What kind of dress shirt? Was the bottom square or did it have the “flaps” (I don’t know what else to call them)? The former is acceptable (and intended) to be untucked; I can’t imagine the latter can be acceptable untucked.
Henry on “Shit My Dad Says” was the first person I thought of when I saw the title of the thread. I think it’s a fashion statement for Henry. I think it shows that he’s kind of an idiot.
I didn’t make the connection to the show but my first thought was sounds like a “pretentious douche”. Wants to break the rules and thinks he looks cool, but he doesn’t.
Ha ha ha. That’s Well-Dressed Wednesday where I work. But t-shirt and jeans is the usual dress here. But yeah, it happens a lot with younger guys where it’s an event between casual and formal, like weddings (obviously not the wedding party) or meeting the girlfriend’s parents. Once you hit your late 20s it’s time to start tucking the shirt in, though.
I haven’t seen the show, so it’s a pure shot in the dark, but my guess:
He has a crappy job that he hates, and is required to wear a tie, which he also hates. So, not tucking is his way of following the letter of the dress code, but not the spirit. And since it’s TV, his boss hasn’t called him on it.
That, or I’m reading way too much into some screen caps from a sitcom.
I have only seen douches in SoCal who think that it’s dressy casual, do it. And maybe a few fat guys that think leaving their shirt untucked doesn’t make them look as fat.
You’re reading too much into it. Henry’s a writer for a magazine and he loves his job. And the atmosphere at his office is rather casual and laid-back. I don’t think they even have a dress code, although he sometimes works from home, too. His boss is a bit of a pretentious douche himself, though.
Funny, I was thinking about this subject today, working on a 1970s costume for our next concert. My conclusion is that it’s ok with a “camp” shirt (no tails), but not ok with a tailed shirt.
It’s acceptable if you’re at an event that starts off formal, but which gradually gets less formal as the evening wears on and the alcohol flows. For instance, you wear tucked-in shirt and tie for a wedding, but the shirt comes untucked in the process of dancing at the reception. But getting up in the morning and getting dressed like that just makes you look like a slob. Any scenario where you’d be putting on a shirt and not bothering to tuck it in, you wouldn’t be wearing a tie, either.