Who Broke Your Heart The Most?

For me, a long and tragic story.

I’d just moved to Tucson from Asheville, NC. This was about 10 years ago. I was working as a waitress and living in an apartment with a roommate. I was in my mid 20’s, freshly divorced, with a hot body and a naivete that today I can’t even comprehend.

I met Travis at the bar in the neighborhood. Travis was soooo cute, especially in a white t-shirt and jeans. He was extremely charismatic, hilariously funny, and knew someone everywhere we went. He had a lot of friends, a nice family, a good job, and said all the right things. He could be so sweet it would bring tears to my eyes. Travis seemed like the man I’d been looking for my whole life, he was my soulmate!

A few months into the relationship, my roommate had noticed that Travis may have some anger issues. I was completely oblivious- I loved Travis and he could do no wrong. My name was not on the lease, so after “we” moved to a new apartment together (with Travis and I doing all the work, in July, in Tucson, I might add), she decided she didn’t really want me as a roommate. So Travis and I moved in together. Things were coming together nicely, I thought.

Immediately I began to notice that Travis drank more than I was comfortable with. And he seemed to go into these black moods when drinking. Then Travis began to want to hurt me when he was mad, which was getting more and more frequent. Me being no fool, I wasn’t about to stand there and let him hurt me, so I’d run. Many’s the night Travis would chase me down the street. Fortunately, my feet could fly back then, and he never did catch me. By the time I’d come home, he’d be sorry, I’d be wonderful again, and we’d make up.

Then one night while drinking, Travis reached his flash point without warning, reached down and grabbed my foot, and bit it. Hard. This was the turning point for me. I could no longer live in my denial and faced the ugly truth that Travis was NOT the charming, charismatic, funny hero I’d thought. Travis was an abusive drunk, and I had to leave. So I did. But it broke my heart in a way I’d never experienced before or since.

I then began dating Travis’s neighbor, that I’d met and hung out with some while I’d lived with Travis. At first I dated him out of some twisted sense of revenge, Travis had to see me with someone else, ha! But then I slowly began to forget about Travis and the neighbor treated me like a queen. My heart began to heal, and while I didn’t fall in love with the neighbor, it was a nice diversion and we became very good friends, and more. Travis didn’t like this too much, but except for a couple of drunken occasions of him banging on the door late at night and not being let in, he pretty much left us alone. I dated the neighbor for a couple of years, and now several years later, that man is my best friend. The last time I spoke to Travis, he had called the neighbor, I answered the phone. He asked for the neighbor, I said he wasn’t there, and he said to “tell him I called.” I didn’t recognize his voice, and asked who it was. “It’s Travis”, he sounded hurt. “Okay, I’ll tell him, bye.”

A couple years later, I got a message on my answering machine in the middle of the night. A drunken Travis, mumbling something about “goodbye forever”. I found out the next day that Travis had asked his girlfriend to marry him. I do feel a sense of satisfaction that Travis must have held a torch for me for a long time, for much longer than I held his. Ha!

Now, all these years later, I’m grateful to Travis. He taught me, in a relatively mild way, that abusive men are to be avoided. No matter how charming, how sweet, how funny, how popular… no one is worth being treated like crap and feeling like crap. I learned that it’s okay to be alone, that I can take care of myself, and that loving someone doesn’t change them.

Who, and under what circumstances, broke your heart the most?

Conrad Birdie

Did he say bye-bye when he went into the Army, or did you?
I know sometimes I feel like the only one who’s ever had their heart broken, but it can’t be true! Can it?

I was crushed when my sweetie left town when his family moved. He promised to write a lot and call a lot and make plans to get together at the first school break, but I never heard from him again.

That would be myself.

It’s over six years ago, longer than the relationship lasted, and I still don’t want to think about it. I suppose what hurts the most is the shame of it all. I should have seen it coming about two months into the relationship and ended it then and there, but I was young and dumb and with a terrible self-esteem problem, and instead I was in there for five years and was fucked up for like two years after that.

I can’t believe the poor little guy I used to be.

