I’m bothered by this. I suppose it is possible that dotchan concluded that Cookies was the one to remove partially dead players, but prior to storyteller’s post in this forbidden thread, I was under the impression that the killer of partly dead was still in the game and not Cookies (based on the way Cookies brought up the information). I also think that scum knew that “Good Ash” could remove the partially dead (hence the dead Cookies).
It’s a slim point but I would say this makes dotchan look like scum.
Wow, there really isn’t much of anything to base suspicions on at this point is there? Day Seven was less than two pages!