[QUOTE=Leaper]
Ah. But what I was saying/asking was, you said that a single phone call and message might’ve put this person ON THE TOP OF THE LIST. So given that, why should anyone pay attention to “no phone calls,” especially yours, if obeying would be to their detriment, and ignoring it would benefit their chances of getting the job so much?
[/QUOTE]
Actually, I kind of muddled that up when I originally mentioned it.
I should not have said that a follow-up call “could have bumped him to the top of the list” because that’s inaccurate and I retract it. We’re selecting our candidates, in addition to good cover letters and qualifications, if they are good on the phone, it will be helpful (that’s more what I meant).
But it’s really, really better to wait until we can call them, because then we will have the time they deserve from us, and they will have a better opportunity to present themselves well. No matter how well-spoken they may be, if we have to hurry them off the phone, it wouldn’t be giving them a fair shake.
Someone calling specifically to verify their submission was recieved, would not have that one call held against them for ignoring the “no calls” request. If they called to apply for the position over the phone, that would kill their chances.
Follow-up: I mentioned yesterday that I called him back. I’d left a messsage with his brother (or roommate, but I got the impression he still lives with his family) that I wanted to speak with him. I think the brother/roommate was screening calls for the guy in my OP because he sounded worried and asked: “Oh… Was he calling you yesterday?”
When I asked him to have the misguided kid call me back today (at a specific time that his brother/roommate said he would be available) he seemed surprised that I wanted him to call me again, and sounded so worried that I actually felt compelled to add: “We’re not angry with him.”
He did not call me back. I wonder if he had a couple different job applications on the go and was using the same technique with everyone. Maybe someone else blew a gasket and screamed at him.