In order:
- Anya
- Fred
- Willow
- Faith
Willow, Fred, Cordy, Darla, Buffy, Tara
Tara of course ties at #1 if WITH Willow G
I’ll go with Willow, Jenny Calendar, Faith and Fred, in no particular order. They will all get the valuable opportunity to be my love puppet.
I never liked Cordelia. In fact, one of the reasons I like Buffy Season 4 so much is that it’s Cordelia-free.
Willow. Of course I always had a thing for cute lesbians. Actually, I just love anything Alyson Hannigan is doing.
Who was the sexy “techno-pagan” teacher in season 1? She was hot, but I don’t remember the actress’ or the character’s name.
Faith. Definately Faith. Then probably jailbait Dawn 
Oh and what about the Buffy bot? She was much hotter than Buffy!
Jenny Calendar
Cool, then my short list is:
Willow
Jenny Calendar
Cordelia
Buffy
Darla
I look forward to watching season 2, which my friend assures me is the best one of all.
Miss Calendar - any day
Briefly hijacking my own thread, the sistas I can recall are:
Rona the potential slayer
Lissa the demon Xander dated in “First Date”
Olivia, Giles’ would-be girlfriend
Nikki Wood the Vampire Slayer
The First Slayer
Kendra the Vampire Slayer
Alonna, Gunn’s sister
Some unnamed vamp Spike talks to in the Bronze in “Sleeper”
Aura, from “Welcome to the Hellmouth” (who found the body in the lockerroom)
Aggie, Lorne’s psychic hotline friend (played by the same actress, Persia White, as Aura) and
Jasmine.
Also, it is interesting that so far no one has selected Buffy as the girl you like. Perhaps the show would’ve been a lot more popular if it had been titled “Willow the Lesbian Wicca.” 
Sorry, to clarify, no one has selected Buffy as his/her first choice so far. Carry on.
Well, since I haven’t a clue who is who in the Buffyverse, and I know who played Buffy… I’ll bite the bullet and take her.
[ol]
[li]Cordelia[/li][li]Willow[/li][li]Eve – a little surprised no-one else has picked her.[/li][li]Virginia Bryce - from season 2 angel. Gotta love a pretty redhead with a faint Irish accent.[/li][li]Gwen Raiden[/li][li]Nina[/li][li]Fred[/li][li]Faith[/li][li]Kennedy[/li][li]Harmony[/li][/ol]
PS to zamboni… there was a little ‘whoosh’ hidden in your list of candidates, right?? Chantarelle, Lily, and Anne are all different names for the same girl.
Gotta revise this, forgot about Darla. I’d put her at about 3.5.
Oh, no! I forgot about Oz! How could I forget OZ! :eek:
Anyone want this dusty ol’ librarian? I gotta catch me a werewolf!
You got it!
Willow! I watch the show just for her. But I certainly wouldn’t say no to Spike or Oz.
Amy Madison had stunning eyes. Me like.
Wesley (season 4-5 of Angel)
Spike (good or bad)
Oz
Charles Gunn