Before I begin, I’d like to say a word about the judges, who are always under a ton of fire for reasons I’ve never understood. I made a rating scale for my opinions of the judges’ decisions, as follows:
1 - Total agreement; they completely nailed it.
2 - Might have been questionable on the margin (was a yooner, should’ve been a splitter, or vice versa), but otherwise complete agreement.
3 - Totally wrong on the margin, but the right bot clearly won, so no harm, no foul.
4 - It was pretty close, and maybe you could make a tiny case for the other bot, but on the whole I think the call was right.
5 - A complete toss-up that could’ve gone either way. I have no opinion.
6 - I thought one bot squeaked it out, but the judges (two of them, anyway) obviously saw something I didn’t, and it was really close, so I just have to defer to their professional opinion.
7 - Questionable decision. Maybe you could’ve seen it that way, but only if you weren’t paying close attention.
8 - Bad decision. Anyone can see that the wrong bot got the nod.
9 - Total robbery. An unbelievable miscarriage of justice. Someone needs to get fired for this.
A nice, wide range, isn’t it? Well, much too wide, actually, since in my entire time watching Battlebots, I have never gone higher than 5. Let me put it this way: The NFL has horrible officiating. The NHL sometimes has horrible officiating. Baseball has far more horrible officiating than a sport so dumb should ever have. Boxing? That one’s corrupt to the bone; of course you’re going to get tons of bad decisions. Battlebots does not have horrible officiating. Victories are earned. Not even the top superstars get preferential treatment.
Why? Well, part of it is that there just isn’t enough money in the sport to justify selling one’s soul (or trying to convince a driver to sell his, for that matter), but mostly, the people in this sport aren’t going to stand for it. This is their life’s passion. They pour their hearts and souls into these finely-tuned, exhaustively tested, and, might I add, expensive machines, and they’re going to pour molten lead on any judge brazen enough to rob them. On the opposite end, the producers and showrunners and matchmakers know that Battlebots doesn’t have a hundredth of the influence of the NFL and cannot laugh off endless bad press, so they are going to make damn sure that any rogue agents get disposed of with extreme prejudice. Remember how Jason Bardis just disappeared without a trace (both times)? That’s the kind of ship they’re running here.
CHAMPIONS 2 - SCS DAY 4
++ First round ++
Banshee vs. Cobalt
Banshee does counterclockwise circles while Cobalt moves slowly and pivots. Banshee is a flipper, which means that it will not survive a head-on assault on Cobalt’s mangling spinner. Cobalt manages to get briefly under its foe, but the spinner can’t find anything. And just as I write that, Banshee runs right up on Cobalt’s wedge and is smashed to the ceiling. (
Goddammit.) That hit seems to have rattled Banshee, and Cobalt capitalizes with another moon shot. Shot of Banshee driver David Small who barks “Flipper works!” which is really tempting fate if you ask me. Banshee demonstrates this functionality by flipping itself over (
) but quickly re-rights and avoids total embarrassment. I have to think Cobalt has this in the bag and it’s only a matter of time…
…Cobalt isn’t pressing the attack. It’s movements are tentative and it’s only getting little hits. We’ve seen destructive power from this machine before, so I figure Cobalt driver John Mladenick is just biding his time. A biggish hit, more metal off Banshee. 1:30 left. Cobalt is chewing away…AND BANSHEE FIRES BACK WITH A FLIP WITH OVERTURNS COBALT for about a tenth of a second.
Less than a minute left…some shaky driving from Mladenick, and Banshee is able to…demonstrate how weak its flipper is.
Definitely wasn’t expecting this one to go the distance. Yooner Cobalt, obviously [1], as Banshee didn’t do much of anything, but it looked far from impressive, and we’ve seen that foreshadow defeat later in the program.
Big Dill vs. Jackpot
Both bots had markedly different designs in the past but could practically be brothers now, BD sporting two forks and a small vertical spinner, Jackpot with two forks and a funny heart-shaped spinner. Clearly the designers were trying to eliminate their past shortcomings; we’ll see how effective they were.
