Here’s my review of HP5, from my LJ:
[spoiler]I thought the movie was…OK. As good as movies generally are, when they are smack dab in the middle of a series. Harry was extraordinarily whiny in the book so I was pleased to have a lot of that cut out of the movie…but they also cut out a lot of things I was looking forward to or thought were vital. In a way it makes me wonder if it isn’t narrowing down Book 7 a bit too much. Ah well, only a few more weeks before we find out.
I think they totally skimped out on the Order of the Phoenix. Tonks got very little screen time and even less dialogue but they sure made her a hottie. Same with Luna, although they gave her some good screen time. But I think they missed on showing how much the other kids made fun of her. And I really missed the part where Harry gives her newspaper the private interview.
I find the glasses thing of Harry’s to be positively charming - waking up and immediately reaching for glasses. It’s one of the few times I’ve seen a realistic depiction of full-time glasses wearing. Usually people just put them on in movies or TV to look good. Real glasses wearers - like myself and my SO - do reach for them first thing as soon as they awaken.
The Howler to Petunia should have been kept in.
They did what they could. The movie was what, two hours long? I think if they had made it even 2.5, it would have made a difference. They completely cut out Kreacher’s role, and made him just a weird, silly little elf, and they cut out Luna’s lovely comment about the dead being just on the other side of the veil. I thought that was important.
Other than that I am waiting for Book 7 and anxiously waiting for the next two movies, however last I checked imdb says they will not be done until 2010. Do you know how old Ron Harry and Hermoine will look by then?
We did like crazy Bellatrix, though. She did a good job.
They missed a lot of the jokes also. I certainly don’t think it was the best of the bunch. I still think that was the first one, which had a clear story arc, defined ending, and was the most eye-opening since it was all new to us. [/spoiler]