Umm, think I said I wasn’t thinking too clearly at the time, but I’ll correct myself now, since many chose to interpret my posts uncharitably anyway.
What I intended to say was that I personally would not trust any teenager of mine to make good decisions about birth control, STIs, or choosing a good, trustworthy partner. No matter how reliable the teen was. And I say this having been a very mature, reliable teen.
This is because if I had teenagers–which I don’t–they would be in my house until age 18/graduation from high school. I would be supporting them, and likely to send them on to college. And I would be responsible for their health care, and their financial upkeep.
And frankly, I don’t feel like providing any teen of mine with a place to have sex, or with health insurance to get cured of any STIs she picked up, or with the funds for an abortion, or with the financial support she would need to have a child. (I mean the same for boys too, except for the obvious biological differences.)
And while all teens do not automatically make bad parents, statistics bear out that teen parents are much more likely to lack good parenting skills, to lack the ability to financially support themselves, to end up divorced (if they marry) or broken up (if the couple doesn’t marry), etc. This is farily commonly known, though I will provide cites if requested. I don’t think I have anything to apologize for when I conclude, as a result, that my hypothetical teen would likely not make a very good mother or father.
Once they’re graduated from high school and are supporting themselves, they can do whatever they want. While I wouldn’t allow them to have random people shacking up for the night while they visited with me, I wouldn’t have any problem with them having a committed partner and my kid sleeping in the same room.
Maybe you (or your parents) were teen parents, and maybe you were good at it, but these are my opinions about how I would run my household. The opinions in no way bear on anyone’s lives but those of me, my kids, and anyone they might happen to be having sex with. Furthermore, a few self-reported success stories will not change my opinion about the desirability of teenaged sexual activity/pregnancy/parenthood for my potential offspring.
However, I’m pleased to hear that there are some exceptions to the grim statistics. I always knew there were; sorry if, at a time when I admitted I was not expressing myself well, it sounded as though I thought such exceptions were impossible.