The person who broke my heart the most is my sister. As far back as I can remember, I’ve idolized her. We didn’t grow up under ideal circimstances. We weren’t poor but the things we dealt with, weren’t talked about back then. She’s six years older than me, and she may as well have been my parent because she was the one who made sure I had food and clothes, while the parental units were busy with their own demons. My mother’s demons were inside her head, my father’s demon was my mother.

Then she went away to college. Once she got a taste of the outside world, she never looked back. On the rare occassion when she would come home, she would push me away, and not allow me to get too attached.
I still lived with my father but I was basicly alone. He stayed in his room and only came out while I was at school or sleeping. There was no one to tell me what to do when I started my period. When I outgrew my clothes, I had to dig out her old clothes, because my father couldn’t be bothered with buying me new ones. It wasn’t until I got frostbite on my toes and had to see the doctor, that my father agreed to have the heat turned on in our huge house. After that, I was too much trouble so he sent me away to school. That’s when I realised why my sister never looked back.
Over the years, I’ve tried to regain our closeness, but we are as opposite as two people can get. She had privledges that I wasn’t allowed and she married a man who hates her past more than she does, including the role I played in it. We live 40 miles from eachother, and haven’t seen eachother since our mother’s funeral 4 years ago.
I’ve forgiven her for abandoning me. And I don’t know if she just doesn’t enjoy my company because we’re so different or if she doesn’t want anything to do with what’s left of her old family. But maybe things will get better between us. We’ve recently started emailing eachother.

It was this woman from Pennsylvania—my best friend at the time. She was 38 years old, and she had never had a boyfriend. She had multiple disabilities and incurable conditions–lupus, osteoporosis, a compromised immune system, Reynauld’s syndrome, a damaged digestive system, blurry vision, a twisted spine, and more. Very few men would even consider going out with her, much less marrying her. Except me.

We were never officially a couple, but we would get cutesy, snuggly and affectionate with each other. We’d hold hands, rub noses and go on dates. On several occasions, we even talked about getting married.

At some point, something went awry. She insisted, “I never wanted to be anything more than friends.” This came as a complete shock to me. Granted, we were never officially a couple, but I thought we were more than just friends. After all, how often does one go rubbing noses with a mere friend, or gently stroke that friend’s face?

So yeah, she’s the one that broke my heart the most.

Wow. Convenient.

I just finished the relationship that has broken my heart the most a month ago and I’m still dealing with the fallout. I used to think I was a really strong person, emotionally - but it turns out I’m not. I never had any idea I was capable of being in such pain. The days were never this long when I thought I loved him.

I was so dumb, it was insane for me not to have seen how it would end. I did two of those things everybody tells you never to do when starting a relationship - how could I not think that people tell you that for a reason!?

So now I’m standng here at the other end of two years after giving him every part of myself - with what feels like nothing left.

Whinge I like to think I’ll be back to normal soon.

Word, brother . . . :frowning:

Way, way, back about 1200 BC, I was an undergraduate. Times were tough, the college was kind of isolated in a town whose residents did not like us, and I was bored. And lonely. And carrying a lot of emotional baggage, including hideously low self-esteem and the angst that comes from having no clue about what to do after graduation. Into my life walks . . . Well, let’s call her Ellie. I had a huge crush on Ellie, which she knew about, and finally, I got up the courage to ask her out. She accepts, and the next thing you know, we’re an item.

It was about then I discovered that Ellie was, well . . . a bit flakey. And manipulative. Somehow when we fought, everything seemed to be my fault. And somehow, I couldn’t let go. I had never heard the term “whipped” applied to a relationship, but damned if that didn’t describe my place with her to a tee. Shit got deeper, and she started cheating. No one told me. No one had to. I have always been a pretty good judge of character, and Ellie was a pretty terrible liar. I mean, Helen Keller wouldn’t have been fooled by her.

