"Wordle," a strangely compelling word game (Part 3)

Wordle 1,590 5/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::yellow_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

HEART
SPOIL
PLUNK
PLUMB
PLUMP

Wordle 1,590 4/6*

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::yellow_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

SNIDE
BATCH
JUROR
PLUMP

Lucky guess, condidering there were still many words to choose from.

Wordle 1,590 4/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::blue_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:orange_square::orange_square::orange_square::orange_square::orange_square:

CRANE
HOIST
BUNNY
PLUMP

Wow, after two whiffs and a single letter, I lucked out.

Wordle 1,591 4/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square:
:green_square::white_large_square::yellow_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::yellow_square::white_large_square::yellow_square::green_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square: :innocent: no Ai :kangaroo:

Au contraire! You’d eliminated over half the alphabet, and with a U not in the second position, you chance for par came down to a mere coin flip berween PLUMP and FLUFF.

I’d call this a game skillfully played. :grin:

Since there have been 1,592 solutions used (games 0-1591), that would mean there are 3,883 words on the NYT list of solutions. That would be a huge expansion from Wardle’s original list of 2,315 solutions. (And some of those were dropped by the NYT because they were thought to be prurient or derogatory.)

Wardle’s original list is out there, and of course the set of past solutions is as well. Someone must’ve compared the two, to see how many solutions so far were NOT on Wardle’s list. Knowing that would give us a rough idea of just how many possible solutions the NYT has added altogether.

Someone did in fact compare the two, specifically Mark McLaren at Techradar.com. And through the end of July, there had been 17 solutions that hadn’t been on Wardle’s list:

One notable feature of July’s Wordles was that there were five ‘non-original’ answers among the 31 games.

When Josh Wardle created Wordle, he and his partner drew up a list of 2,315 words which would form the game’s answer list, then scheduled them to appear one a day for the next six or so years.

The New York Times removed a few of those when it bought Wordle in 2022, then left the list more or less unchanged for the next year. Then, in March 2023, it gave us GUANO – the first ‘extra’ solution added to the original pool and the start of a new era for Wordle.
More have followed since then, 17 in total

The seventeen non-Wardle past solutions are:

ATRIA, BALSA, BEAUT, GOFER, GUANO, KAZOO, LASER, LORIS, MOMMY, NERVY, PIOUS, PRIMP, SNAFU, SQUID, TAUPE, TIZZY, UVULA.

This count was through the end of July (Wordle 1503). GUANO, the first to appear, was Wordle 646. So in 858 (or more, depending on when they put the additional words into the pool from which each day’s solution is presumably selected at random) Wordles, there were 17 non-Wardle Wordles. (Say that five times real fast!) That’s slightly less than one non-Wardle solution per 50 games. So through the end of July, there had been 1487 Wardle solutions (recall, there’s a Wordle 0, whose solution was CIGAR). 2315 total Wardle solutions - 1487 Wardle solutions used through the end of July leaves 828 unused Wardle solutions as of July 31. Some of them (e.g. PENIS) won’t be used either, since the NYT just isn’t going to allow certain words. But still, one non-Wardle solution for every 50 Wardle solutions suggests there might be in the ballpark of another 17 non-Wardle solutions, give or take, either that have been solutions in the past three months, or will be solutions sometime in the future.

That’s not many, is it? Clearly there aren’t enough non-Wardle solutions in the pool to noticeably lengthen the game. It still comes back to their having already gone through 2/3 of their possible solutions.

Wordle 1,591 3/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::green_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::white_large_square::green_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

RATIO
UNTIL
FETID

Wordle 1,591 3/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:yellow_square::green_square::white_large_square::green_square::green_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

AUDIO
TEPID
FETID

Thanks to RTFirefly for going into details.

So 67% of words are used up. (Or slightly less when new (non-Wardle) Wordle words are included.) But my experiments (shown in thread) show 84% (46 of 55) of the words I think of already used-up. My experiments are biased (I think of simple words and overlook weirder words) but that bias should be uncorrelated with a random draw from the bag of Wordle words.

But is the draw random?

My hypothesis is that there are many hard-to-think-of Wordle words that are rejected by the Editor when drawn from the bag of Wordle words. For examples, from the C-words on the
wordle-starting-words-not-used-yet-full-list we see Cabby, Cairn, Cavil, China, Clack, Clink, Clung, Copse, Coupe, Covey, Creme, Cress, Crock, Croup, Crump, Cutie. About half of these words I barely recognize and couldn’t define; several look like slang (or foreign words like Creme); and China looks like a capitalized proper noun.

