'Bam!' this, you loud-mouthed, shrill Portuguese jackass!

I like to cook. I enjoy cooking. I’m actually pretty good. The only thing I’ve never mastered is the art of Cooking for One. I usually end up with enough leftovers for three or four meals, which is too much of any one dish. Anyway, I’ve got a buddy who I regularly invite over for dinner. Said friend doesn’t/won’t cook. If it weren’t for me and the occasional visit to his parent’s house, he’d live on McDonald’s Hamburgers and The meat and dessert portions of T.V. dinners. I figure I’m helping to keep him alive and he’s willing to chip in on the cost and do the dishes. Plus he’s an enthuiastic eater. Anyway, I’m grilling some wild-rice and dried apple stuffed lamb-chops and he’s channel surfing. He calls me into the other room. “Hey Fenris! Look at that.” he says, and gestures to the T.V. wherein Emril, Food Network’s alleged 'cook" and the aforementioned Mush-Mouthed, Shrill Portuguese Asshole is doing his little “flabby fanny” dance on the Cooking Channel (he wiggles his butt at the camera while poking his index fingers in the air). My appetite goes. If only he could bottle that dance and sell it to slim-fast.

“BAM!” Emril shrieks. “Pawhk Fat RULEZ!!” His audience shrieks in near-orgasmic delight. Emril moans in a disturbingly sexual way “OOooOOOohh yuh! Bay-bee! Uhhhnh! I LUV Gahlik! Let’s aahd abowt 500 cloves!” he tosses about 15 garlic cloves into a pan of smouldering green beans and rendered bacon grease. He’s got the pan too hot. The garlic immediatly turns black. The food will not be good.

“How come you don’t cook like that?” my friend says, apparently in all innocense.

I am puzzled. “What? Make green beans soaked in bacon grease with pecans and burned garlic? Because I’m trying to lose some weight and it looks disgusting. What do you care? You don’t eat vegetables anyway.”

“No” he says. “Why don’t you cook like that.” he gestures to the T.V. I stare, agahst. Emril now is doing a little mock ballet dance. He’s standing en pointe and tossing in his “Essence” from his fingertips towards the pan from about 10 feet away; a fat, ugly sugarplum fairy sprinkling, not pixie dust, but rather an unpleasantly pungent mixture of spices onto the floor. Some small fraction is getting into the pork-fat fried green beans. “LET’S KICK IT UP TO NOTCHES UNKNOWN!” he howls for the 10th time in 8 minutes, preparing overspice yet another dish.

EVERY goddamned friend I’ve got who ISN’T a cook thinks that Emril is how cooking “should” be done. Not as a mixture of creativity and skill but as professional wrestling mixed with slapstick comedy.

And to make matters worse, Emril’s a phoney. He has a fake “Bahaston” accent that he constantly drops when he’s not paying attention (“I wanna ‘awhsk’ youse sumthin’.”), his recipes don’t work (I’ve tried several…in each one that I’ve tried he drastically overestimated the amount of spice needed and underestimated the liquid.), his diction’s terrible and he keeps burning his food.

The two or three catch-phrases he has are just barely amusing the first ten thousand time you hear them (“Pawhk Faht RULEZ!”, “Dis ain’t like dem utter late night tawhk shows!”, “Dis ain’t rahket science”, “Let’s kick it up annudder notch!”). The Food Network could save money by hireing a parrot to repeat the catch-phrases and get a chimp to burn the ingredients. They’d certainly be as compentent as Emril. And far less annoying.

Emeril can’t even cook properly, given the percentage of food that he accidentally blackens. A few weeks ago he made some sort of fritters. He was busy playing with the audience and smoke started to come out of the fryer. He pulled out some fritter briquettes. This is typical. There’s also something disturbingly Oedipal about the way he talks to his mother “Hilder” even when ‘Hilder’ ain’t dere. (“Hey! Hilder! How’d’yuh like da way I do dis chiffonade dis basil? I’m doin’ it fah youse, Hilder! Fah YOUSE!”)

And his mother (Hilder) is scary. She’s shaved her eyebrows and pencilled new, fake ones on about three inches too high, giving her a perpetually surprised/Snow White’s evil queen (but less regal and more toad-like) look.