So I broke it off with her. I had broken up with other girls, and while painful, it was really no big deal. Not so with this one. She might not have been able to lie, but she could manipulate people’s emotions very well. (I had gone into the relationship knowing what she had done to her previous boyfriend. Silly me, ha-ha!!). I won’t bore you with the details of what she did to get me back, but it was bad. It was very bad, and probably this is what sticks with me all these years later. How in God’s name could I have been taken in by this? Why, for God’s sake, didn’t I just avoid her for the rest of the semester? Knowing the kind of woman she was, how could I have been this stupid to wind up back in bed with her? What in Christ’s name convinced me that I could have a platonic friendship with this woman without her trying to sandbag me right back onto the game?

Years later, before I worked it out of my system, it wasn’t the cheating that got me down; this is quite common in college relationships, and in the majority of incidents, it has nothing to do with the cuckold. I didn’t mind being a cuckold. I minded being a naive sap. I minded being a pussy-whipped sucker who didn’t have the strength or common sense to stand up for myself and tell Ellie to fuck off. That is what made me feel ashamed of myself.

So what happened? We graduated. At the time of graduation, we were on the outs, but she still wanted to “be friends.” I went back to my town and broke it off. I just walked away. I didn’t call, I didn’t write, and I hooked up with the first local girl who looked at me twice, but this time, I wasn’t out for a long term relationship, just the sex. She wrote me a couple of times and then gave up. I later heard that she couldn’t talk about me with her friends without crying. Somehow, she had found out about the hookup. Even after all that time, I felt lousy for having hurt her like that. Sigh . . .

A few months after that, I was in the army. Now army life changed things all around. I toughened up, I quickly learned that my own Ellie story paled in comparison to what the guys in my basic training platoon had to go through with their ex-girlfriends and soon-to-be ex-wives. I forgot about college life, and with it, I forgot about Ellie, more or less, although some shame remained. Still, I matured in the army. I toughened up. I found my direction in life which has carried me through to this day.

A couple of years into my service, I’d remember her on an FTX in Korea or on a 12-mile ruckmarch state-side. It would be a semi-fond memory, the way you’d remember an old pet from your childhood. But she generally stayed in the back of my mind. I got out of the army, got married, and forgot about Ellie completely.

Until one year ago, a little over 11 years after we’d kissed each other goodbye for the last time. I was looking for the obituary of an army buddy who just happened to have grown up in the vicinity of Ellie. I didn’t find the buddy’s obit. I did find the obituary of Ellie’s father, a man whom I had met a few times and actually grown to like before all the shit went down. That just brought back everything. See, I hadn’t really worked it all out of my system. That happy horseshit just kind of got pushed to the back of my mind what with the army and marriage and all. I found this out the hard way when I read the obituary. Somewhere in the past 11 years, Ellie had gotten married and settled down. Good for her.

But the news of the death of her father triggered everything. I felt all the old pain again. I was just beside myself thinking about this shit. It wasn’t that I wanted to be with Ellie again. By that time, I had wised up, thanks to army life and married life. Plus, I love my wife. She is the best woman on the planet, and she has more sense and respect in one of her fingernail clippings than Ellie ever saw in her life. I just wanted to write Ellie and tell her that I was sorry about her dad and sorry about how things didn’t work out. I sat down with Mrs. Fresh, told her everything, including how Ellie got me back and how I just forgot about her after graduation. Mrs. Fresh, of course, had the answer right off the top of her head. Following her advice, I bought a sympathy card, wrote down a brief note of condolence, along with the fragment of a poem I had memorized in the army when my grandmother had died. Then I wrapped it in an envelope and mailed it to Ellie’s family (not Ellie), leaving no return address. To this day, I don’t know who saw it or even if it got through the mail. That cleared it up, and thoughts of Ellie have not bothered me since.

The only thing you can do about the pain and the shame is realize that it wasn’t your fault. Realize that it had nothing to do with you. Manipulative people don’t just manipulate the people who deserve it. They also target the weak and unsure. Quite often, this is what will snap a weak and unsure person out of his or her insecurity and take him or her to the next step in life. Then they get to look back on the incident and go "What was I thinking?? :smack: :smack: " Just reflect on how much you’ve grown since then. In a way, I find myself thanking Ellie. She wound up teaching me what was what, and what I could put up with in a relationship, and what I shouldn’t put up with. It was that knowledge that eventually led me to my wife.

