[QUOTE=pseudotriton ruber ruber]
OK. Let me invite you all to shoot down my idea:
The US decides that sending our soldiers to fight in the Spanish Civil War (say we sent a few advisors over there Vietnam-style) is a good idea, and we establish a military presence in Europe so by 1936 there are many thousand battle-ready American troops there. We start building a wartime economy five years before we actually did, have a bunch of Europeans claiming that Americans are warmongering maniacs (just like we have today anyway), and send Hitler the strong signal, “No funny business, Bub.”
Plus which we have a democratic Spain, grateful to us and more than happy to lease the U.S. some military bases from which we could wage a pretty good ground war if need be.
Commence firing–NOW!
[/QUOTE]
To me the Questions are why involve Spain at all in the scenerio**(1)** and which country, and why, would allow the U.S to establish many thousand troops there**(2)**
(1)
*(a)*I guess I wonder if “Vietnam-style” American advisors in Spain would change the course of that War. There were actually Italian and German Regulars fighting there, would the U.S. intervention have just pushed a local Civil War into a World War? That is what France-Britain believed and convinced FDR of.
*(b)*Further, the 1936 election - last election before the war the Left-Right parties were extremely close :
*Out of a possible 13.5 million voters, over 9,870,000 participated in the 1936 General Election. 4,654,116 people (34.3) voted for the Popular Front, whereas the National Front obtained 4,503,505 (33.2) and the center parties got 526,615 (5.4). The Popular Front, with 263 seats out of the 473 in the Cortes formed the new government.
*
While I am not sure how “grateful” democratic Spain would be - I need to ask *grateful enough for thousands of battle ready American troops to be stationed there permanantly as a front line to fight the Germans * - I doubt it.
(2) (a)I guess it depends on which countries would allow American troops to be semi-permanently stationed there prior to September 1st 1939 - you imply but don‘t say Spain.
(b)Then I guess I would ask would American trip-wire troops, in say a prescient France, intimidate Hitler in the East? If the answer is no (not sure) then I think American Troops would have even less impact being in Spain. I guess I wonder - not saying I am sure it absolutely wouldn’t make a difference but really am not seeing it would be a slam-dunk.
Sorry again I f’ed up your thread man - tried here to answer you straight up!