Why do people watch this moron? They obviously are, because the Food Network has him on every two hours (“ALL EMRIL ALL THE TIME!”).

AAARGH! Bring back Julia Child, David Rosengarten, The Two Fat Ladies, The Two Hot Tamales! Give us more Iron Chef (“ALLEZ CUSINE!”). Anyone but Emril (and that smarmy punk Bobby Flay…but that’s another rant).

Bam this, Emril you asshole.

Fenris

Thank you for a rant well written. Emeril reminds me of the bad guy in Spawn. What a evil little bahastahd.

BAM!! You hit it exactly as I see it.
I went to cooking school and if I had tried any of those stunts, the instructor would have broken a spoon across my head-- I’m NOT kidding.
My kids like the bammer 'cause he’s fun to look at esp. if you don’t care about food.
I want to see more of Alton Brown and “Good Eats”.
Here is a chef who knows that while being funny is good, it is no replacemnt for sound cooking techniques. I have prepared many of his dishes and they work.

So FoodTV: More Good Eats!!

The only problem I have with the cooking shows on TV is when they bake. In Denver, things cook a bit differently than they do at, say, 200 feet ASL. It’s always a riot trying to figure out how much extra flour to add, or how much longer to cook it.

I happen to like him. It’s not the great chef’s of San Fransico, but he has his place.

Even you have to admidt, he’s been able to tap a market top-heavy with Julia Childs’, Martha Stewarts’, and the frugal gourmet.

Oh, wait, what was that I heard about the frugal gourmet tenderizing the behinds of little young…

Anyrate, he adds a bit to the fray that can get often get a bit pompus and arrogant.

I still watch Emeril now and then but I don’t like him as much as I used to. He’s gotten really full of himself, I think. His overuse of catch phrases makes him seem like he’s taking the audience reaction totally for granted-- oooh, can we make the “Fork a lemon” joke one more time? I don’t think I got the subtle innuendo the first 17,000 times.

It’s a shame, because he used to be a lot of fun. Gotta agree with MikeG, Good Eats rocks.

Wow, Fenris. That was quite a rant. I’m impressed. Or, I guess I would be if it wasn’t for one thing: You’re totally fucking wrong.

I can understand if you don’t like his persona. He’s brash and enthusiastic. He’s over the top. If you don’t like the way he’s acting, that’s great. I can respect that.

But don’t ever, ever even think something like “Emeril can’t even cook properly”. He used to be the executive chef at Commander’s freaking Palace, for the love of God. Do you have any idea what that means?

And then MikeG goes on about Alton Brown. Alton Brown?!? Hey, I love Alton to death. He’s got a great show. He’s funny and hip. But to call him a paragon of technical ability is stretching things a bit. I mean, this is the guy who repeatedly tells us “A pint is a pound the world around.” Uh, sorry, Alton, but it’s not. And MikeG, you may have been hit over the head with a spoon if you tried Emeril’s stunts, but that’s because you were a peon student. He’s not.

So, Fenris, rant all you want about the mannerisms you don’t like. But don’t question his ability to cook. He’s forgotten more about cooking that you’ll ever know.

BTW, Emeril’s from Fall River, Massachusetts. I’m not sure how far that is from Boston, but his accent might not be all fake.

I, Cheffie, COMPLETELY agree that Emeril must be stopped. He is the culinary equivalent of a professional wrestler.

And the ironic thing is, he must have SOME talent as a chef or his restaurants wouldn’t have been doing huge business even before he pranced onto the TV Food Network. But it doesn’t show on the screen. He may be a good chef, but he’s a terrible TV chef.

He doesn’t give amounts, he mentions ingredients and then doesn’t use them (and worse, he sometimes uses ingredients that he didn’t tell you you were going to need), he crop-dusts that spice mixture of his on everything like he’s a tomcat spraying a fence post… and he performs important steps of the recipe while the show is on a fucking COMMERCIAL BREAK. grinds teeth

And that lobotomized studio audience acts like he’s James Fucking Beard and Escoffier rolled into one. Probably the only chef they were ever familiar with before Emeril was Chef Boyardee, and they mistake his embarrassing antics for professionalism. I clicked past his “show” once and he was making oysters bienville… he said, “Okay, here’s how I’d plate this…” and all he did was put a few leafy greens on the plate and arrange the oysters in a circle, and the crowd oohed and ahhed like he had repainted the ceiling of the Sistine chapel and replaced God with Elvis and Adam with JFK. YOU FUCKING SHEEP! You better not be in that studio if Emeril ever decides to cook mutton.

