Fair enough. So warning, major spoilers for the Plot Line of Phantom Liberty (from here on PL).
The Endings
For those who have played it, or those who don’t care about spoilers - the main thrust to me is to have a parallel story to V/Johnny’s situation. You have multiple new characters introduced, but the choices come down to siding with Songbird, or siding with Reed.
Now… the endings (double spoilers!) seem to push that helping Songbird is the “happier” ending. Not that there are really happy endings in the base game or the DLC, but happy-er at least. In the “Put Songbird on the Shuttle ending” Alex lives, and Reed, because you Killed him (triple spoilers) isn’t at least caught between his loyalty to his subordinates while trying to show loyalty to his superiors who certainly don’t show any loyalty in turn. Songbird is theoretically free, and hopefully saved from their fate (although I doubt they’re free or safe any more than V is in the prior endings of the game). V is just as screwed as they were at the beginning.
In the second save Songbird option, you choose to turn in Songbird to Reed after she confesses her fraud to you. Done this way Songbird is “alive” but back in the arms of government, Reed remains alive and apparently is no longer doing field work, V has a solution that the game seems bound and determined to make sound horrible but I had issues with, and Johnny is screwed.
If you work with Reed, Songbird freaks out, and Alex dies (more on this) and depending on your choice you can kill her (her choice) which Reed reluctantly accepts, or bring her in alive, which earns you extra cash and recognition, including a choice of doing the same new ending as above.
My Feelings
So, of course, the parallel with Vs/Johnny’s situation is strong. Both Songbird and V are dying, there’s very little they can do about it, and it’s a question of just how far they will go to stay alive.
But emotionally and story-wise, Songbird just didn’t come off as sympathetic to me. It’s really, really obviously fishy from veeeery early in the quest regarding Songbird’s role in the events, and eventually she comes partially clean with you (long after you notice it yourself). She’s the one responsible for the entire shit show. And while I’m somewhat sympathetic for her being made into a living WMD - she’s always felt free to betray others for her own ends. Very Cyberpunk of course. She’s betrayed Reed (historically), betrayed the president (setting up the DLC), betrayed the person she betrayed the president too, betrayed you, betrayed the partners who are risking their lives to save her (unto death, although they again have their own motivations). Oh, and causally massacred a huge number of civilians.
Now, to be fair, there is a huge amount of wiggle room involved - how much she is directly responsible for, and how much is covert or overt influence of the AIs is arguable… but no. At the end I was infinitely happier with the endings in which I helped Reed stop her.
Still, all the characters involved are at a minimum interesting, well voiced and acted, and the story felt both complete and contained while still very much a part of the larger Night City story and Johnny/V’s saga. One of the best DLC for a game I’ve experienced in a long time.