I did. I also told him he was acting like an asshole. I never have to mince words with that group.
It’s… This is what happened. A buddy of ours had a very friendly, open-style writers group that often got bogged down with people showing up who had no idea what the hell they were doing and didn’t really have the commitment to follow through. They were just wasting time for more serious writers, but he insisted on being super inclusive of everyone. There’s no delicate way to put this… the buddy who created this group is now terminally ill. A few months ago, he handed over leadership to Group Leader and is now too sick to manage the group.
At that point, there were 4-5 of us who were regularly. seriously involved in the group. We all agreed we wanted something more focused on craft and that it would probably be better off juried. We made decisions together about what the new group would look like. This created a form of intimacy that can’t easily be reproduced. We regularly talk to one another outside of group, we’ve formed friendships, we know deeply personal things about one another, we swap stories all the time, we’ve seen multiple drafts of the same thing, and we can be brutally honest about each other’s writing without damaging relationships with one another. We’ve become very close very quickly, but we are a dark-humored, sarcastic, frequently inappropriate bunch of goofballs that people could totally read the wrong way if they didn’t know all the mushy stuff underneath.
This has absolutely affected group culture. There are about ten of us now, and I think our honesty is one of the best things we have to offer. But our threshold for taking offense is so high within that group that it can be difficult to tell initially if someone is crossing the line, or lines can get crossed more easily. And when lines are crossed it’s easier to repair them because we have this foundation of friendship and loyalty and mutual support. New Kid had no context for any of this. On his first day, I was feeling super feisty, came right out the gate with a pretty harsh comment toward Group Leader’s piece, (Something like ‘‘Sometimes you write with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer’’) and the kid jumped right on it and interpreted it as some kind of free-for-all to insult people’s work. That wasn’t it, he just didn’t have the context, but that wasn’t his fault.
I blamed myself for all the animosity people suddenly had toward New Kid because I was the one who set the tone with that comment. Apparently, his redline critique comments were really rude, too, but it’s not like we’re all sunshine and light with each other. So I’ve been trying to set it right ever since, and everyone, including Asshole Friend, has been telling me it’s not my responsibility to fix. I think I’ve actually been making it worse by trying to fix it. Maybe it would otherwise blow over.
I’ve never really been such a big part of a group like this, it’s teaching me a lot about group dynamics I never really had to consider or understand.
That’s what I said. For clarification, the ‘‘kid’’ is 25. He’s an adult also, just younger than a lot of those guys in the group. But he’s definitely a new writer. And it’s total bullshit to accept someone into the group and then treat them like a 2nd class member. I’ve made my feelings on this crystal clear.