You-Solve-It Mafia Game

Day 2 votes in correct order… I’m not sure there’s much to be gleaned from day 2, for when Cookies revealed the killer’s trait, a OAOW lynch was inevitable.

However, I thought I’d list the pre-revelation vote count:

brewha (2): shadowfacts, Hockey Monkey
faithfool (2): Diomedes, Pleonast
Diomedes (1): faithfool

Here’s the end of day vote count:

OAOW (10): Hal, Hawkeyeop, sachertorte, shadowfacts, freudian slit, Kat, Hockey Monkey, faithfool, Diomedes, OAOW
Diomedes (1): Rysto
No Vote (5): brewha, Hazel, zuma, story, Pleonast

The only things to note were that Pleonast placed the 5th vote on OAOW, then unvoted because he said he didn’t want to end the day early. Diomedes placed the 9th vote (I think we’ve discussed that one), and OAOW self-hammered the 10th vote to end the day instantly. Rysto said he placed his vote on Diomedes because of Diomedes’s 9th vote.

Aargh. Well, NAF missed your vote too :slight_smile:

OK, Final and I think correct day 1 vote counts, in the correct order:

Mhaye (10): OAOW, zuma, brewha, freudian slit, Diomedes, Hawkeyeop, Kat, Cookies, Pleonast, Hockey Monkey
zuma (4): sachertorte, Mhaye, Hal Briston, HazelNutCoffee
Diomedes (1): storyteller
Hal(1): faithfool
brewha (1): shadowfacts
No Vote (1): Rysto

Day 3 vote counts: (This was the no-lynch day - Brewha was 1 vote short of majority)

brewha (7): sach, Hockey Monkey, Hawkeyeop, fruedian slit, Rysto, Hal, Pleonast
faithfool (2): Diomedes, zuma
Diomedes (2): faithfool, kat
Hawkeyeop(1): Brewha
No Vote (2): HazelNutCoffee, storyteller

I didn’t see faithfool vote for brewha anywhere on day 3.

Day 4 vote counts in the correct order:

Here was the state of voting before story laid out his case against Fruedian Slit if anyone is interested:

brewha (6): Hockey Monkey, freudian slit, hawkeyeop, sachertorte, Diomedes, faithfool
faithfool (2): Pleonast, zuma
Diomedes (1): HazelNutCoffee
Not yet voted: Rysto, storyteller, brewha, Hal

And the final vote count in the correct order:

Freudian Slit (8): storyteller, brewha, zuma, Diomedes, sachertorte, rysto, hawkeyeop, faithfool
brewha (3): Hockey Monkey, Freudian Slit, Pleonast
Diomedes (2): HazelNutCoffee, Hal

Based on an incomplete so far reread, I will most likely place a vote tnmmorow on Hawkeye, Pleonast, faithfool. or Rystn. Voting history will play a part, along with other issues.

I also have issues with the shady accounting department in this company. I think toeays postr will influence my vote a lot.

To be fair to Dio, by the time he made the 9th vote, discussion had come to a standstill. I don’t think we lost anything for ending that day early.

I’ve been stupid busy at work all this week. I don’t have much time to post, but I have been reading.

Right now, I’ve comfortable with a vote for either HockeyMonkey or Pleonast based on their attempts to disuade the Fruedian Slit vote yesterday.

I will be voting for one of them later today - hopefully after more research if I get time.

Hawk, I have been more than fair. I was simply putting all votes out there in context. I had no problem with dios vote. if i did I would have challenged hhm on it…

I would like tn hear from hawk what he thinks of the voting of the part two days. I would also like to hear anything, other than a drive by vote from Rysto.

The past two days? I don’t think we can tell anything from the Brewha voting without knowing if Brewha was scum or not. I analysed the last days’ voting already in a previous post already. My stated conclusion was I found Faithfool’s and Hal Briston’s votes as most suspicious.

We know FS is scum. You can give us your opinion on that vote.

I may have missed your day 4 analysir. Hawk. I Will look tommorow. I still want to hear from Rysto why he should not get my vote today…

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=9390524&postcount=1137

Thanks Hawk. I agree with your thoughts on the faith vote. that is why i put her on my suspect list.

Hi. Sorry, I’ve been absent. I’ve been sick.
I’ll try and catch up tonight and post something of value tomorrow.

To whom it may concern. The memorandum above has undergone post-issuance review by management. The areas addressing an error on the accounting for a vote by faithfool have been scrutinized, and the following position reached.

No vote for brewha was cast by faithfool during Day 3. As a result, no majority, as required for a lynch, was reached during the Day. To the best of our knowledge, no one who should have been lynched has been left unlynched, and no one who should not have been lynched was lynched.

Enjoy,
Steven

Uh, where is everyone? I’m not seeing much going on. We need to lynch three scum in five lynches. Let’s not get apathetic!

Do you really want me to come up with some hare-brained scheme to get everyone riled up?

When does the Day end again? Sorry, I’m really bad at keeping track of dates and times.

I’ll be able to post more after tomorrow evening. It’s just that from Monday-Thursday I’m teaching over a full-time workload, so after being on my feet for hours and grading papers that would make Strunk writhe in his grave, I’m usually burned out once I come home.

Please do… I’m totally at a loss as for whom to vote for.