So thanks, Ellie. And stay the fuck away from my house!! :mad:

This is a few years ago. 1990-91, or so.

I was in the Navy, at the time, and actually enjoying it. (Some people go to boot camp and have the stress get to them. I went to boot camp and relaxed. Amazing what answering the phones at a hospital billing office can do to one.) I was in training for the Nuclear Power Program, and enjoying the challenge. I’d been keeping in touch with college friends by letter writing, and phone calls. During this time I got close to one of them.

When the time came to end classroom study and go to one of the Navy’s prototype facilities I was thrilled to realize that not only would my duty station near Albany put me close to my family and friends I had growing up, but close to her, too.

For the next nine months, whenever I got a weekend I spent at least an hour or three visiting her. Where she lived was about 45 minutes to an hour out of the way from where I lived at the time to where my parents lived. Not far out of the way at all. (Or so I told myself.) We had a lot of fun, and were getting along pretty well.

Then my training period ended and I got my orders to my ship. Actually, since my ship was on deployment I got my orders to proceed to Little Creek and wait there. All in all I was there for about two months, I think.

During that time I really began to miss this woman, and talked to her on the phone about three or five times a week. I felt, at the time, we were just getting closer and closer. And began to think about popping The Question to her.

Then when talking to a mutual friend he mentioned that she’d just gotten engaged.

I was 22, and an idiot, as many 22 year olds are. I decided with some thinking, that I wasn’t going to confront her about it - I was going to wait for her to tell me. We kept talking on the phone and I still enjoyed talking, but I kept waiting for the shoe to drop. And it never did.

Eventually my time in Purgatory ended and I was sent to my ship. My Med cruise was frustrating, busy and fun, too. But I kept up with the writing. And she kept writing me.

When we got back, I called again, and visited, even. And still nothing. Before people get the wrong impression - she was not having sex with me during these visits. I’d suggest it once while we were making out, and accepted her ‘no.’ I told her I’d be interested if she changed her mind, and just kept on. It may have been a mistake, I don’t know. At the time I wouldn’t have considered a physical seduction moral. (Yeah, I was something of a prig as a young snot.)

Anyways, to cut this shorter, eventually - about six months after her marriage - she 'fessed up and told me what had happened. I told her I’d heard, but had expected her to tell me.

I heard from her exactly once after that - a Christmas letter that mentioned that she and her husband had lost their first child. (Failure to thrive, I think they call it.) And after that I couldn’t even think what to say to her.

Anyways, that’s my one big adventure with romance. So, no, you’re not the only who’s had their heart broken, trublmakr.

The Dodgers.

The girl with freckles.

She warned me not to like her. She had baggage from her past, including a violent husband she had divorced about a year befor I met her. She said she was trouble. I thought she was my kind of trouble.

She had this smile, this dry wit. Oh, man, her lower lip. Her almond shaped eyes. She kissed passionately, yet so delicately. And freckles. Her body was lined with delicious freckles. The days we were together my feet never touched the ground.

All too soon, she got scared. Scared because she had started feeling things for me and didn’t think she was ready. She pushed me out in her headstrong stubborn way and there was no talking her out of it.

I couldn’t function for several days afterward. I told her “Oh God, Jess, this hurts so much!” And it did. In a single day I went from flying high to abject misery. It had only been a couple of months since we met, but the last thing I said before (effectively) walking out of her life was “I Love You”. It was the only time I ever told her, and probably the first time I realized I felt that deeply. The pain broke through all my resistance as I spoke those words and my face, for a second, registered my perfect agony.

Once I start loving a person, I never really stop. I still think of her. I probably always will, along with others I have loved. With her, the relationship ended before it ever had a chance. That’s why the heartbreak was so great.

Thanks for the stories, everyone. I, for one, find other people’s tales of love gone wrong interesting.

It’s been almost 10 years, so I haven’t felt pain upon thinking of Travis for a long time. I do still think of him very occasionally, and I wonder what could have been, if he’d been who I’d hoped he was, instead of who he really was.

Show me someone who never screwed up, and I’ll show you someone who never learned.

Show me someone who never suffered, and I’ll show you someone who never grew.

