When Mr. Feeny tells you "I don't want to talk to you" don't believe him

So I was in the collision shop, waiting an hour, eating a bag of popcorn. I drove out of the collision shop with an estimate and with a bizzare experience. I was sitting in the waiting area and an elderly man wearing a hat sat down across from me. I overheard him saying to one of the collision workers that he was getting his headlights done. I asked him if he was getting his headlights replaced or repaired. He said he was having them replaced. I asked him about the estimate. He abruptly said, “I don’t want to talk to you.” I thought about what he said for a moment and how he had a vaugely English accent. I said, “For someone who speaks so politely, you are very rude.” and, in the same breath, I said, “You don’t want to talk to me. I want to talk to you.”

Just like in The Princess Bride, we were at an impass. He wanted to say, “I don’t want you to talk to me.”, but can’t. If he said that I’d say, “You have no right to tell me what to do.” It got ridiculous. I was talking ostensibly to him about how I sure hope that I get a good estimate. He then says, “You are brazen.” “Brazen?” I say. (I looked it up. Contemptuously bold, according to Merriam Webster.) Then, sarcasically brazen, I said, “Didn’t you say you don’t want to talk to me?”

At this point, it went from ridiculous to ludicrous.

Enter guy wearing sunglasses indoors. Guy wearing sunglasses indoor is standing around, getting a bag of popcorn. Guy wear sunglasses gets involved, confronting me. He says “what are you doing here?” “do you have a car in the shop?”. I don’t really know how to answer him. He says “You need to leave. I’m calling the police.” I ask him: “Do you work here?” He says no. I say, “you’re just a customer like me, you have no right to threaten me.” He says, “Don’t talk to anyone!” I respond by putting on a pair of sunglasses I happen to have in my pocket.

Now there are two guys wearing sunglasses.

I’m eating my popcorn, enjoying the show. I throw the popcorn bag in the trash, stand up, face the other guy wearing sunglasses, and mirror his posture. Even though I subtly mock him, even though by putting on the sunglasses I acknowledge his order to not “talk to anyone”, he keeps talking. Doesn’t he know that by putting on sunglasses I agree to not talk and that he, also wearing sunglasses, shouldn’t talk either? He says I was rude to that man. I wanted to say he was rude to me. He goes on to say that he don’t know whether I have a mental disorder. I wanted to say how do I know you don’t have a mental disorder.

Maybe the elderly man wearing a hat is related to that old man with the cane.

Dude, did you confuse micrograms and milligrams again?

The main point I want to make is that a direct statement of, “I don’t want to talk to you,” strikes me as being one of the least-rude ways to get a person to stop talking to you while, hopefully, achieving the result of them quickly taking the hint and stopping the conversation.

Do you have a mental disorder? You are correct that this entire exchange is bizarre, ridiculous, and ludicrous, but I believe it was your behavior that made it so.

Cool story, bro.

Eggplant butter-nut tractor!

Purple monkey dishwasher!

This is the sort of shit that white people get to get away with.

I so needed a laugh. Thank you!

And here I thought you got the brush-off from William Daniels…

“I don’t want to talk about ‘car repairs’. I’d much rather have my automobile promptly fixed so that I may drive from here post haste.”

“I understand. I want to get my car repairs done too, qucickly and cheaply, I might add.”

End of conversation.

No, I don’t have a mental disorder. I think him saying that is a cop-out. I would have said to him “How do I know you don’t have a mental disorder? You’re wearing sunglasses indoors just like me, bud.” For all we know, he could be merely trying to gain the trust of the elderly man. (I, on the other hand, am worried about money - my own!)

My thoughts exactly.

Why would you ask about someone’s estimate? I would have said “What’s it to you?”

Ironically, I would have responded, “Nothing. Just wondering if they give good estimates here.” I would not have been offended and I would be unaware that I am having an exchange with a fellow Doper.

What this exchange is, is Seinfeldian. I’m actually glad I had it. I taught that elderly man a lesson I learned before reaching the age of 30: You are going to sit there anyway so you might as well talk. Think about it. Had I not spoken to that elderly man then he would have left the collision shop and I would have left the collision shop, and nothing would come of it. That elderly man did not know that he was dealing with someone who pratically has a Ph.D. in Linguistics. Not to mention that I’ve studied Logic, Psychology, Philosophy, and Political Science.

I “won” the “conversation”. I had the last word. He said “I don’t want to talk to you” with the expectation that I would saunder off into the corner, look away, look defeated. I studied Game Theory, too. :smiley:

You know how you go years without particularly noticing another poster and then they suddenly post something that makes you go, “Welp, there’s another one for the crazy list”?

Inconceivable!

Assuming this comment can find it’s way through the crazy-maze to the tiny little Minotaur of sanity at the center…you did not teach him a lesson. You intruded on him in a very rude, and, it sounds like, rather threatening manner. If the whole exchange was as it sounds, I may have felt moved to involve the management of the shop, at the very least.

How did I intrude on him?

Or misread ‘one every four hours’ as ‘four every one hour’?

He told you he didn’t want to talk to you. You, a stranger, continued to impose conversation on him. He then indicated he didn’t find the conversation agreeable. You continued to talk to him. That’s rude, at best, and kind of scary, at worst.

By continuing to speak after he made his desire to not speak perfectly clear. Your behavior was rude, aggressive, and entirely inappropriate. You’re lucky the guy with the sunglasses did not rearrange your teeth for you.