De'endee Mafia

[gnarlycharlie]

@Silver_Jan

well this is it

i’m wondering though why you felt you had to claim. there hasn’t been a recent vote count but isn’t Kelly still lynch leader?

[Suburban_Plankton]

@LightFoot

I thought that is what I said.
I was sort of responding to the double thinking posts about power voting a leader to possibly gain XP vs Vanilla voting a leader to smoke screen the power roles.

I thought you said that we gain experience points by voting for the lynchee (period).

I ‘corrected’ you by clarifying that we gain experience points by voting for the lynchee only if the lynchee is Scum.

Of course, given my misunderstanding of the double-voting rules, I wouldn’t take my word for it, if I were you.

[Suburban_Plankton]

@special_ed

Thanks.
@ Everyone, so all this fretting about not casting our second votes is for naught. Unless we cast them for the same person.

You could have told me that earlier!

[gnarlycharlie]

@Suburban_Plankton

snipped

So just to clarify, since I am apparently no paying near as close attention to this game as I thought I was:

As long as I don’t cast two votes for the same person, I am free to have multiple votes on the board all Day long, and change them as often as I wish?

I am currently voting for Kelly. I can vote for Ed again now, then change my mind and vote for **Pinkies **and Inner Stickler, then work my way through the entire Town, as long as I don’t have two votes on the same player at the same time?

snipped

yes, you aren’t paying attention if you think you can vote Pinkies.

[Suburban_Plankton]

@gnarlycharlie

yes, you aren’t paying attention if you think you can vote Pinkies.

Damn! Wrong game!

Although one could argue that it’s *never *wrong to vote for Pinkies…

[Normal_Phase]

@Suburban_Plankton

As long as I don’t cast two votes for the same person, I am free to have multiple votes on the board all Day long, and change them as often as I wish?

Apparently.

I must now rethink a whole bunch of thoughts that I had concerning voting strategy. But I am comfortable with my vote as it stands currently.

And apparently.

[Silver_Jan]

@special_ed

What did you think about the fact that your character class didn’t match kelly’s?

I didn’t think it didn’t match Kelly’s and thats why I unvoted, I believe what he’s saying.

Wouldn’t it be good if he told us which sex he was?

[Silver_Jan]

Sorry, gender!

[gnarlycharlie]

@Suburban_Plankton

Damn! Wrong game!

Although one could argue that it’s *never *wrong to vote for Pinkies…

agreed. Ed wanted to vote for Pinkies too and i thought it was okay as well.

[Scathach]

@Silver_Jan

well this is it

@Silver_Jan

So why was that in my PM as I am obviously plaing?
playing

It’s referring to D&D NPC’s.

Non-player character

[Scathach]

And since we have two votes before they lock. I’m going to

** vote Koldanar
**
For the same reasons I laid out earlier.

[Scathach]

@Silver_Jan

I didn’t think it didn’t match Kelly’s and thats why I unvoted, I believe what he’s saying.

Wouldn’t it be good if he told us which sex he was?

But your class is different to the vanilla role pm, instead of NPC Townsperson, it’s mage.

[Silver_Jan]

Intersting so I am controlled by the dungeon Master, thanks

I still don’t know if who I voted for is right but I am a little Townie.

[choie]

Okay, Silver Jan’s claim sheet has me really confused now. Her Class is Mage but her role is NPC, and she has no powers. Why would a Mage have no powers? Why would a Mage be an NPC in the first place?

Am I just utterly ignorant of the difference between “Class” and “Role”?

[gnarlycharlie]

@choie

Okay, Silver Jan’s claim sheet has me really confused now. Her Class is Mage but her role is NPC, and she has no powers. Why would a Mage have no powers? Why would a Mage be an NPC in the first place?

Am I just utterly ignorant of the difference between “Class” and “Role”?

it could be the mods’ way to prevent handshakes or she’s lying.

[Silver_Jan]

I have to place a vote before 1am so I think I will go with

Vote Koldanar

I can’t make a case so if you vote me off it will be a little VT.

I hope Town knows this and doesn’t vote for me cos we need lots of secret VT’s so Scum don’t kill power roles

[Scathach]

@choie

Okay, Silver Jan’s claim sheet has me really confused now. Her Class is Mage but her role is NPC, and she has no powers. Why would a Mage have no powers? Why would a Mage be an NPC in the first place?

Am I just utterly ignorant of the difference between “Class” and “Role”?

I’m not quite sure what to make of it either. It might be just meaningless flavour added to prevent handshakes. Or it might not. I’m finding it reasonably unlikely that she made it up if her unfamiliarity with D&D is true.

[Silver_Jan]

I played D&D 24 years ago, My name ws Silver. I haven’t played since

[choie]

@Scathach

I’m not quite sure what to make of it either. It might be just meaningless flavour added to prevent handshakes. Or it might not. I’m finding it reasonably unlikely that she made it up if her unfamiliarity with D&D is true.

Yeah, I dunno, I can imagine their adding color to avoid handshakes, but not creating a role of “Mage” that has no powers.

Posit: she’s a scum Mage who just switched her real Role with “NPC Townsperson,” which is referenced in the public vanilla claim from the OP.

My suspicion is raised. Sorry, Silver Jan.

vote Silver Jan

(This is my second vote, though if I understand the rules, I’m not locked in since my first vote is still Kelly. Correct?)

[Normal_Phase]

Handshake prevention would be my guess given I’m predisposed to believe her. Even if she’s scum, though, there’s no reason to expect it to be made up – they’d have the sample PM and hypothetically Kelly’s to go off of; introducing something new as a fake would be silly if they have no vanilla cover role on hand; and if they do, they’d probably just use it.