Incidentally, askeptic, I think you should check out those lyrics again. I was convinced for a long time that it was a pretty racist song, but I’ve changed my mind for the most part. I still have some questions, but right here’s as good a chance as I’ll ever have to build my case.
First off, I always thought it was “Boo Hoo Hoo” after the guv’nor line, as in, stop crying about it, what’s done is done. It’s not in the lyrics from the official site at all, so who knows.
Anyway, about this:
I hear Lynyrd Skynyrd actually really admired Neil Young, for what it’s worth, so it wasn’t exactly a war. I just thought that after Young wrote “Southern Man” and “Alabama,” Skynyrd decided to stick up for their roots, and that’s what “Sweet Home Alabama” is about.
What I was trying to say before was that the way I interpreted it, that verse you referenced means that just as not all Northerners, or even all Americans, bear the guilt for Watergate, neither are all Southerners represented by Wallace and his supporters. Why else would “We all did what we could do” be in there, unless he means they disagreed? You don’t honestly think he means he did what he could do to keep blacks out of schools, do you?
The Watergate line is a question- “Now Watergate does not bother me, does your conscience bother you?” In other words, do the Neil Youngs of the world feel responsible for the bad deeds of others, and if not, why are all Southerners responsible for what Wallace did? That’s how I take it, anyway; it seems pretty vague, and I don’t really think it’s supposed to be of earth-shattering significance. I think it’s just a little dig at the band’s buddy Neil, while at the same time trying to defend the South from blanket condemnation. An in-joke that turned out to be one of the most popular songs of all time.
I also think it’s pretty hard to call Van Zant a racist when another song from that same album is a tribute to an old black blues player who Van Zant loved when he was a kid. And honestly, in every other song, they sure sound pretty progressive to me.
This hi, I suppose, has been thoroughly jacked.