BD blitzes straight in and drills a still-stationary Jackpot to seemingly little effect. Jackpot makes a break for it, and BD hounds it, flipping it over. Jackpot’s cornerman makes seal noises or whatever. BD gets a fork caught in a saw notch, allowing Jackpot to strike back. BD pushes back but Jackpot slips to its right and…gets stuck there for a bit. It pulls free, taking out a belt and some red metal in the process. BD’s lost its weapon and its left side drive is ailing, and against Jackpot’s power, that’s the kiss of death. Jackpot…
…doesn’t…close…the…deal.
Lots of poking and jousting and jabbing and slapping and whapping, no real damage dealt. With 1:30 left, they lock up in the middle of the box…and…just stay there for a while. Disengage, more jabbing, some smoke from BD. Jackpot reverses into the wall for whatever reason and nearly gets tagged by a clown hammer. And another lockup, and the hammer hits home this time. And now Jackpot is running all over the place, all while BD still has a fair amount of maneuverability. And BD shoves Jackpot across the box.
Weird bout. It looked for all the world like both drivers were totally winging it; I certainly didn’t see anything resembling a strategy from either driver. Jackpot has the clear edge in all three categories and gets the deserved yooner [1]. Driver Jeff Waters admits that he intended to lay on the pain but backed off, most likely to avoid damage. Rose reveals that all three judges scored it 7-4, which sits fine with Florian.
Emulsifier vs. Captain Shrederator
One of the big keys to championships in Battlebots has always been adaptability. If all a bot can do is hit really hard, it may have some success, but somewhere along the line a smart opponent is going to figure it out. That’s why the top teams continually tinker with different forks, spinner configurations, armor setups, etc. With a single high vertical spinner like Emulsifier’s, or being in constant attack mode by design as with Captain Shrederator, there just isn’t any plan B. Getting the win here and salvaging Not A Loser could be the best either can hope for.
Lots of pokes and jabs to start. CS actually has Emulsifier on its back, but it quickly gets back up. And…that was quick; Emulsifier’s left side drive is conked, while CS is having the usual CS control headaches. Emulsifier’s driver goes “C’mon Brian!” thus satisfying this episode’s bad sportsmanship quota.
CS suddenly has become extremely tentative. The ref demands some kind of engagement, and anytime you hear “hoi hakkeyoi” in robot combat, that’s a very bad sign. Another swipe by CS. And more pawing. Aaaaaand there it is, CS has stopped spinning.
Honestly, you can set your damn watch by it. Emulsifier immediately capitalizes by making as many as four scratches on CS’ body. Nabe announces “Another minute”, and…yeah, why the hell not just skip to that point; I’m too depressed to do anything else. Something beats nothing; yooner Emulsifier [1].
Lucky vs. Overhaul
Florian decries Overhaul’s grabber design as a relic. If relegation is actually a thing (and I stress that I’ve yet to see any evidence of this), Charles Guan could be heading for a swan song. Slow approach to begin. Lucky catches Overhaul’s back but the flipper can’t reach. Brief chase. Tentative pawing shot by Lucky to no effect. And another. Guan: “I see you! I see what you’re doing!”
Dude, it’s a flipper; it’s not full of mysteries like Defender. Lucky gets briefly under but the flipper whiffs to the left. Finally! Overhaul’s trapped against the wall! FLIP…some height. (And it takes a clown hammer in response, big whoop.) Overhaul’s having trouble moving. Lucky gets it up, then up again on the upper deck, which I think should count as a field goal, whatever that’s worth in this sport. Nothing interesting happens for the remainder of the fight, during which I think Overhaul actually had negative offense. Yooner Lucky [1]. Guan remains adamant in his loyalty to the lifter design, and the word “Quixotic” comes to mind, not to mention “fragged”.
++ Semis ++
Emulsifier vs. Cobalt
Emulsifier is going without the front wedge in other to get more offense out of the spinner. Agree with Florian that it’s a big gamble. Someone in the Emulsifier box holds up a whiteboard saying “forks are for eating”, because we all know how bear-poking hubris never backfires. 
