A Joke or Just Not Funny?

I’m getting sick of a trend in MPSIMS:

People are telling jokes, but they DON’T explain the joke, generating a bunch of puzzled responses.

Krusty does this here , but he’s by no means the only one.

Yes, I didn’t understand it. Yes, it went right over my head (and I’m not the only one who didn’t). Yes, I’m getting pissed by this trend. And, once I got someone to explain the joke to me, yeah, it was very funny. Until then, it was as much not funny as if he’d posted thread titled “My Dog Has No Nose”, just to see the groans. And he’s by no means the only person who’s done this.

And it isn’t sour grapes about the fact that I didn’t understand it, I’ve displayed a total lack of humour about this before, see here .

I wanna know, jokers, how exactly, it undermines the artistry of your humour to post a full explanation of the joke after your post? The first reason that would come to mind, if I didn’t consider the otherwise exemplary nature of the posters doing this, is that if you do, you won’t get the a puzzled reaction from other posters who are too thick to figure out the joke. Which, pretty much, is what the standard definition of not being funny is. (I was wondering if Krusty just wasn’t funny anymore in the other thread).

I know the people doing this don’t have being unfunny as their intent, but intent doesn’t matter in this case. I think it’s just a habit, but it’s a habit it’s long past time to break.

I’m NOT saying to stop these joke threads, they’re funny and humourous once you explain the joke, I’m just saying “Explain the joke in the OP so backward densoids with no sense of humour can be in on it.”

Futile, prepared for being called a backward densoids.

CAN THIS PLEASE STOP? ALL OF THIS? PLEASE?

Futile you backward densoids

Don’t you realize how much work it takes to write a successful, genuinely humorous joke? Here’s a hint: try it some time, and see how long it takes you.

Of course, if you ever took the effort to write one of these jokes you’d know this. Until you do, you don’t get an opinion.

A parody of a thread about a parody of a thread.

Hmm…seems like it should be funny, but somehow it isn’t.

Hee hee hee.

A parody thread about a thread about parodies. How stiflingly original and groundbreaking.

:: yawn ::

But…you kill the humor if you explain the joke.

Dammit, there’s physics behind Moe poking Larry in the eyes…but it’s better to just watch it happen.

Ferrous, get off my brain, willya? :smiley:

A complaint about a parody thread about a thread about parodies being unoriginal. How staggeringly original and groundbreaking.

Like, not even first one in the thread.

::yawn::

Yawning’s so passé.

Wow. Repeating my post, changing the wording somewhat. What an interesting… well, non-defense. Ain’t never seen that one before! Proves to me, Futile Gesture, that you’re living up to your username.

Perhaps a colorful metaphor is called for.

Wow. Opening up, re-reading and posting again to a thread you’ve already complained to have seen and heard all before. What an interesting… well, way to attain a whole new level of deja vu. Bet you’ve seen this one before too! Proves to me, Zanshin, that you’ve nothing better to do.

Nope. Just proves I’m sick of unfunny parody threads. They’re becoming the 2002 SDMB equivalent of ‘all your base belong to us’.

Is posting in threads that make you sick the message board equivalent of bulimia?

Zanshin, you rule.

Your parody of a curmudgeon is second to none!

This is all some sort of parody, isn’t it? I’m so confused…

I agree, barking would be better. Wait, did anyone get my joke or do I have to explain it?

-pinky

Implying that people are too stupid to get your highbrow humor. That’s SO five minutes ago.

So this is a parody of a parody of a parody of a parody? Figuring out Greek mythological family trees is easier.