S.M. Stirling’s Draka (Draka - Wikipedia) vs. Gordon R. Dickson’s Dorsai (Childe Cycle - Wikipedia): Both groups products of a martial culture, both trained for war from their youth. Assuming unmodified human Draka, and roughly equal numbers and equipment, if a Draka army fought a Dorsai army, who would win?
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
S.M. Stirling’s Draka (Draka - Wikipedia) vs. Gordon R. Dickson’s Dorsai (Childe Cycle - Wikipedia): Both groups products of a martial culture, both trained for war from their youth. Assuming unmodified human Draka, and roughly equal numbers and equipment, if a Draka army fought a Dorsai army, who would win?
[/QUOTE]
Well, this is easy - the Dorsai are the Good Guys ™, whereas the Draka are poorly written racist ubermensch caricatures. Dorsai for the win, unless Stirling’s doing the writing.
[QUOTE=MrDibble]
Well, this is easy - the Dorsai are the Good Guys ™, whereas the Draka are poorly written racist ubermensch caricatures. Dorsai for the win, unless Stirling’s doing the writing.
[/QUOTE]
The Nazis were racist ubermensch scumbags, but were generally acknowledged to be very good at fighting. So I don’t know that your objection to the Draka holds. I don’t diddly about the Dorsai, so I can’t say who would win.
[QUOTE=MrDibble]
Well, this is easy - the Dorsai are the Good Guys ™, whereas the Draka are poorly written racist ubermensch caricatures.
[/QUOTE]
“Poorly written”?! Stirling is a much better writer than Dickson!
[QUOTE=BrainGlutton]
“Poorly written”?! Stirling is a much better writer than Dickson!
[/QUOTE]
Follow the criticism link from the Draka Wiki page and tell me that. The Draka are whatever the AH version of mary-sue-ism is, they are written as unstoppable and therefore dull. Plus the sheer wrongness of them gets my goat - check my location, and it should be no wonder why I wouldn’t be rooting for the Draka of all possible fictional races.
All I know is I read the Childe cycle up to Chantry Guild, I would have thrown Domination at the wall if it wasn’t a library book.
Evil Captor, the Nazis weren’t victorious. Enough said.
[QUOTE=MrDibble]
Draka are whatever the AH version of mary-sue-ism is, they are written as unstoppable and therefore dull.
[/quote]
Not compared to Donal Graeme. Now there’s a Mary Sue!
[QUOTE=MrDibble]
All I know is I read the Childe cycle up to Chantry Guild, I would have thrown Domination at the wall if it wasn’t a library book.
[/QUOTE]
I read Dorsai! and Soldier, Ask Not, and after that I couldn’t get down another spoonful.