I realize that my criticisms only apply if you take the admittedly long leap of assuming “Emeril Live” is actually a cooking show at all. But come on, people, it’s the FOOD Network, not the FOOL network.

They need to give a show to ME. I was fucking BORN to be a cooking-show host. Who’ll back me? I promise to deliver an entertaining show that will actually teach people how to MAKE something.

My teeth start grinding every time I see him while surfing channels.

One of my major irks about him is his penchant for taking a perfectly decent dish and BAMMing the crap out of it with extraneous gew-gaws that have no place whatsoever!

Maybe he was/is a good chef. Now he’s so full of himself and so adored by the audience/sheep that who knows whether he’s any good?

Hooray for the suggestiong of bringing back the Two Fat Ladies (however, with Jennifer’s death last year that will be a bit difficult).

I’m getting hooked into Iron Chef now, which sometimes has the ‘train wreck’ quality to it. I can’t bear to look away, and often it’s painful to watch. Perhaps it’s the inane English voice-overs? The translation?

Watching something like The Bocuse D’Or, where the focus is on tremendously skilled professional chefs who often study and train for years to attend the event, affords true awe.

P.S. Mr. Miliana is a chef - he nearly hurls every time Emeril starts his shtick.

Have you ever made one of his recipes? I have. More than once. Having followed the exact measurements, adjusting for altitude if necessary(I’m in Denver and have been doing altitude adjustments for 20+ years) I’ve never ONCE made an Emril recipe that works. There’ve been a few I can salvage. I’ve never had this problem with any other professional chef’s recipes. One example: He had an apple-custard pie (no longer available on Food TV’s web site. And I can’t check the print-out of the recipe so the amounts I give will be approximate) in which he said to dissolve (but not melt!) 2 cups of brown sugar in 2 tablespoons of apple juice, then heat. You can’t. Period. Sure you can melt the brown sugar, but that’s not what the recipe called for. It specifically said “Dissolve”. In another, for some sort of Manhattan style seafood chowder, he said to put two TABLEspoons of Cayenne pepper into about 2 pints of broth. He obviously meant two teaspoons (or less). Julia Child once said “Writing a recipe is like writing a short story”. With Emril’s random measurements and obscure instructions, it’s more like free verse.

And I’ll agree, he’s forgetten lots about cooking. of course, he KEEPS forgetting about cooking, hence all his burned dishes that show up on his show.

I admit that, given his professional history, he may be a competent chef when he’s not showboating for an audience, but as a TV Chef, he sucks.

Fenris

PS: Miliana-Iron Chef is great. Give it a few weeks, get into the BDJ’s (Bimbo Du Jour’s) inane comments ("<giggle> It’s like I’m floating on a dreamy cloud when I’m asleep"), marvel at the intense DRAMA and you’ll be hooked. And Iron Chef French (Sakai) has the best presentations of any chef I’ve ever seen. Far better than Emril’s “Spoon the glop in the middle of the plate then sprinkle the outside with essence”

Emeril is annoying. I really like Good Eats as I like to understand the science behind the techniques.

IRON CHEF absolutely rules!!!
See http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=38327

I AM getting way too into Iron Chef for my own good. We’re talking cheering back to the TV and such nonsense!

Every time the resident “Actress” has a comment I always chime out at the end (using her voice, natch), “And I want to sleep with you.”

You’d be surprised how often using that tag line makes sense with the inane crap she spouts.

Which does get me to wondering - are the English translations exact or are they loose approximations? If so, the Japanese totally excel at double entendres.

Iron Chef French is extremely talented - his presentations are always lovely.

What I’d really pay to see is one of the Iron Chefs taking a cleaver to that thick-necked stumpy ass Emeril…

<snip>
I like it!

You should see what I.C. Japan did to that smarmy, preening little twerp Bobby Flay. Morimoto opened an industrial sized can of ass-whup and served it up cold to Booby. (At one point, Flay stood up on his cutting board and did a little premature victory dance, Morimoto commented that he wasn’t a chef, he was a clown since chefs have respect for the tools of their trade)

I’d love to see Sakai (I.C. French) or Chen (I.C. Chinese) go up against Emril too.

