Exercise: Best results with least amount of time spent?

I’m afraid this is going to sound Wildest Bill-ish.

Changing my diet isn’t working for weight-loss. I’ve come to the conclusion that I’ve got to start excercising. I hate all exercise. Trust me on this. I don’t like sports, I don’t have access to a swimming pool, and I don’t like doing laps anyway. I don’t like aerobic bounce-up-and-down to music exercise and I don’t like gym-class push-ups type exercise.
It’s not fun to ride a bike,
weight lifting I do not like.
I do not like it in a gym,
I do not like it when I swim.
I do not like it here or there,
I do not like it anywhere.
I do not want to exercise,
but I know it’s needed to decrease my size.
I’m gonna work-out, that’s my plan
But I do not like it, Sam-I-Am.
So please, no “You’ll learn to like it when you start getting results” comments. No I won’t. It’s a necessary evil.

Given that, the best I can hope for is getting my exercise over with quickly. I want maximum results for the least time spent per day/week. I figure there are three factors to consider: How often I work out, how ‘hard’ I work out, how long I work out. The length of time per day is my key factor to minimize.

I don’t (and probably won’t) join a health-club, so factor that into your answers, please.

Suggestions would be appreciated.

Fenris

You’re not asking for much, are you? I don’t know if there is an “exercise-free exercise”. Since you seem to be intent on decresing your waist line, elevating your heart rate to your target heart rate at least three times a week is the way to go.

Stationary bicycles, treadmills, stairmasters, etc., have the benefit of being inside air conditioned health clubs (your reluctance to join notwithstanding).

I recommend the YMCA, as they usually have good facilities and worthwhile community support programs, especially for youth. So you can feel good about yourself while getting fit.

And swimming is good, as it is low impact, and it exercises more and differnet muscles than you probably realized that you had. Good calorie burner. Laps or water aerobics, whichever you prefer. If you find laps monotonous, try varying your strokes to emphasize differnet muscle groups.

Alternately, a little power walking, adding wrist and ankle weights, will also burn calories, but I don’t care much for the impact upon the leg joints power walking entails.

But on the subject of diet, what methods are you currently using? Low Carb? High Protien? Balanced but less? Whichever you use, I also recommend cutting sodium intake, coupled with an elevated water intake. In a coupel of weeks, you’ll flush most excess water weight from your fat cells.

I use a combination of weights and swimming; lean muscle mass is a great fat burner. I also watch what I eat (usually), but try not to cut anything entirely out of my diet. Just remember that you probably take in more empty calories than you burn in the form of soft drinks, even diet soft drinks. And fruit juices, even all natural, no-sugars-added ones, aren’t much better than colas where carbs are concerned.

It’s difficult in the extreme to lose weight solely by diet, Hollywierd fad diets to the contrary.

The best, easiest to stick to, exercise plan I have ever found is…

Hours of energentic sex with many changes of positions. For example, missionary is good for abs, butt and arms for the male partner. Find a workout “partner”, get creative with positions and screw your way into shape :smiley:

Lemme rephrase: I don’t want “exercise-free exercise”, I just wanna get it over with quickly. (I was afraid it’d come across this way).

<snip good advice>
**

Balanced, but less. Weight Watchers, essentially, with some added emphasis on carb-avoidance (but not to stupid levels).

**

My best friend has been diag’d with type 2 diabetes, and I tagged along to the classes and picked that up.

Fenris

Here’s something you may want to consider, if you’re really serious.

When I was married we had one, although I forget the name… those cross-country machines. You know what I’m talking about. You glide along with those ski-things and pull the rotating cord in front of you to simulate the pole motion. Buying a used one shouldn’t set you back all that much, and it has the convenience of being right where you are. No travel time to/from the gym, and you can get a good workout in 20-30 minutes.

Well, if time is the driving factor, I’d drop weights and swimming. A good stationary (or even mobile) bicycle jaunt, for about 30 minutes (a 5 minute warmup, and 5 minute cooldown, with a 20 minute exercise period at target heart rate), at least 3 times a week, is probably more suited to you. If you do not know your target heart rate, you can find it here.

Before you begin any exercise routine, always consult a physician. As you seem like a smart person, I’m sure that you have, or at least considered your general health level before commencing an exercise routine. I just have to say those obligatory things, ya know. CYA. CMA.

From my own personal experience: in late ‘98, I was up to 195+ pounds. As I am 5’ 7" tall…well, let’s just say I was rapidly approaching a generally spherical shape. So I joined Bally’s health club and stated exercising in fits and starts, and gradually getting into a regualr routine.

Coupled with a sensible diet, I am now around 160 and holding, with more muscle mass than fat. At 34, that’s probably about as good as I can get w/o dedicating serious amounts of time to an exercise routine or a diet made up entirely of rabbit food.

