These are getting harder to choose - most are pretty decent. But I’m going to give it to Needscoffee for the succinct “Partner of Plenty”. Nicely done. Maybe “Partner o’ Plenty” would be overegging the pudding.
I’ve never heard of the Good Brothers and had to look that one up.
I thought of the Good Brothers mainly because I remember when they were playing bars in southern Ontario, and you’d see in the entertainment pages of the paper that the Good Brothers were playing this weekend at (say) the Belvedere Tavern on Main Street.
They went on to have a good (pun fully intended) career, made a number of recordings, and would be well-known to country music fans. However, I’ll grant that it would be a tricky clue for any solver who is not a country music fan.
I will add that I also liked “Partner of Plenty.” Got the advertising jingle (“Charlie says, love my Good and Plenty…”) stuck in my head for a while after that. Nicely done, needscoffee!
If I recall twickster’s advice correctly, you try to avoid using symbols in puzzle clues. If you do use them, chances are that they are there for a reason; such as in a theme puzzle.
Similarly, you try to avoid using “(abbr.)” unless you absolutely must. You indicate somehow in the clue that you’re looking for an abbreviation, usually by using one. So earlier, we had UP. I came up (heh) with “R.R. company,” meaning Union Pacific, but abbreviated as “U.P.”
Thanks! I really liked @Wheelz’s “James Brown felt it”, but I couldn’t figure out his “Between the uprights” - probably something very obvious that I’m just not seeing.
Regarding “between the uprights,” it’s used in football. A kicker is trying for a field goal or an extra point after touchdown. He has to kick the ball between the uprights in the end zone. Typically, the TV announcer will say, as the ball flies through the air, “Annnnnd–it’s good!” if the kicker succeeds.
The protocol, as you say, is an abbreviation or irregularity in the clue is somehow involved with the answer. But it actually is “Good & Plenty” candy. Not sure why I initially thought it was “Good ‘n Plenty”, but it’s not like I’ve seen it recently.