The last thing the Wordle editor wants is to annoy even a small portion of Wordlers with words they’ve barely heard of, or otherwise reject.

Wordle 1,591 4/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square::yellow_square:
:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::green_square::yellow_square::green_square::yellow_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

SLATE
CHOIR
BEFIT
FETID
After clue #2 I thought of four fitting words; Befit, Fetid and two already-used.
Pursuant to my hypothesis I decided the Editor might dislike Fetid (nastier than Penis IMO).
Oh well.

Wordle 1,591 3/6*

\begin{aligned} &\bbox[silver,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt H} \bbox[silver,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt O} \bbox[yellow,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt I} \bbox[silver,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt S} \bbox[yellow,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt T} \\ &\bbox[yellow,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt T} \bbox[yellow,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt I} \bbox[silver,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt G} \bbox[yellow,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt E} \bbox[silver,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt R} \\ &\bbox[lime,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt F} \bbox[lime,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt E} \bbox[lime,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt T} \bbox[lime,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt I} \bbox[lime,5px,border:1px solid black]{\texttt D} \\ \end{aligned}

Wordle 1,591 3/6

:black_large_square::black_large_square::black_large_square::black_large_square::black_large_square:
:black_large_square::blue_square::orange_square::blue_square::black_large_square:
:orange_square::orange_square::orange_square::orange_square::orange_square:

WOMAN
LITER
FETID

Broke my streak of fives with a nice whiff-to-birdie.

Wordle 1,591 4/6

:black_large_square::black_large_square::black_large_square::black_large_square::yellow_square:
:yellow_square::black_large_square::yellow_square::black_large_square::black_large_square:
:black_large_square::yellow_square::green_square::yellow_square::green_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

SPARE
DOILY
CITED
FETID

Wordle 1,591 4/6* 10/27/2025

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::green_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:yellow_square::green_square::green_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:


PLUMP → Whiff. Can’t go with SLATE or its anagrams here, but I do want that A & E, so I’ll go with
NEARS → Placed E and nothing else. I need to try T… and O? First word I see that fits the bill is
DETOX → I is still out there, and if I put it in the logical fourth spot that moves D to the end, which looks like
FETID
FETED
was also out there, and might be nonbogus. Scoredle ends up with a bogey; it plays a double letter with its third guess, trying to place it, and misses out on the last letter until there was just one word left. It turns out my third guess was key, though Scoredle’s third guess from my position turned out to be even better.

Wordle 1591 4/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square:
:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square:
:yellow_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

SLANT
CHORE
DUMPY
FETID

TWEED had been used.

My impression is that there are a couple of distinct categories of words that the NYT dropped from Wardle’s list: (1) sexual/prurient words, and (2) slurs and derogatory words. (E.g. if SQUAW was on Wardle’s list, I’m sure it’s not on the NYT’s list.) Today’s solution doesn’t fall in either category.

I would assume that the NYT reviewed the list more than once in the first year that they actively ran the game, and removed all the words they’re going to remove. I recognized and could roughly define all the words I’ve spoilered here, with the exception of one that I figured must be onomatopoetic, and a check of the dictionary confirmed it. ‘Creme’ isn’t foreign anymore, it’s one of the many words of foreign origin that English cheerfully absorbed. (French words? No biggie ever since that fella from Normandy conquered England nearly a thousand years ago.) And ‘china’ is spelled with a lowercase ‘c’ when referring to plates and saucers and so forth. (Ran into another example of that when coming up with possible solutions after my second guess today: ‘Teddy’ has an initial cap when it’s someone’s name, but it’s ‘teddy’ when it’s the item of feminine lingerie. So if it’s not on the list, it’s not because it has to be a proper noun.)

Wordle 1,591 4/6

:white_large_square::white_large_square::white_large_square::yellow_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::green_square::white_large_square::green_square::white_large_square:
:white_large_square::green_square::white_large_square::green_square::green_square:
:green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square::green_square:

BUYER
SEPIA
GEOID
FETID

YOU recognized and know all those words. NYTimes wants to appeal to a very large audience. Using words many are unsure of (or that are unlikely to pop to mind) is certain to annoy.

Hey! That’s a little like today’s Wordle which is not an overly common word…