Fenris

You guys and gals are missing the point of “Emeril Live” (note the difference–if you want to see Emeril cook “correctly,” watch “Essence of Emeril”) which is to make cooking good food fun. He’s got a band, he’s got a live audience, and a limited amount of time in which to make several dishes. I’m a cook, and a damn good one, if I do say so myself, and I enjoy watching him. Sure, he overdoes the show and the catchphrases, but he has a good time. Most of the others on there–especially David Rosengarten(what a pompous asshole)–make cooking look like interior decorating, or oil painting, or some other kind of pansy, boring, artsy crap. Emeril’s more like Rosey Greer on Captain Kangaroo doing needlepoint. Some of you will remember that one. It’s fun, it’s cool, and you eat well after you do it.

BTW, if you’ve not made up a batch of essence, I suggest you do so. It’s far better than most of the Cajun spice mixes on the market. Oh, yeah, as for the recipes on-line…do you think a guy with a nightly live show and 8 or 10 restaurants has time to publish his recipes?

Anyhow, he’s a lot less condescending than either Alton Brown or the “Food 911” guy. What a pair of putzes.

Thanks, stofsky. You, at least, seem to get it.
Actually, Fenris, I haven’t made any of his recipies that are up on TVFN’s website. But, as stofsky pointed out, I suspect he doesn’t write those down anyway. I doubt he has even been on their website, judging from the way he refers to it.

I have, however, made some of the recipies in his books, and they do seem to work. Maybe I just got lucky. But then, I use few measurements. I kinda know what works and what doesn’t. Sometimes I’ll glance over recipies to get a sense of proportion, but that’s about it. I pretty much never follow them to the letter. That probably comes from a lot of cooking I’ve done out of Pro Chef, where if you follow all the measurements, you end up with something like 85 gallons of mashed potatoes.

You’re in Denver? So am I. We can get together and fight over it. :slight_smile: Or cook.

You’re all full of shit and PORK FAT DOES RULE!!! Anyone south of Maryland knows it does!

We like Emeril because he’s fun. Jeff Smith was fun. (Before he got caught having fun.) Graham Kerr was fun. Even Julia Child was fun. Emeril doesn’t need your approval, he made over 3 million dollars last year and opened a new restaraunt in Vegas. I think he’s done wonders for cooking myself. He helps take the “mystery” out of it. His live show isn’t technical but I don’t see YOU filling auditoriums full of people to watch you cook! I’ve used some of his recipes from the website. Usually if I see something I like I just remember and improvise. I don’t bake so copying a cake wouldn’t be my thing anyway. I adapted one of his potato salad recipes and everyone asks for it all the time now.

He also does not seem in the least bit arrogant to me. Bobby Flay, now that’s an asshole. So is that hick he “grills” with. I happen to like David Rosengarten too, but to me he’s more of an eater than at cook. You can keep the Iron Chef, it’s like watching a Godzilla movie, it gets on my nerves. We like Mario, he’s a little on the preachy side but his dishes are often simple and he seems to know his stuff.

You better not let my daughter hear you say anything bad about Emeril. We’re hashing out now where she’s gonna go to school when she graduates. She wants to go to the Culinary Arts Institute in Fall River. I want her to go to Johnston and Wales in Norfolk. It’s only an hour and a half away. I keep telling her that Emeril went to Johnston and Wales. Of course she was a Jeff Smith fan when she was only 7.

Like I heard Emeril say once on an interview when he was criticized for his crazy behavior…“It’s only a cooking show.” Well now he’s got people watching that didn’t know a capon from a bucket of Kentucky Fried Chicken.

Needs2know

Like Cheffie said, I’ve found my people…

My beef with the Big E is that he really does go for the lowest common denominator in his show. His audience is for people who do not know how to cook. As a culinary student, I sometimes watch him for things not to do in a kitchen.

