OK, if you were going to cast a movie and try to fill it with the creepiest/most disturbing actors/actresses out there, who would you pick? My choices:
Actors:
Willem Dafoe
Christopher Waken
James Woods
Jeff Goldblum (I don’t know why, he just freaks me out)
Actresses:
That midget from “Poltergeist”
Ruth Buzzi
Nominations?
I don’t know her name, but that woman from “Seventh Heaven.” I’d rather meet Christopher Walken in a dark alley that her in broad daylight anyday.
As for Ruth Buzzi, has she appeared in any live action films? I always thought of her as a cartoon voice.
I name rings clear through the night.
Johnathan Lipnicki
I don’t know the actor’s name and I don’t know how much makeup was used, but my god, that kid from Deliverance was creepy.
Clint Howard kinda scares me, too.
Anne Ramsey, Momma from “Let’s Throw Momma from the Train.”
Christopher Lloyd.
Porky pudster Ron Jeremy.
And a famous face but obscure name: Michael Berryman, the tall, bulgy-eyed, bulletheaded bald guy from “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest,” “Weird Science” (“Let’s do lunch”), and “The Hills Have Eyes.”
According to IMDB.com, the kid’s name is Hoyt Pollard. I don’t have any other info on him at this moment.
Max Schreck (?), the way creepy vampire from the old silent film “Nosferatu.” Played, coincidentally enough, by another creepy actor, Willem Dafoe, in the new movie “Shadow of the Vampire.”
I hear O.J. is looking for work 
Dennis Hopper. That guy makes coffee nervous.
Brad Dourif has never played a rational person in his entire life. Next role: Grima Wormtongue in Lord of the Rings.
Might I suggest Anthony Hopkins? Just give him a psycopathic/sociopathic role.
Robert Carlyle
He scares the hell out of me and seems to have an uncanny gift for playing psychos. He was in an episode of Cracker and was a complete nutcase. It’s the eyes I think.
One vote for James Caan. In his more violent movies he gets this wonderfully bug-eyed look on his face just before he blows up and kicks the crap out of someone.
–sublight.
I’ve always found Jack Palance to be creepy.
Jeffrey Combs.
I had a chance to watch Re-Animator and Bride of Re-Animator this weekend and was once again blown away by how perfectly Combs can play a mad scientist. He’s cute too, but that doesn’t take away from the crrepiness.
Peter Lorre. M, anyone?
I’ve noticed so far that only two creepy women have been named: Ruth Buzzi (who I don’t think is creepy per se) and Zelda Rubinstein (who I think probably does meet the criteria).
I guess creepy women just don’t do as well in Hollywood as creepy men. The only other creepy woman I can think of is Grace Jones.
Any others?
::cough:: Anne Ramsey ::cough::
::cough:: not ::cough::
::cough:: a ::cough::
::cough:: guy ::cough::
Okay, I’ve got some chicks:
Maxine Bahns, who was Ed Burns’ GF for his first two movies, and thusly, got the leads. Not only is her acting talent on par with my doorknob’s, she just looks creepy to me.
Heather Graham. Yeah, she’s gorgeous, but her eyes are twice as big as they should be for her head. She looks like a cross between an alien and some Dondi character to me. Love Swingers, but whenever she was having her scenes I just wanted to scream, “Stop looking at me! For the love of all that’s good and holy, woman, take your voodoo elsewhere!”
Melanie Griffith. Whatever she USED to have, she ain’t got it no more. She reminds me of those 50-year old women that hang out at hotel lobby bars in pleather miniskirts.
Okay, none of these are standardly creepy, but they always make ME feel funny.
Anybody remember Crispin Glover. He palyed a speed freak in The River’s Edge a little too convincingly. And he scared the bejesus out of David Lettermen on his show a few times.