I saw that movie again just a few days ago, and I had the same problem. Janeane Garofalo is sex on a stick. Uma Thurman… well, she’s pretty much just a stick.
You’re not alone. A lot of guys I know, and myself, perved on her when that show was on. I still find her quite attactive today. She’s aged quite well.
Oh, can’t believe I forgot to say Mayim Bialik. I’ve crushed on her since Blossom. And getting a Ph.D in neuroscience? Funny and good-looking and super-smart? Triple-threat hot!
There’s nothing WTF about her.
And yeah, she’s aging just fine, she can keep it for lots of time.
I am, in my OCD way, driven to offer up Robert Carlyle, Rumpelstiltskin on Once Upon A Time. Mr. Carlyle hasn’t pushed Alan Rickman aside, but they are jostling for position. In my sad little mind!
I heartily concur. However, I can imagine a slight WTF in RiverRunner’s estimate if there is an age gap between himself and Mrs. Richardson. She was, after all, a mature woman during the show’s run, playing a mother of three. A beautiful woman to be sure, but (particularly to a younger man), not necessarily an object of lust. And yet she was and continues to be. 
Alice Cooper (yes, he’s funny looking. He’s also *very *sexy in his AC persona).
Alan Rickman (I’m not sure I’d call him a “WTF?” though. Lots of people have crushes on him)
Gene Wilder, circa “Willy Wonka”
David Hyde Pierce
Jeremy Irons
Julian Sands
I don’t know about a crush, but I would definitely like to give her a hug.
I believe I’ve mentioned my raging crush on Jorge Garcia. I like big boys.
These.
And Miranda July.
Bears an almost disturbing resemblance to my DH, except my DH is still working on getting in shape.