OK, I’m sure this can’t be it, but it fits your description other than the female vocals:
The Way You Make Me Feel by Michael Jackson?
I’m sorry for insulting your intelligence, but every other bit of your description fits pretty much.
Haha I almost wrote "it sounds the same as The Way You Make Me Feel in the last post, but I figured one song for comparison was enough.
Good ear. Keep thinking along those lines, people.
Even if this isn’t it, it’s worth linking to. Duffy, Mercy.
OK…I’m hoping this is it:
True Blue by Madonna? The chorus even ends “True blue, baby I love you.” This has got to be it, no?
Yeah, that’s it. Thanks. I knew someone would get it sooner or later.
After all that, it is Ma freakin’ donna?
No mind, there are some reminders of good old songs in the thread. And thanks to Poysyn, I remember that song, Hold Me Now but couldn’t remember the name of the group that sang it.
Ugh. I was so sure it was going to be “I’m Your Baby Tonight” by Whitney Houston!
Woo hoo! “Cherish” was my initial Madonna guess, but the lyrics didn’t quite fit, so I went down the catalog to see if I could find another popular shuffle by her. Lots of hit shuffles in the 80s, it seems.
‘True Blue’ trivia! The song is about her then-husband Sean Penn, and since they divorced Madonna has refused to perform it live or include it on any greatest hits compilations, despite it being a number one hit.
See, now this is what I like to stumble across when reading threads like this 'un. I was thinking of Hold Me Now, same name but totally different song, done by The Thompson Twins, and was pleasantly surprised, as I’d never heard this one before. Yay!
Its called hold me now by one to one and its taken me 4 years to figure that out.
I’m going to guess that Pictionary and Charades are not your games, are they, Katie?