When you first begin, stretch, stretch, and stretch some more. Your muscles will both hate you and love you for it. Flexibility is a vastly underrated aspect of general fitness, leading to more sprains and strains than are necessary (hence my fondness for more low impact exercises; the Army wasn’t kind to my body).

I wasn’t too thrilled at first (even though I enjoyed exercise in the Army), but as I noticed positive results, and a higher overall energy level, I became (once again) one of the enthusiastically converted.

I know you didn’t wanna hear that. :slight_smile:

Good luck, and keep us posted.

Is there any physical activity that you do like? I currently get most of my exercise from ballroom dance, and it works just fine - it doesn’t feel like “exercising” to me.

ENugent has a good suggestion. Why don’t you take up something involving dancing? Like he said, it doesn’t feel like excercise, it’s fun and you’ll get good results. I’d good for that. This is from a person who detests excercising also.

yes, many changes of positions–and partners.

I found the martial arts to be a very good work out plus you learn a new art/skill, much like dancing. If you learn how to do the moves correctly, you end up concentrating on what your doing instead of how hard you’re working. It’s a great way to get rid of stress, you stretch alot, you can go at your own pace, and sometimes you can learn a bit of history in there. Plus, you get to kick a little butt! :slight_smile:

Oh, and cycling is totally my bag baby, but if it doesn’t work for you, that’s ok. If you just wanna go on a relaxing little stroll through the woods or a park, that may give you some time to think or something. You don’t have to go fast all the time. I also don’t like stationary bikes, but if you put one in front of the TV, you can make a game out of it. Say your watching the Simpsons, everytime Homer says “doh”, sprint for 30 sec. Stuff like that.

And finally, I’d get a partner. It makes things alot more fun and you end up pushing yourself just a bit harder.

Yoga rules.

A: Ex-Tank, you are hot, hot, hot. If you ever turn gay, let me know.

Fenris, deal. If you want to get svelte, not to mention avoid diabetes and lower your cancer and arteriosclerosis risk, you need to do weight training and aerobics a minimum of three times a week. You can do a simple routine in 45 minutes. If you want to know more, e-mail me.

Swim.

Swim slowly for a while, to warm up and stretch. Then swim fast until you cannot swim fast. Then swim slowly until you cannot swim slowly. Then get out of the pool, and go about your business. Morning is best.

After you can swim fast until you run out of time, put on wrist and ankle weights (little ones) and start over.

Tris

“The road to truth is long, and lined the entire way with annoying bastards.” ~ Alexander Jablokov ~

Well, there is a school of thought that says if you learn to breathe correctly, you’ll burn more calories. I dunno if anything scientific substantiates this, but there’s a woman who sells a book about it called “Oxy-cize.” It’s breathing (and stretching,) not exercise. Boring, but if you’re not into bouncing around and stuff, maybe worth looking into? Unless someone who is knowledgable about the technique can debunk it?

Hi, Fenris.

Everyone has his likes and dislikes on exercise, so I’ll throw out a few ideas that might help you find the right one for you.

Walking is what turned me from a totally sedentary person into an active one. (I’ve maintained about a 50 pound weight loss for about 14 years now, excepting time out for 2 babies). I started with walking because it was something I knew how to do, and could do on my own, and wouldn’t be ridiculed for doing — exercise incognito, as it were. (I was paranoid about going into a gym full of people in great shape, and being judged inferior.)

When I got started, I lived about half a mile from where I worked, so I started by walking to work in the morning. When I went home, I made sure that I took a route that took me at least 30 minutes to complete. As I got in better and better shape, my routes got longer and more circuitous. I promised myself that every day I would fit in at least one 30 minute walk, or, if I couldn’t make one 30 minutes, at least three 20 minute walks. As I got more knowledgeable about my fitness needs, I started adding on occasional stretching sessions for flexibility.

When I could, I went for a change of scenery, as you can get sort of bored with the scenery in your neighborhood. Whenever possible, I made my walks functional — purposely “forgetting” a small item, like a bar of soap, when I did my grocery shopping, so I would have a purpose for walking to the store for it (in a long, circuitous route.) If you do this, be sure you take a backpack or fanny pack to carry the item. Carrying stuff for long distances is no fun, and can make your walk miserable. (And please, PLEASE, ignore what Ex Tank said about ankle and wrist weights. Ankle weights should only be used for static strength work, and NEVER as part of an aerobic workout. Wrist weights could only offer terribly marginal benefits as far as your upper body work would go, and their use could throw off your natural arm/leg coordination, thus slowing you down, and reducing the overall aerobic benefit from what you would get if you just walked a little faster without the wrist weights to annoy you.)

