Well don’t get me wrong. i might’ve said it was my favorite at some time recently, and it’s probably the catchiest. But I’m looking for the soulful vocals with the more open melody.
I have to go with Joy to the World. But I like many others.
Liar.
^ Baker’s probably telling the truth. 
Pieces of April written by Dave Loggins.
Mama Told Me Not to Come was written by Randy Newman for Eric Burdon.
Eli’s Coming was written by Laura Nyro.
Shambala.
No one has mentioned Black & White. That’s a good one.
Yes, the beat on that one is fantastic and the background details.
Good timing. Yesterday my brother texted me a YouTube link to Sugarloaf - Green Eyed Lady (not sure why) so the 1970 hit I texted in reply was TDN - Celebrate 
Back in college we used to sing Celebrate but with a different word. (Starts with M.)
Melebrate??? lol
Mama Told Me.
No, masticate; it was lunch time and they were in the cafeteria.
Masticate, masticate
Chew to the music
Favorite to listen to: Shambala
Favorite to sing along with at the top of my lungs when it played on the car radio: Joy to the World
So many good ones, but I have to go with, “Eli’s Coming” . . .this particular live version. What I wouldn’t give for a high-quality mix from the soundboard.
Hey! That’s not fair! You’re telling us which song to choose! What if I don’t particularly like “One”? 
Me too.
There are 5-6 which I hadn’t heard in a long time but liked… and Many here that I’d never heard at all.
Thank You!
Definitely Shambala.