Because Joanna Pacitti got booted: American Idol 8 Dumps Joanna Pacitti
[Scott] Can we stop talking about his challenges? Blech. Admit it, it wasn’t great.
Why are they focusing on his piano skills? Not fair!
He blew his chance IMO although the false sympathy vote will probably get him through.
It looks like the judges are really trying to sell him for the story value. I don’t mind, I guess. I like him ok. I just don’t think he’s turning out to be a musical genius or anything. Maybe I expect too much of blind musicians.
Not bad, but not great.
Sigh.
Maybe she should do one for the boys.
Kendall
I’m not much into country, but I have to say she sounds really good. Maybe the best of the night.
Seriously? Kendall’s yellow trash bag with a dried flower arrangement at the waist is the best outfit of the night?
Simon hates country as much as I do. He never knows how to critique it.
I think you were listening with your eyes.
I loved Paula’s comment about how she hoped Kendall liked it on stage, because I felt the implication was, “Because it’s your last time there.”
I don’t either. I can’t get past the lyrics to critique the singing. I’m a girl and I don’t “wish on a shooting star”. :rolleyes:
He has a beautiful voice.
He needs to work a little harder on his pronunciation. If they hadn’t emphasized it on his promo, then maybe I might not have noticed so much.
I’m voting for him because I like him.
Jorge has given me chills for the second time this season. I think he’s my favorite. He has a spectacular voice.
So far tonight, only three men have impressed me. All the girls can be kicked.
- Jorge
- Blind Guy
- Black guy with funny name and cute son.
Yes, that’s what I call them.
Yeah! That was funny.
I remember during the auditions being annoyed that they went to Puerto Rico and then bagged on people for having Spanish accents.
I thought Jorge was pitchy in parts, but ok.
She’s all overwith MJB’s song.
I expected more.
Bad song choice.
I can’t believe they loved it so much.
I’m not watching, just listening and I wasn’t impressed.
They script their responses before the show, and they already know who they’re going to pimp. Paula got exposed a little bit last year when she got mixed up and critiqued a song before it had been sung.
My predictions to go through to the finals: Scott, Jorge, Lil.