In your opinion, what are the marks of being ‘needy’, in a relationship context?
Requiring the partner to provide things that a healthy, well-balanced person can provide for themselves.
Examples include: Constantly requiring that the partner compliments them on their appearance as opposed to looking in the mirror themselves and deciding that they look good. Wanting the partner to be with them 24/7, instead of learning how to be comfortable being alone from time to time. Asking the partner to perform a task they are capable of performing themselves.
You haven’t asked, but I think this can come from two ways:
- One person starts off being needy, and seeks to be controlled by a stronger person
- One person is controlling, and reduces the other person’s esteem to the point where they become needy
***Do you think a needy person will always be like that, in every relationship, as a characteristic of their personality? ***
If they don’t recognise that they are needy, then quite possibly. But all of us change over time with experience and I would say most of us have been needy at some stage in our lives. Let’s face it, as baby’s, we were all needy. We were then (hopefully) taught by our parents and education and society how to be independent adults as we grew up.
***Would you consider ‘neediness’ more like a spectrum: if two people who are further apart on the spectrum are in a relationship, it might become an issue, but if they are in similar spots on the scale then neither will consider the other odd? ***
That’s an interesting question.
For your first part, where people are far apart on the spectrum, it could go either way. A non-needy person could feel quite happy that they are doing things for their partner. But over time, I would expect the neediness to increase. Not doing something for yourself makes the idea of doing it for yourself much more scary, so over time I would expect the needy person to become needier. This could result in the non-needy person feeling resentful, that they are doing ‘more than their share’ for the relationship.
If both the people are needy, and are able to meet each others needs, then could they be living happy lives? A part of me thinks no, because there are always going to be situations where a person needs to stand on their own two feet, such as the workplace, where the other partner cannot be present.
Do you ever feel like you’re acting ‘needy’ in certain situations or with certain people, even if you wouldn’t generally call yourself a needy person? If so, does this bother you?
I go through confident and unconfident periods, and during the unconfident periods, I am needier than when I am confident. But I think that’s quite natural.
There is a particular situation where I am needy, and that is talking on the phone. I hate talking on the phone, i feel extremely uncomfortable, and so my husband generally answers the phone.
Conversely, when people act needy towards you, or do you find it burdensome?
I appreciate that there are times when people go through needy periods, depending on what else is happening in their lives. My friend lost her mother, and needed extra support and attention. That is natural. That was not a burden, that was part of being a good friend.
However, someone who is needy in many aspects of their life, when there is no external reason for being that way, that can annoy me.
I think if the way you live your life is being impaired by your mental health, then you should seek help for that, in the same way you should seek medical help if your life is being impaired by a physical illness. In both situations, I feel frustrated if people do not seek the help they need.