You-Solve-It Mafia Game

It’s not a threat. And as cliche as it is to say, it’s a fact.

How could your suspicions of me remain despite how the voting went yesterday?

I guess my death might actually be the best thing for the town at this point. No one can get their focus away from me, and it’s killing our chances of winning. Maybe my death will convince the town to look at those who have been on my case.

I’m still not voting for me though.

Yes, but it is a fact with any vote. You have chosen to emphasize it about votes for you many times.

Your vote is one piece of evidence. Of course scum will vote for scum. It doesn’t clear the rest of the case against you. Scum will take protown actions to confuse town members. They are sneaky like that.

Oh Lord, not this Brewha shit again. I think we are playing a very sloppy game right now.

Care to reiterate those 17 reasons? Your case against me was based on me having no unique dossier traits. You then said that me defending myself was too thought out and defensive and that me suggesting that Pleonast copied my public trait was ‘pointing my finger at anyone and everyone’.

I can see one reason - maybe three if you break it down. That’s a far cry from 17.

I fully agree. That’s getting me out of the picture may be the best thing for the town.

I can if you like, but it will take a while. Kind of understaffed here today.

Except that very few of us seem to be looking at the best evidence we have tn date. Actual voting history.

Zuma,

How do you suggest we achieve a majority to ensure that someone gets lynched? I mostly switched my voted to Brewha, so that there would be two viable choices. If everyone votes for one of those two, we will have a majority.

It’s more for your benefit than mine. You are not going to convince me that I’m scum - I know better. But you are the one who tied me for the majority of votes. The other two - Hockey and Faithfool have already stated that they are just voting for me out of habit.

Like I said before, I don’t have reason to believe you are scum. But if I get lynched you will look scummy. That may very well lead to another town getting lynched tomorrow. That is very bad for us.

I want scum to die today - but if that can’t happen, I’ll jump off the cliff just to get the game focused on someone else.

I haven’t seen a good arguement out of you as to why you think I’m scum. I’m pretty sure the town will assume you to be the bad guy if I get lynched and you don’t have a valid reason for voting for me.

Well, according to your logic, I should be voting for you, since I know I’m not scum, and you’re the only other person who’s admitted to that trait. I’m going to stick to what I said before, though - the only dossiers we can trust are those of known town. Which means there is still the possibility that you aren’t scum and the killer has lied about their dossier. So tempting as it is to turn your own logic back on yourself and vote for you, I won’t.

I am also tempted to vote for Pleonast, because his numbers just seem completely arbitrary to me, and I have never agreed with the idea of playing mafia based on percentages and possibilities. However, I must reluctantly concede that a disagreement of gameplay does not necessarily equal scumminess … so again, I am witholding judgement for the time being.

brewha, I’ll just have to repeat what I’ve said before - me forgetting about the game was simply … me forgetting about the game. It was not a conscious decision. I almost wish I’d just asked for a modkill, since it seems impossible for people to get around this. It was just a very hectic time for me, and the game was frequently not on the first page, so the whole thing slipped my mind until I was reminded via PM.

Speaking of getting around something, I am also tempted to vote for brewha simply to get him out of the way so we can move forward. But I don’t believe he’s scum. And this is why I didn’t vote for Freudian Slit. I didn’t believe she was scum! can’t believe you guys are giving me so much grief over that vote. When I voted for Diomedes, it was still well before the end of the Day. The votes against Freudian Slit didn’t build up until after I’d voted, and during the span of hours in which I was unable to log in because of work.

Neither Pleonast nor Diomedes have responded to my arguments. Diomedes simply posted a vote for me without even an explanation. WTF?

I’m

voting Diomedes

for now. I don’t have work today, so I’ll be keeping an eye on the thread - if it looks like there’s going to be a no-lynch I’ll swing my vote to create the necessary majority.

Well I don’t need to convince me either, so I’ll not bother unless anyone else requests.

According to my logic. Hazel, you should not vnte for me. My logic was based on voting records. Not traits. I clearly stated that I chose to use your trait as a tie breaker. My logic is transparent. I did not vote e for you for your trait. I voted for you m your history.

What the hell, let’s try to get this bandwagon rolling.

Vote Dio

I’m standing by for a last-minute switch when it becomes necessary.

Fine. You still used my trait as a factor in your decision. I’ve already explained myself in a previous post, but no one who’s voting for me has deigned to respond. I made ONE freakin’ “throwaway” vote (yesterDay, Diomedes) and apparently that damns me (I refuse to see my vote for you on Day 1 as a
“throwaway” vote since there were four people voting for you; I wasn’t exactly going against the crowd). Well, I’ve already voted for him again, and I’m sticking to it, unless we come to an impasse where it looks like no one is going to get lynched. If sticking to my opinion is what you consider a throwaway vote, then so be it.

Sorry for lack of explanation for the HazelNut vote. Honestly, I’m buying Pleo’s arguments against her more than I’m buying any of the other fairly weak cases runnign around here. I’ve done a 180 on faithfool, and I’ve never been convinced by the ‘lynch brewha’ crowd.

I may have time this weekend to go more in depth about this.

That’s nice, but the deadline for voting is today.

:::sigh:::

unvote Brewha

vote HazelNutCoffee

Well, I said I’d only swing my vote if there was a chance of a no-lynch. Looks like there’s no danger of that, at least. :rolleyes:

Apparently my defense for myself is either deliberately being ignored or is too stupid to even bother responding to. I think my time will be better spent doing my laundry.

Official Count

4 - HazelNutCoffee (Pleo, Dio, zuma, HM)

2 - brewha (faithfool, hawkeye)
2 - Diomedes (HNC, Rysto)

1 - faithfool (sach)
1- Hocky Monkey (brewha)
1- Hawkeyeop (Hal)
One player must recieve 6 votes or there will not be a lynch.
Just under 2 hours and 30 minutes until the deadline.

unvote Brewha

vote Diomedes

Brewha doesn’t seem to be getting much support, so I’ll again switch to the most popular candidate that isn’t Hazel. I think Hazel is town, and I can go either way on Dio. Consider this more a not Hazel vote then anything else.