Necros, obviously, you’ve never been in the industry. What Emeril does in front of TV cameras would never be done in a professional kitchen. I watched him make a salmon mousse that was to be finished off with a little vodka. He poured in a shot’s worth into the food processor, and said, “hey, what the hell” and poured in another two shots worth into the mix, to the delight of his studio audience. An executive chef would have smacked a sous chef with a spoon (if not fired him for being a wasteful ass for ruining a batch of salmon mousse) for doing the exact same thing. I know that the comment was not directed towards me, but as a peon culinary student that puts in 7 hours a day in a kitchen, along with 3 hours a night of homework to make sure if you ever walk into my restaurant that you walk away satisfied, along with not dying of food poisoning: fuck you and the horse you rode in on.

Yes, Emeril plays for the TV, but he has been executive chef of Commander’s Palace and has opened up a few places of his own, meaning that he obviously does have something there. But, just because he’s an executive chef does not mean he’s also the best cook–he’s probably hired hundreds of line cooks that have more real experience and talent that he does. Some people make it to executive chef because they have the stamina to handle the hours, and the management ability to run a restaurant–it’s not always the best cook that makes it there. An executive chef oversees the books, hires & fires, prices & develops menus–not just cooking.

I have to agree with Fenris about the recipes–my mother gave me one of his cookbooks for Christmas, and by Gawd–half of the recipes are unintelligable. He needs to fire his cookbook writer and find someone who can write out recipes that can be used–and that work.

Food Network should cut down on their Emeril usuage, it drags them down. They need to throw in some new faces–or some old ones: Julia Child, Madeline Kamman, Jacques Pepin (I just received a copy of his La Technique, which has been out of print for years… you wanna talk 'bout someone who knows what they’re doing…), heck, let’s get a show going for Cheffie. I know he’d make a better cooking show host than the big E, any day.

[mildly related hijack]

That guy sounds really bad but I don’t think that, in terms of sheer vomit inducing stupidity, he can match up to the one, the only Ainsley Harriot. He’s an English TV Chef who is so damn hyperactive it looks like he’s snorted a line of speed as long as a rush hour traffic jam.
He presents a show called “Can’t cook, Won’t cook”, more commonly known as “Can’t cook, Don’t give a toss” and is full of bizarre, nonsensical and downright annoying catchphrases (“Oh Ainsley, Oh Ainsley, cha cha cha”). If you want to be cured of your loathing of Emril then come over to England (I don’t THINK Ainsley’s infiltrated the US yet) and watch one of his shows. I guarantee that after watching just five minutes Emril will seem like a bastion of sanity and calm in a sea of chaos.

[/hijack]

This Emril sounds like a serious case but TV chefs on the whole are a strange breed indeed. What always amazes me is how these people can act so damn chirpy all the time they’re on air, I don’t think they’re happy at all. I think that what you normally witness on the Emril show is most likely 30 minutes of relative calm edited from a 3hr long hysteria attack. As soon as the camera’s are off they probably drag him back into a padded cell, shove a stick between his teeth and shoot him full of PCP to stop him from biting through the door (just a theory;) ).
But anyways, fear not Fenris, this guy won’t be on TV forever and if he is Ainsley Harriot will probably be arriving in the US soon anyway so you’ll have more to worry about (Pain? You don’t know what pain is bwahahahaha;) )

Fenris: The smug posturing of Bobby Flay tortures me on a daily basis - my office building is directly next door to Mesa Grill and since we’re on the penthouse, for some reason the smells drift up every now and then. Sometimes it’s good as some kickass roasted red meat aromas occasionally drift skyward - although more often it’s the nagging tang of burnt toast. I don’t know dick about ventilation systems, so have no idea why it happens, it just does…

stofsky: I have no objections to Emeril having a good time on his show with the music, good times, blah blah fishcakes - what bothers me is that he’s buying his own shit, lock stock and barrel, every single day, ad nauseum. Cooking is damn good fun on its own and doesn’t need a three-ring circus to make it come alive.

Methinks marriage to a professional chef (whose mother has baked her own bread and made her own butter for the last 50 years) has warped me forever.

#1) His show’s live, so we see all the fuck-ups in living color.

#2) His show’s a full, horrible hour long.

#3) That hour is repeated incessantly. He’s on something like 1 out of every 3 hours.

The nutjob (Ainsley Harriot) you’re talking about frankly sounds like he’s watched Emril or Emril’s watched Ainsley. They sound pretty similar.

Fenris