It’s silly to think that NAF meant only those roles are excluded. I read the statement as meaning “no power roles or other funky stuff. really.” They advertised this game as a basic vanilla game.
To accept that some player could have special knowledge just goes against the premise of this game. I don’t buy it. I’m not willing to give a player a free pass because of a claim whose validity that depends on a legalistic interpretation that goes against the spirit of the game. That’s my opinion, you’re welcome to disagree. But if Hal is scum, you’re handing the game to him.
What does that mean? Scum will do anything, and a skilled Scum player will sound indistinguishable from the rest of us.
Hey NAF, not to point mistakes or anything, but I never voted for Faithfool
Townies that are voting for me, reconsider your vote. Ask yourself why you are voting for me. Is it because Hawkeye has been putting words in my mouth? Is it becuase I’ve been vocal with the intention to just get conversation going? Do you have any reason that you believe that I’m guilty? If you are just reading what others are saying about me and not forming your own opinions, you are playing right into scummy hands.
If I do take a swan dive into the abyss tonight, take a close look at whose been dogging me.
Well you don’t have to worry about that. Voting has ended ladies and gents and brewha only had 7 out of the required 8 votes for a lynch. ToDay no one dies.
ToNight is a different story.
Scum have 48 hours from this post to make a Night action decision (Wednesday at 9:30 am pacific) Get to work!
(I promise to be less frazzled for the rest of the game.)
Aw, crudnasty. I was away for the weekend, and thought I’d get back before Day’s end. I suppose I’ll use this time to go back and read over what I assume were some amazing insight on why we should have lynched brewha.
(I apologize for double posting here… I may end up quadruple posting, just because I’m going to respond to things one at a time as I catch up with today, and I plan on saving story’s continued attacck on me for last)
faithfool made a major slip to start the game off. She hasn’t done much of anything other than act aggrieved by me voting for her (a perfectly neutral reaction, especially for a new player), so there isn’t much more for me to go on. I’m confident enough in her slip being a scumtell that I don’t need any more. While I’m starting to see some of the case made against brewha, it seems a much shakier indictment of scumdom than faithfool’s near outright admission of guilt on Day One.
Yeah, I’m like a dog with a bone sometimes. But this one is just too tasty to pass up.
You know, I live in LA. Grew up in LA. I love LA.* But sometime…sometimes something comes along that just makes me ashamed.
My home town has besmirched the name of Top Dog and my world just became that much sadder a place.
*(I secretly prefer LA to San Francisco, but don’t tell anyone, it isn’t cool to think that way)