As you pull the mechanical door handle (inside or outside), the computer runs the window down an inch or so, so by the time your pitifully slow human body can get the door moving, the computer has long since gotten the window clear of the weather seals. If for some reason that doesn’t happen, the effort to open the door is slightly greater. It’s a concession to seal durability, not to ease of access.
I’m sure there is somebody somewhere who is exactly infirm enough they can get the door open with great difficulty with the window down, and would fail with the window up. That person is not the target market for that kind of car, and IMO is not really within the design envelope for any kind of car. “Too weak to move” and “still drives” ought to be an empty set.
Why only restrict to the front? The primary criticism has always been on the Model Y’s back seats. The door release is in an extremely unintuitive place and 99.9% of people would not be able to figure it out in the event of an emergency:
And even if it is, and the owner has studied the manual and knows where it is, I foresee other problems. What if it’s a rental car? The way Elmo designs his cars, one would appear to need a one-week training course in order to qualify to drive them. Or in the immortal words of Donald J Trump – a man who can turn a phrase with a brilliance unseen since William Shakespeare – who said, upon first getting into a “Tesler”: “Hey, it’s all computer!”.
But the other problem I’m imagining is that the Tesla owner, having educated himself on the location of the mechanical door release, knows how to react when his Tesla is on fire, which happens from time to time, and fiercely pulls on that little plastic piece.
I think we’ve all seen those cartoonish comedies where a car is careening down a steep slope and the driver pulls hard on the emergency brake, and it comes off in their hand. Yeah, like that. I have no specific reason to believe that would happen in any particular model of Tesla, except for the history of Elmo’s design ingenuity!
99.9% of the people who know that is where the emergency release is won’t be able to access it in an emergency (I particularly like needing fingernails to pry open the cover). 100% not privy to that level of the Tesla arcana will fail to locate it.
They remind me of the homemade car bodies hobbyists would put on VW frames back in the day. A stack of 1" rigid foam insulation and a couple rolls of duct tape and you got yourself a car!
Tesla has recalled every Cybertruck it has sold in the US after admitting that the glued-on panels on the unconventional pick-up truck have been falling off…