[QUOTE=astorian]
So, what do you do when things aren’t so black and white?
What about a company that pollutes the environment but simultaneously provides benefits to the partners of gay employees? Is that a “progressive” company?
How about tobacco companies that give generously to Planned Parenthood?
How about a supermarket chain that supports small-scale organic farmers, but crushes all attempts by its employees to unionize?
[/QUOTE]
And
[QUOTE=bump]
What if a company was very progressive, but 40% of its ownership was the Southern Baptist Convention pension fund?
Or… better yet, what if a company’s owner is seriously Christian, and through his company, donates a lot of money to help the poor, invests in the community, highly subsidizes his workers’ health insurance, etc… AND also donates a sizeable portion o f his own personal wealth to right-to-life groups?
You have to draw a distinction, at least with public companies, between ownership of a company, and the company itself.
[/QUOTE]
You’re right, no doubt about it (except for the tobacco analogy…if you disapprove of tobacco, you don’t smoke, right? If you don’t smoke, there’s no reason to give them your business
). The quandaries that you present concerning conflicting values have to be solved by the conscience of each individual person. Keep in mind, though, that that may be easier than you think…it’s not necessary for companies to be perfect, just better than other companies providing the same goods or services. I don’t think people are obliged to torture themselves about the values of the businesses of every single purchase, they should make a reasonable effort and make their best guess (t-bonham@scc.net is right, http://www.buyblue.org looks good). I also think it behooves people making these judgements to show some respect for those who share similar general progressive values but make decisions differently, e.g., an upper class gay might place an emphasis on gay rights but a blue collar worker might place a greater emphasis on workplace security. Everyone is obliged to recognize that others may have different priorities, no?