Little late, but I wanted to chime in on the Bears activity. I was tied up in an offsite all day yesterday and missed all the FA fury and only saw the Bears move via a ESPN text without details. Now I see they landed Bennett for 4 years at $20M and Bushrod for 5 years at $36M.
My immediate reactions:
-
Yay! We got help at our two most desperate need positions, potentially the top two FA at their respective positions, and now can really go BPA in the 1st round.
-
Shit! How the hell are they going to afford these guys?
Taking the second point first, the Bears were only about $3.5M under the cap prior to yesterday and had Urlacher, Izzy, Louis, Roach and several other role players unsigned. I’m sure these are somewhat cap friendly deals but they are probably at least somewhere in the $8M-$10M range for a cap hit. Today they cut Kellen Davis to save $2.4M, and its possible that Spaeth, Bush and a few others will be gone soon too but none of those contracts free up enough to match this and sign other guys.
This means that either a few veterans are going to need to take pay cuts or restructure or else there’s going to be some house cleaning on defense. Peppers is the big nut and a restructure isn’t going to be helpful. Both Tillman and Jennings could be in line for extensions to reduce their cap numbers. Melton could sign a long term deal with a friendlier cap hit in 2013. Still, I think someone important might have to go. Wonder if there’s any chance the Bears cut bait on Forte, probably would hurt more than help due to acceleration but he’s another big number that’s overpaid.
Back to the positive, these signings are excellent news. Bennett is a huge upgrade over Davis in all phases and so long as he’s the Giants version and not the Cowboys version he’s worth every penny of that $2.6M premium we’re paying over Davis. TE is obviously a glaring weakness for the Bears and this fills it in the best way possible, I disliked the idea of drafting Eiffert or Ertz in the first on general principles and he’s a much better value than either Cook or Walker. I’m curious if the Bears will look for a rookie TE in the later rounds as insurance or if they’ll keep Spaeth and/or Adams. Sounds like it could be Rodriguez and Bennett out there in 2 TE sets which I like a lot.
Of even greater impact is the Bushrod signing. I admit to not having a real great feel for how good Bushrod is and statistically he’s a minor upgrade over Webb, but for what it’s worth he’s been nominated to 2 Pro Bowls on a really dynamic, pass happy offense. My gut (maybe this is the Cubs fan in me leaking out) tells me that the stats understate the value of Bushrod in NOLA, in that system under last years circumstances with nary a double team to help he was solid, with a West Coast system he should be much better than Webb. Plus he run blocks and doesn’t get flagged. I worry he’s overpaid and I may have preferred Long if healthy, but overall I think this is a positive move.
Webb will almost certainly be retained and tried either as the starter on the right side or as the swing simply because he’s cheap and still has potential to improve. I’m guessing Scott is gone (unless he signs for league minimum) and Carimi’s move to OG will be permanent. Spencer is certainly not coming back and it’s possible that Garza gets cut too if they think Williams can step in and save a few bucks. I’d still love to see the Bears land Cooper in the draft with that 20th pick (or find a steal in the mid-to-late rounds) and bolster the inside of the line, but this signing really alleviates the temptation to reach on a OT like Fluker or Watson.
The Bears still have a lot of work to do, resigning their own and maybe grabbing a mid-range WR or LB, but the real question will be if anyone is going to get cut as a result of this.