know or that the answer is totally lame.
The two example I know of such stories :

-In the first a priest has a a green-skinned dwarf holding a blue bowling ball entering its church and killing all the attendance. It happens several times, until the priest decides to chase the dwarf down in order to know why he kills people in his church. After a long rambling, when they both have become old, he eventually find the dwarf and ask him. The old dwarf, lying on his deathbed, begins to answer and…dies in the middle of the sentence
-In the second one, when asked his job a draftee says he’s a gluger. The guy in charge of the draftees go to see the corporal and ask him what to do with the gluger. The corporal mocks him for not knowing what a gluger is, but of course don’t know, either. So he reports to the sargeant, who does the same, etc…(the whole thing taking a long time to tell). Eventually, the top level of the army/governement discovering they’ve enlisted the only gluger known, and nobody being willing to admit they don’t know what a gluger is, decides to use his talents and grant him a large budget. The story goes on again for a long time, with the gluger working in a workshop, and eventually announcing he’s done his job. Then he’s ceremoniously brought aboard a ship, at his request, bringing a mysterious packet. After some more rambling, he opens the packet which contains a black ball with a hole in it. He drops the ball in the ocean, and while sinking, it makes a “glug, glug, glug” sound . End of the story, which can easily take more than half an hour to tell.

Didn’t know that type of joke had a name. Here’s another…

One night, a man is driving down the road and just as he passes a large monastery, he gets a flat tire. It’s far too late to find a spare, so he knocks on the door of the monastery to ask for shelter until the next day when he can call for a mechanic. They are happy to provide a room for him and feed him, and everything is great. Except that just before he falls asleep, he hears a strange noise coming from the floor below. It’s not loud enough to be a real problem, but it’s a great curiosity, and he falls asleep wondering what could be making that sound. The next day, the monks ask, “How did you sleep?” and he tells them, “Just fine, thank you,” having forgotten entirely about the strange noise. He has a nice breakfast, thanks the monks, repairs the tire, and leaves. One day, some forty odd years later, the same man is driving down the same road, and again has car trouble. Same story [repeat several details here to add length] As he falls asleep, he hears the same noise and suddenly remembers hearing it in his youth. The next morning, he decides to ask what it was. “We can’t tell you,” the monks reply, “because you’re not a monk.” The man is curious, and happens to have a lot of time on his hands, so he says, “Okay then. How do I become a monk.” “You must search far and wide and count every blade of grass on the planet, and every grain of sand on the planet.” Fifty-seven years later, he is miraculously still alive, and returns to the monastery, to report his findings: “There are 923,103,203,381 blades of grass and 824,120,208,028,388,129 grains of sand on this earth.” The monks check their records, and tell him, “Yes. That is correct. You may now see the source of the sound. It is just behind this door.” They hand him an old rusty key. He opens the door, made of the finest oak wood, only to find… another door, this one made of pine. It is also locked, so they politely hand him the key. Behind it, there is another door, this time of intricate stained glass. Gradually, the sound seems to get louder and louder. Behind the glass door, there is a door made of concrete, securely locked. They give him the key and [he goes through as many doors as you can possibly invent as you tell it, each made of a different type of wood, stone, or other material]. Finally, after all these years, all these struggles and tasks and doors, he turns the jewel-studded silver handle, opens the great steel door, and sees it. There it is, the single, tiny object that was making that puzzling noise those nights he stayed at the monastery. There it was. But I can’t tell you what it was, because you’re not a monk.

This is exactly the one I was thinking of :smiley: How excellent!

Gets out magnifying glass and tweezers, and settles in for a long night on the beach

This one’s better suited to IMHO.

Off you go.

samclem GQ moderator

“Why did you do that?” says the man.

The lawyer replied : “I had to - the letter was an invoice … and my name is Bernadette.”

There are a couple I remember that were all long and drawn out like these, then had either a really stupid ending.

One was a story about this guy who was looking for the baby blue gorilla. Most of the story is about his journey trying to find the baby blue gorilla, then when he finds it sitting there in it’s cage sleeping, he touches it and it goes berserk, breaks out of the cage, and starts to chase him. It chases him back through every scene you had just described in the story, and finally catches up with the guy and has him cornered. The baby blue gorilla slowly approaches the guy with a wild, maniacle look on his face, ready for blood. He reaches out his hand, touches the guy on the shoulder and says…“Tag! You’re IT!”

The other one was basically just a long drawn out story that went on forever about a guy, but it ended with the guy running into this haunted house with a friend of his. The spirits in the house start making his friend kill himself with a razor blade, then they try to do the same thing to the guy, who just starts laughing. The more they try, the more the guy laughs, until the guy finally says…“That won’t work on me. I use Bic Safey Blades.”

Here’s my favorite shaggy dog. I’m not sure if it’s kosher to copy text from another user’s post, so I just used as link. It’s the very first post.

I’m not saying that alcohol doesn’t help, but I’m not so sure that really qualifies as a Shaggy Dog story. Aren’t shaggy dog stories supposed to be really long and end with a related, but comically understated, punchline? E.g., the shaggy dog story: Some guy has a shaggy dog and enters it in his local shaggy dog contest. Everybody is bowled over at how shaggy the dog is, heaping praise & encouragement on the man because this simply must be the shaggiest dog in the world. So he takes the dog to a series of competitions with the same results. Finally he gets to the world’s shaggy dog competition and the judge looks at the dog and says, “Meh, it’s not so shaggy.” Now fill that out with twenty minutes of quality acting and embellishment and you’ve got yourself a shaggy dog story.

