Who was hotter In their prime, Robert Plant v. Roger Daltry v. Mick Jagger?

Yeah, none of them are remotely sexy.

Guys, who’s the sexist: Ann Coulter, Juliette Lewis, or Hilary Swank?

Hilary Swank - Mos def

Juliette Lewis - Has her moments

Ann Coulter - Meh, has her moments too, but mostly because of her facial expressions, coltishness and sense of humor

Morrison would be my choice if he were in the running, personally, but I wholly agree with you on the subject of Robert Plant. Mick Jagger has a bit of it too, but he’s always playing roles in his music, where Plant had pain down in his soul that you can hear in the lyrics. (Even in Black Dog!) It’s the combination of the way he exudes sex and the way he has a hurt that you want to make better that makes him sexy.

Well that and I want to lick my screen every time I see this.

Huh. It just makes me want to giggle a little and go look for that video by The Darkness.

Of the three choices, I’d say it’s pretty close between Daltrey and Plant, who I always felt resembled each other anyway. Definitely not Jagger.

I think I know what incident you’re referring to, but that’s not quite the way it happened. Daltrey and Townshend did come to blows either when recording the Quadrophenia album or rehearsing for the tour, but Townshend struck the first blow. Daltrey responded by punching him, and was reportedly horrified that this knocked Townshend out. I don’t believe Townshend’s famous nose was ever broken.

As a teenager Daltrey was a “rough and tumble Cockney” – he has a scar on his belly from a knife fight – but settled down a lot by the late '60s. By rock star standards he’s led a pretty quiet adult life. He’s been quite open about having sex with a lot of groupies in the '60s and '70s even after he married, but his wife was apparently okay with that – they’re still together after 40 years. He’s also the only member of the Who never to have a (known) drug or alcohol problem.

Nobody oozed sexuality not only from looks but through their music like Robert Plant did. Daltrey is a distant second and Mick is still prancing around pretending his guitarist isn’t his better half of the band.

Robert Plant was the least ugly.

Without a doubt, Robert Plant.

The scar is from surgery he had as a child to remove a rusty nail he had swallowed. He talks about it in an interview in the Sunday Times dated May 1, 2008. I’d link to it but this is a work computer still runing (barely) on Win2000 and opening an extra window crashes the system.

I’ll keep the straight male vote unanimous in favor of Mr. Plant. Roger Daltrey is ‘prettier’, but not ‘hotter’. And Mick may be many things, but ‘hot’ is not one of them.

Windows 2000? Damn…you are a trooper!
:slight_smile:

where’s my 386?

So, he says “Oy, les go git a pint after t’ sho?” Who doesn’t???

So Michael Jackson/Bono/Noel Gallagher/Snoop/JayZ/CeeLo etc. are obviously more sexy??? Who are you talking about???

I’ve never heard that before, but I’ll believe you even without the link. :slight_smile:

Daltrey was reportedly a bit of a brawler as a teenager, even if knives weren’t involved. Pete Townshend (who attended the same high school) has told stories about Daltrey’s schoolyard fights and said he fought dirty. I don’t believe the two ever fought with each other until they were actually in a band together, though!

Are we truly qualified to vote?
Most women when asked if Janis were sexy would offer an opinion of how many guys in Big Brother she had sex with.

I think Mick could kick Morrison’s ass, for whatever that’s worth. :slight_smile:

David Bowie is still eye candy…

Nick Drake.

But Daltrey is so SHORT! Most Doper women would be like Vegas showgirls standing next to him.

Roger is short, but he has very large feet. :stuck_out_tongue:

If we’re going to talk about size of feet, then Robert Plant wins hands down. (Hint: 3:25) :eek: