I think you mean John Goodman. Dan Conner was the character.
Or am I being whooshed?
John Noble as Walter Bishop on Fringe - his character’s insane glee is strangely attractive (very good term for that).
That is strange. She’s spunky, I’ll give her that.
These women are all gorgeous. Nothing strange about it.
No whoosh. Just a ::pfffftt:: sound, indicating a brain-fart on my end! 
John Goodman is exactly who I meant!
I’m gonna say Kristen Schaal of Flight of the Conchords (and also an occasional Daily Show correspondent).
Obviously not a conventional beauty, but she manages to have a strange allure. (I think mostly by virtue of her wit and vivaciousness.)
Sadly, he’s not aging well, but in his prime I can totally see the reason he got work.
There is more than one? Don’t tell my wife, she’ll want the spare.
Yeah, he had it going on in Earth Girls Are Easy.
Oh, please. She’ll want all of them, and you damned well know it! 
Who gracefully aged to this one:
Fionhula Flanagan, whom you may remember from the very fine Irish film, 'Waking Ned Devine".
Man, I’d…
She could, uh…
I’d fight all her dragons for her, just to have her look at me once with those smoldering eyes and then tell me to peel her a grape!
Plus, she’s only 7 years older than me!
Quasi
Benicio del Toro.
He’s lanky and mumbly and bored/stoned-looking. He seems scary and weird. He looks older than he is. Yet…there’s something appealing about him.
See, I never ‘get’ this attraction. He’s always making someone-or-another’s list of ‘50 Sexiest Men In Hollywood’ or something. I’m glad so many people like him, but I. . .just don’t get it.
Well, I am a lady. And it wasn’t negative, if that’s what “negs! ;)” means.
I’m going to go with Kate Micucci, who plays Shelly, the doggy day care singer/songwriter.
mmm
I hate spunk!
mmm
My opinion is that they all have a sort of jolie-laide interesting thing going on-as opposed to being very “obviously” goodlooking, like say Angelina Jolie, Aishwarya Rai, Catherine Zeta Jones and the like. I simply don’t think Tilda Swinton is obviously goodlooking-though she is supposedly quite smart and interesting. I think she looks a bit like an alien or someone who’d be a high fashion model who routinely start in whacked out couture runway shows.
Trust me; in person she is so beautiful it’s impossible to describe.
I have a huge thing for Mickey Rourke. Like, modern day Mickey Rourke. Probably not in ‘real life’ but when he’s in character as some fucked up guy in a superhero movie? TAKE ME NOW. Seriously, I watched Iron-Man 2 only because of him.
Also I have a bizarre crush on Lil Wayne, who is a very strange looking little man. Admittedly, he does have pretty ridiculous muscles, but still. I think it qualifies as ‘strangely attractive.’
Whimper.
I had no idea. See, the joke was premised on a man describing a woman as having “reptilian beauty” and that being the ultimate in doomed win-on lines and…
I should give up now. The first rule of holes is that when you are in one, stop digging.