Dr. Brian Harold May, lead guitarist of the rock group Queen has been knighted. The King’s Honors list for 2023 cites May as “Dr. Brian Harold May CBE, Musician, Astrophysicist and animal welfare advocate for services to music and to charity.”
May said in response to the honor, "I’m happy and grateful to receive this honor. I will regard the knighthood not so much as a reward, but more as a charge, a commission, for me to continue to fight for justice, to be a voice for those who have no voice. I will endeavor to be worthy, to be that knight in shining armor.”
May received his Ph.D. from Imperial College, London in Astrophysics in 2007. As an activist for animal welfare, May also serves as vice president of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in the U.K.
So what does one call him now: ‘Sir Dr. Brian May’? ‘Dr. Sir Brian May’? Or does the ‘Sir’ now take precedence and he’s ‘Sir Brian May’ without the Dr.?
This is one of those weird language things where I’m almost certain I’ve never encountered this before, yet
(a) I have a strong intuition that “Dr. Sir Brian May” sounds right, “Sir Dr. Brian May” sounds wrong;
(b) This really makes no logical sense.
Is my brain unconsciously following an analogy with something else? I can’t figure it out.
Also, Brian May pisses me off. How can one human being be so fucking awesome? He’s like a young kid’s ridiculous fantasy of “what I want to be when I grow up”.
In the case of a military officer who is also a knight, the appropriate form of address puts the professional military rank first, then the correct manner of address for the individual, then his name. Examples include:
…
Academic
This is also the case with academic ranks and titles, such as ‘Professor’. For example, Patrick Bateson was both a professor[note 2] and a knight bachelor; his correct title would be Professor Sir Patrick Bateson. However, the title of ‘Doctor’ (Dr.) is not used in combination with ‘Sir’, with the knighthood taking precedence. Knighted doctors are addressed as knights, though they may still use any post-nominal letters associated with their degrees.
Well, we can’t let this pass without linking to a strong contender for the greatest live performance in the history of… well, history. I’ve cued it up to just before Hammer To Fall, written by Brian May. It’s hard to get noticed when Freddie’s on stage. It’s pretty funny - Freddie is so charismatic that even when Brian is playing his solo, the camera is still mostly on Freddie playing air guitar with his mic stand.
We Will Rock You at 17:39 is also a May composition.