You-Solve-It Mafia Game

[Hawkeyeop]

@Rysto

Well, I’m annoyed at how this went down – especially considering that NAF said “90 minutes extension at least”, and then cut things off at 60 minutes – but it’s not like the Town deserved to win this one anyway.

ETA: Apparently he said 60. :smack:

I could sworn he said 90 too. Was that edited?

[Pleonast]

@zuma

OK, last post on this game from me… but I have a question for Pleo.

Assuming faith didn’t get modkilled, who would you have killed in the final night? I made the argument in the spoiler thread that if in fact faith came to life, if I were you I’d kill her, based on her being “confirmed” town, and the possibility that the two remaining townies might vote for each other (I forgot the details, but either hawk said he was suspicious of rysto, or vice-versa). I hadn’t considered dossiers, and where that might have led. What was your strategy, if you had one, for the final day?

You can read the scum board to see what I was thinking. In summary: I was intending to kill Hawkeye. I thought my best chances were to play Rysto and faithfool off each other. Set myself up as the Townie who needs to decide between the other two.

[Rysto]

You don’t think that would have been a mistake? faith seemed ready to vote for you on the last Day and I would have known that you were the last scum because faith would have been confirmed Town by her dossier.

[Pleonast]

Maybe. I guess I had the impression that I could convince faith to vote for you. These end-game choices are hard for everyone to make.

[Rysto]

It just seems to me that you wouldn’t even have had to convince Hawk and I to vote for each other.