Rod Stewart. He is MILES away from classically handsome, but I think he is just plain sexy.
Oh, and I love his voice, too . 
WARNING: the spoiler contains info on “Close My Eyes” and “Angels and Insects”
Interesting that both films feature brother-sister incest and full-frontals on the guys playing the brothers.
If you think he’s sexy, I believe you are supposed to tell him so. 
ROTFLMFAO!
Thank you, I needed that.
Marla Sokoloff is considered ugly in my circle of friends. I think she’s quite cute and even hot.
Also, I really am attracted toSchuyler Fisk. Jolie…eh, not so much.
Jeez your friends are insane!! There is nothing ugly about Marla Sokoloff.
Me too, especially her character in Orange County.
Maybe it’s that once you’ve busted up one taboo, the rest don’t seem quite so heinous! “Close My Eyes” is sexier, IMO, but “Angels and Insects” is much the weirder movie by a long shot.
And Clive is much hotter than that ruddy faced slab of underdone bacon who played the brother in A&I–AND he has a bigger penis, too! Not that I’m measuring, and not that it makes any difference at all, guys, it’s not the size that counts and all that reassuring stuff… 
Jack Black. Although it doesn’t seem odd to me personally. If I wasn’t able to find appeal in large guys, I would never have hooked up with Mr. Rilch.
Um, both of these guys are considered Hollywood hunks. I don’t think they qualify.
Also Clea Duvall…not at all a “regular” hotty such as they slather onto Maxim each month, but I find her oddly sexy. Very sexy.
Oh yeah! She’s on my list. Absolutely beautiful, she is.
Why do I think this is getting to be a free pass for those who admire the men, but for those who are into women, it’s turning into a double-dare-gross-out contest?
Every female but Bea Arthur so far gets the “she’s not really ugly” comeback. Are we really waiting for someone to say, “I have the hots for an irredeemably skank-ass chyk?” Which will accomplish what?