I’m here with a message of hope! My husband of 19 years (been together almost 23) is also a very utilitarian, practical sort of individual. But I have, over the years, been able to train him into acting more intimately, on a regular basis. But your SO has to be secure with himself so he doesn’t take these things as criticisms, and you have to be willing to express and model the behavior you would like.
My husband does not respond to subtlety. If I want something, I have to be very clear about it. If I were in your place, I’d have to say to him (as sex was getting started), “You know what would be great? If after we were finished, you would just lie here with me a while and hold me”. If he reacts well to that, you can make other suggestions (“You know, it would mean a lot to me if you would express appreciation for me sometimes”).
As far as expressing appreciation, when my hubby doesn’t do it but I think it’s due, I approach it with humor. Some years ago, I started signing my emails to him “UW”. Eventually, he asked me what it meant, and I responded “Ultimate Wife”.
So now, when I think I’ve done something that deserves appreciation, I’ll just wink at him and say “Don’t worry about it; it’s all part of being Ultimate”, or “Being Ultimate isn’t easy; it’s just that I’m so good at it I make it look that way. Kinda like those olympic skaters”.
We relate to one another on a level of humor a lot. Of course, that’s what we do because it’s what works for us. Your relationship is pretty new, and you two have to find what works for you!
What absolutely does not work is being coy or disingenuous in hopes he’ll figure you out. If he’s the practical, utilitarian type, you’ll do much better just asking for what you want! The really good news is, if he’s practical, he can be taught that there’s a reward to behaving in certain ways, and those rewards will reinforce the behavior you desire.
As a last caveat, I have to say that you have to be willing to make some changes, too. Long term relationships don’t work without compromise.
Best of luck!