Are Moderaters Moderate?

I’m now here. (How long can I keep using this excuse?)

I lurked for a year before posting.

In the Pit, Uncle Beer, one of the Moderators, shot at another user, “No Shit, Dick Tracy.”

I don’t get it…

I respect the right of the Moderators to post their own opinions on real issues. But how does it serve the BBS for Moderators to post rudely?

I highly respect those moderators who will say “moderator hat on… moderator hat off…” to make sure that their opinions are separate from their regulatory actions.

But isn’t it incumbent upon a Moderator to behave in a moderate manner, and to refrain from succumbing to the temptation to shoot from the hip with a facile slur?

To be sure, the person Uncle Beer took the shot at was being a jerk… But isn’t the role of a Moderator to help pour oil on troubled waters? I asked Uncle Beer, “How does this help?” He answered, “What makes you think I was trying to help.”

But isn’t that his job?

I lurked the SDMB for a year, and started posting only with great trepidation. This is a slam-dunk, no-holds-barred, knock-down, drag-out, smash-and-grab debate area…and my own preferences are more sedate…

On the other hand, there’s more collective knowledge here than in any ten encyclopedia! So I think I’ll hang around for a while!

Best regards,
Trinopus

Can Manhatten swear while closing a thread?

(this is only the 4th time I’ve used this joke)

Boy, can he! I mean, CAN HE EVER!

Happy

Since this is not about the message board, but about the administration of the board, it belongs in the Pit.

Off to the Pit.

DrMatrix - Your Moderate Moderator

Link to the thread Enough; please!(mild) by the clown MachineHead, to which this OP refers.

Sure.

But their job description doesn’t mention anything about being sickly-sweetly nice to any motherfucker that comes down the pike.

The thing I don’t understand is how UncleBeer can say that Machinehead’s compalint is valid, while also bleiveing he was just trolling.

Provide a link to what you’re talking about, please, Aslan2.

In this thread , in reference to MachineHead pitting Brian Ekers.
Last post, cannot link it because it’s closed.

I still don’t follow.

UncleBeer only posted a single word to the thread. I’m not trying to argue with you, I just can’t work out what you’re talking about.

Wrong thread.

Sorry.

Correct thread

We don’t call them moderators because they are moderate (the noun), it’s because they moderate (the verb, meaning they keep the board on an even keel, not necessarily themselves).

And as already discussed in the other thread- the poster in question opened a MPSIMS version of a PIT thread he wasn’t doing so well in. This was a bad idea, and a violation for the forum descriptions. Unclebeer was pretty mild with him actually.

Neither do I. Shouldn’t that be, “No Shit, Sherlock”?

I thought UncleBeer’s responses were very measured compared to what MachineHead probably deserved.

He for damn sure had me laughing out loud in a thread that needed some levity.

Okay, I guess I still have a lot to learn…

(But that’s why I’m here, right?)

Trinopus

Yeah, that’s what I thought. But he also says weird things like “making winkies” as a euphemism for peeing. Something’s seriously wrong with him.

Interesting observation from someone with all of three posts.

A lot of anger? Heh, good one.

Again, read Ethilrist’s comment and welcome here!