That’s why we say “sadder but wiser.” The sadder makes you wiser.

I had just gotten an apartment for myself. I had either lived at home with my mother or with my first wife in a very bad marriage. Carrie lived at the other end of the building. She was a tall blond of Scandanavian descent. She was 3 months pregnant and all by herself, the father of the baby split when he found out she was pregnant. The rest of her family lived in Oregon and she rarely saw them. Over a 4 month period we grew extremely close. I would come home from work at 1 am and she would be up with something for me to eat even though she had to get up at 5am to go to work herself. We talked about the birth of the baby and how she thought I would be the perfect father. With the end of her apartment lease coming up, we decided she would move in with me. We moved most of her stuff into my apartment and put her furniture in storage till we could get something big enough for all our furniture. On the afternoon of October 31, 1981, I went to work thinking I had an official roommate starting the next day.

When I got home at 1 am, everything she owned was gone from the apartment. There was no note, no nothing. I had a phone number for her sister and called, she said she knew nothing but would call me if she heard anything. My neighbor said a U-Haul truck was there for about an hour that evening. No one else saw anything. The storage locker we put her furniture in was empty too. A week later her sister called me back, she had found out what happened. The father of the baby showed up that fateful Halloween day with a sob story and a wallet full of cash. He was going to give them the life they deserved and she bit.

The next time I saw Carrie was on October 13, 1989, the day of my mother’s funeral. She read the obituary in the newspaper and she had really gotten along well with my mother when we were together. She apolgized and told me she was available, the relationship with her child’s father lasted only a few years. By then I have gone through a marriage and annulment and had just met the woman I am still married to this day. I told her to leave, I had nothing to say to her and there could never be anything between us again. Typing this made me realize it still hurts.

I lived with a woman when I was twenty-one. In Texas, way back then, people simply DID NOT live together; it simply wasn’t done. I wanted to marry her; she wanted to marry me, but she was Catholic and I was not and wouldn’t convert. Her father hated me for seducing her, which ain’t what happened, and for having stolen her from her church, and worked on her constantly to leave me. I guess it was inevitable, but I went to work one day and when I came home, she and all her stuff was gone. She didn’t even leave a note; she just went home to Daddy.

I was emotionally destroyed for the best part of five years. I know now that I was profoundly depressed; back then I thought I was insane. I dreamed about her nearly every night and would often be absolutely convinced that she would call, which she never did. She broke my heart almost to the point of killing me.

The father of my children, when I found out he was fucking his sister -in-law. Anyway, they’re married now and live with her mother. This was his brother’s wife (now ex-wife). It really fucked with my head for a while, but I’m cool with it now.

My ex girlfriend.

We’re talking total heartbreak. After our 3-year relationship ended, she started seeing people almost immediately, and I frequently had to witness her and her many flavors of the month climbing the fuck all over each other, since she and I were part of the same circle of friends, and if I wanted to avoid her completely, it would involve me becoming a hermit before I’d turned 20.
You’d think that would be a wake up call, but it wasn’t. In my defense, I was 19 at the time.

I guess I never stopped loving her, despite the pain she put me through, stupid me. A couple of years after the break up, we were both single, and relatively decent friends. At a friend’s engagement pre-wedding bash, we were both a little tipsy, which led to some light snogging, which then turned into a couple of dates, which then turned into us seeing each other again.

Till she dumped me one week after it started. Again.

I also found out later that she’d been trashing me over the years, and had even snogged a couple of friends of mine.

The proverbial last straw, that was. It took a lot to get over that girl, but I did. And thank Og I did, because I met Sniperfangess, who is the most wonderful, intelligent, caring, funny and beautiful I’ve known. :smiley:

A girl I dated from age 15 to 22. Not just seven years, but seven completely formative years, full of the high hormones and drama and self-discovery and changes and etc. etc. etc. In retrospect, it’s not just completely absurd that we thought we could make it to marriage, but that it even lasted that long - by the tail end of that seven years, we were both fundamentally different people than the 15-year-old kids that we started out as.

Things ended pretty badly, and it was basically like going through a divorce at age 22. I don’t think I’ve ever truly recovered.