The OP joke reminds me of one we told when were kids: A mouse and an elephant are sitting in a bath tub. The elephant says to the mouse, “Please pass me the soap,” and the mouse says, “What do you think I am, a typewriter?!” That’s the joke, but the real joke is that everybody but the person you’re telling it to breaks out laughing as though the joke were hilarious, and the person has no idea why everybody is laughing at this joke. Try it sometime. If you don’t have a joke handy, a copy of any Family Circus will do.

I heard a similar story when I was a teen. It goes something like this:

A man was reading one of those magazines and one of the letters to the editor mentions “purple passion.” The letter implies that it’s very erotic, but doesn’t describe what it is. So the man asks his wife, “Have you ever heard of ‘purple passion?’” She becomes enraged and slaps him so hard his ears ring and he gets a black eye. He goes to the store for some ice for his eye and the cashier asks him how it happened. He explains, but when he asks her about “purple passion,” she, too, angrily slaps him. Outside the store, a lady says she saw him get slapped, and wonders what happened. He explains, but once again, when he asks about “purple passion,” she punches him in the face. Now he’s hurting, bewildered, and more curious now than ever to know what “purple passion” is. But now he’s becoming afraid to ask. Then he spies a hooker on the street and goes up to her and tells her that he wants to ask a question and will pay her her usual fee if she’ll just answer without hitting him. She says, “OK, what’s the question?” He says, “All day, I’ve been trying to find out what ‘purple passion’ is, but any time I ask, I get slapped! WHAT IS IT??” She looks at him for a long time, then says, “OK, I’ll tell you, but not out here in public. We need to go back to my place.” He is hesitant, because he doesn’t want to be seen going off somewhere with a prostitute, but now he’s desperate to know, so he agrees. They step off the curb to cross the street–and they’re both struck and killed by a taxi.

Jokes that make you go :smack: .

The ending doesn’t have to be “related” at all – often it’s quite the contrary:

Although PaulFitzroy’s relation of the story is marked by a brevity that’s antithetical to the concept of a proper shaggy-dog, even in its condensed form the story bears the hallmarks of the genre: A repetitive structure with incidental details that vary slightly and have implied significance. Heck, it even matches the archetypical shaggy-dog story in that each person approached directs the protagonist: “you should show [the object] to ”, until the series ends with unexpected abruptness.

There was a young man named Jim. Jim had learning disabilities, but his family and friends (and he had a lot of friends, because he was a pleasant, accomodating guy) helped him as much as they could throughout elementary school and high school.

During Jim’s four years in high school he developed a passion for football. He went to every single school game and rooted the team on. He was undoubtedly the team’s number one fan. He also had dreams of playing on the team himself, but he didn’t understand the rules, and he wasn’t in great physical shape. Still, by the time he was a senior, his friends were determined to get this young man, who had done perhaps more than anyone to support the football program, onto the team.

They petitioned his principal, but he preferred to stay out of the issue. They asked the football coaches, but they were reluctant to use up a spot on their roster on someone who would most likely never play in a game. Finally they talked to the football players themselves. They all liked Jim very much because of his positive attitude and his dedication to the team, and they agreed to ask their head coach to let Jim play. They cornered the coach after practice one day and demanded that Jim be put on the team. After much debate, he agreed, and Jim became the third-string running back.

Now, Jim, as you might expect, was absolutely ecstatic about his appointment. If he was happy just cheering the team on, he was completely beside himself with joy at the prospect on watching the game from the bench like a real player. He knew he would probably never play, but that didn’t matter.

The season wore on. Every game Jim was the loudest fan, the most rambunctious player after a win, and the most sympathetic consoler after a loss. By the last game of the season, he had won everyone’s hearts.

Unfortunately the last game was a blowout. Jim’s team was down by over thirty points by the fourth quarter and they had no hope of a comeback. Since the rest of the game didn’t matter, the players began to pressure their coach into letting Jim play. The coach resisted, but the players grew more and more determined. They wore down the coach until he finally agreed to put Jim in for the last play of the game.

With three seconds on the clock, Jim’s team had fought their way to the five-yard line. A touchdown wouldn’t get them a win, but it would let them recover some of their dignity - particularly if Jim scored it. The plan was simple - hand the ball off to Jim and let him plow into the end zone.

Jim couldn’t speak, he was so happy to be playing the sport he loved, on the team he worshiped, with the friends he had cheered on for so long. He put his helmet on and went out on the field. His team huddled up and the quarterback told Jim the play.

The coach, watching from the sideline, saw that something was wrong. His players seemed to be arguing amongst themselves while the play clock ran down. His team was hit with a delay-of-game penalty, and they were backed up five yards. All they had to do was run one play and the game would be over, but the players again seemed agitated. The quarterback began waving his arms toward the sidelines, apparently asking for help. The coach waved him off - just run the play!

Another delay-of-game, and five more yards. This happened several more times, until Jim’s team was backed up into their own territory. Finally the quarterback ripped his helmet off in frustration and stormed off onto the sidelines. The coach asked him what was wrong, why they didn’t just give the ball to Jim and run the play.

The quarterback answers, “Jim says he doesn’t want the ball!”

Does “Mr. Peabody” ring a bell?

You forgot the punchline!

[spoiler]And the moral of the story IIIIIIIIIIS:

Look both ways before you cross the street.[/spoiler]

Well told, a shaggy dog story is genuinely gutwrenchingly hilarious to everyone involved; it’s not just to mystify and annoy.