Maneuvering. Emulsifier gets to Cobalt’s left and takes a few bites. Cobalt goes after Emulsifier’s left front, knocking off a bit of steel. Emulsifier goes into the upper deck wall. I swear, that deck has been an idiot trap more than anything else for its entire existence. Someone in the Emulsifier box goes “C’mon John ya get the mack dress!” or whatever. Lots of passes, and another sliver falls off of Emulsifier. Something green is on the floor too, but Cobalt still has all its forks. Uh oh, uh oh, here it is! BIG SHOT…okay, not that big, but something round is now on the floor, quickly determined to be Emulsifier’s left side tread. Emulsifier immediately betrays major handling problems, even getting its spinner into the floor. Now the right side tread is off; Emulsifier is basically running on rubber bands. The final blow come soon after, Cobalt launching Emulsifier inverted into the corner. Yeah, I suppose forks are for eating, given how Cobalt totally ate your lunch. 
Lucky vs. Jackpot
Lucky runs into Jackpot from the left but can’t get in position to flip. Running around, no offense. Lucky, apparently frustrated, goes after Jackpot’s minibot and of course whiffs because it’s so low…which allows Jackpot to rush in and attack from the left. Lucky gives chase and comes up short. The minibot, which has surprising torque, muscles Lucky into the corner; Jackpot tries to attack but can’t find room. Escape, scramble. Finally Lucky gets something going by knocking Jackpot over. Oh dear, we’ve seen this story before; the weapon chains fell off of Jackpot and it’s spinner is now an undersized bludgeon. Lucky pushes ahead, getting Jackpot on the upper deck, which, as always, is an outstanding tactic because it’s completely impossible to follow up.
Jackpot descends; Lucky charges and gets completely under it, and after one clown hammer harassment…they’re deadlocked. Lucky, after a long wait, fires. And a second, and Lucky smokes a bit. Lucky’s left side drive is done…but what can Jackpot do with no weapon? As it turns out, nothing…and that’s how this one ends.
And now the judges get a tough one. This is a fifty-percent-plus-one call if ever there was one. It’s a splitter! Davis - Lucky, Young - Jackpot, Winter…Jackpot! [5] Jeff Waters admits that it was a tough battle. Marc Demers puts in succinctly: “In Vegas, sometimes you hit the Jackpot, sometimes the Jackpot hits you.”
The three final day bye teams have words.
Profile of Mark Condrackian and his unique designs. Quick look at Stalker, his new prototype five-legged bot. It’s amazingly nimble, and, as he demonstrates, highly sturdy as well. Not sure how effective it’s going to be as a fighter, but it looks like a lot of fun! 
++ Final ++
Jackpot vs. Cobalt
Cautious maneuvering. Cobalt…very stupidly turns its back for no reason I could determine, and Jackpot cheerfully takes the free shot.
(and again
) Lots of smoke ensues; so much, in fact, that Rose should at least consider the obvious Spy Hunter reference, dammit. Now Cobalt has caught on fire and is stuck on Jackpot. Jackpot reverses, reverses, reverses, then finally gets the brilliant idea to go in the correct direction, and finally manages to shake Cobalt off. Cobalt incredibly manages to hang tough for a few more seconds, but with such a massive fire with so much time left there’s no saving it.
Well, as any gambler knows, luck runs hot and cold, and the streaky Jackpot definitely got the hot side tonight. Jeff Waters is soaring, clearly not expecting to have won the day. John Mladenick admits that he got distracted by the minibot, a fatal blunder. Man, this is, no exaggeration, the most impact I have ever seen a minibot have. Take note, Team Skorpios! 
Well, would you look at that, four total agreements and one coin flip on the decisions. The judges are fine. Leave them alone. Geez.
Still not seeing a match for End Game, Tantrum, or Sawblaze, but there are a couple possible spoilers in the day 5 field. I’m anticipating more excitement than we’ve had in days 3 and 4.
DCnDC - I mentioned before how most of the owners are making a bot that they think has the best chance of winning, they are making their bot…their design, their dream, their fantasy, their obsession. And the producers love seeing creative, innovative, or simply weird designs If it can beat anything, it has a place here.