Also, don’t be put off by it if your shins burn when you first start a walking program. This is because the shin muscle (the tibialis anterior) is not really used very much in any activity except for walking, and when you start increasing either your speed or frequency of walking, or both, it will start complaining about it. Regular walking will strengthen the muscle, and the problem will go away. (Man, I’m getting carried away with this, aren’t I? The lecturing is sort of a habit — I teach fitness walking at the YMCA for grins.)

Next time you go to your favorite bookstore, try parking a mile or so away and walking over, (or, if you’re going to be carrying a lot of books back without a backpack, park beside the store, walk away from the store for at least 15 minutes, and then walk back to the store, giving you 30 minutes of walking before you get your reward.) Walk at a pace where you could comfortably carry on a conversation with someone without having to gasp for breath, but couldn’t sing a song comfortably.

OK, maybe you just don’t like walking, or want more variety, and want to consider some home exercise equipment. A lot of the home exercise equipment is cheap and junky. To keep costs down, it is frequently made of lighter weight materials, and is less stable and able to withstand frequent use. Even though you say you don’t want to join a gym, I would suggest you try joining one for just a month, just so you can have the opportunity to try out some really good gym-grade exercise equipment so you can see what type you like before investing in any home equipment. Once you’ve decided what type you like (or at least can live with), you’ll have a better idea of what features you think your home equipment should have, and what items should not be skimped on. (I like the rowing machine. It has the advantage of throwing in a little upper body work, which was lacking in walking. YMMV, though.)

Another option is exercise tapes. Even if you aren’t the dancey aerobics type, you may enjoy Tae-bo or cardio-kickboxing. (I love cardio kickboxing. I’m addicted to my Y’s Contact kickboxing class, where we get to glove up, and kick and punch a heavy bag.) Your local video store should have some Tae-bo tapes in stock, so you can try renting one first to try it out before buying. You can also check out ESPN2 and some other cable/satellite channels for exercise classes they offer, such as Crunch Fitness. You’re better off taping these, and playing them back later, so you can fast-forward past the commercials, however.

Think about this as something you are doing for yourself because you deserve to be taken care of, not something you have to do to fit society’s view of how you should look. I think of exercise as my immunization against depression. I have a huge family history of depression, and am the only one in my immediate family NOT being treated for it currently, which I attribute it to regular exercise. I really feel a huge difference in my mood when I’m forced to miss more than a few days in a row due injuries or job stress.

Good luck!

One of the problems with swimming as calorie-burning is that the cool water prevents you from overheating and thus you don’t burn calories trying to cool down.

You can check here to see a handy-dandy calories burned comparison. According to that, swimming at 50 yds/minute (which was close to my top speed when swimming breaststroke, as I recall), is still about 100 calories short of my slow to medium jog pace (5.5 mi./hr) for a half hour. For some reason, it’s also a lot easier for me to work out at the breathing-hard 85% heart rate level when running than when I do any other sort of excercise. Some drawbacks are the lack of upper body strength-building and the high-impact workout (but on the other hand, weight-bearing excercise increases bone density). Get a really good pair of shoes–I recommend Reebok DMX 10 for thier incredible cushioning powers if you’re running on concrete–and you’re good to go. Add in a MP3 player and the run becomes much more entertaining, but even without it there’s something very basic and satisfying about just stepping out the door and “going for a run” when everybody else is spinning and Tae-boing and ellipticaling and such.

“NordicTrack” is the brand name. Conveniently located at http://www.nordictrack.com. They give a good work out, but not as good as the real thing. On the other hand, they don’t require snow.

-ellis

Liposuction.

ExTank: Thanks for the advice. The stationary bike thing looks like the way I’m considering (my folks have a relatively new one they don’t want). The heart rate thing sounds like a very good idea.

ENugent: Nope. Give my druthers, I’d be sitting on my butt all day. I don’t like dancing either. I appreciate the suggestion, though

Cyrider: The stationary bike while watching the Simpsons sounds like the perfect workout!

Goboy: I’m never gonna be svelt given my build (I’m far to stocky to be described as svelt) :D. Anyway 45 minutes 3 times a week isn’t bad. I’ll e-mail you.

Trisk: There’s no place nearby to swim.

Cranky: Wasn’t that a spin-off from the guys who said you didn’t need food, just air? (Breath-itarians or something?)

YWalker: I like the “park far away from someplace you’re going so you have to walk for a while to get there and back” idea a lot. The problem with where I live is that I’m in the middle of nowhere and there’s no place to walk to. But I can still do the first suggestion.

Fenris

Steam room, sauna and a lite beer at the bar (make sure it’s real cold so you burn up an additional calorie just slammin’ it down). Wall Street swears by this exercise regime.